GE Multilin Power Swing Blocking and Out-of-Step Protection (ANSI 68 and 78): Power System Stability, Impedance Trajectories, Settings and Testing

Table Of Contents
  1. 1. Introduction
  2. 2. What Is a Power Swing?
  3. 3. Stable and Unstable Power Swings
  4. 4. Why Distance Protection Can Operate During a Power Swing
  5. 5. The Electrical Centre of a Power Swing
  6. 6. Power Swing Impedance Trajectory
  7. 7. Power Swing Blocking – ANSI 68
  8. 8. Out-of-Step Protection – ANSI 78
  9. 9. Difference Between ANSI 68 and ANSI 78
  10. 10. Power Swing Detection Methods
  11. 11. Settings and Engineering Considerations
  12. 12. Practical Engineering Example
  13. 13. GE Multilin Relays and Power Swing Applications
  14. 14. Generic EnerVista Configuration Workflow
  15. 15. Testing and Commissioning
  16. 16. Common Problems and Troubleshooting
  17. 17. Practical Commissioning Checklist
  18. 18. Important Engineering Recommendations
  19. 19. Training on GE Multilin Protection Relays by Elec-Engg
  20. 20. Frequently Asked Questions
  21. 21. Conclusion

1. Introduction

Power swings are changes in the relative rotor angles and power transfer between synchronous generators or interconnected areas of an electrical network. They commonly occur following major system disturbances, such as transmission-line faults, generator outages, switching operations or sudden changes in generation and load.

During a power swing, the apparent impedance measured by a distance protection relay can move across its impedance characteristics even though no short circuit exists at the measurement location.

This creates an important protection challenge: a distance relay may interpret a stable power swing as a fault and issue an unnecessary trip.

GE Multilin distance and generator protection platforms may provide power swing detection, power swing blocking (PSB) and out-of-step protection functions, depending on the exact model, firmware and configuration.

This article explains the operating principles of power swing detection, impedance trajectories, stable and unstable swings, ANSI 68 blocking, ANSI 78 out-of-step protection, engineering settings and practical testing.

2. What Is a Power Swing?

A power swing is an oscillation in the relative electrical angles of synchronous machines or interconnected power-system areas.

Under normal operating conditions, generators connected to the same synchronous network operate at a stable relationship between their rotor angles.

When a significant disturbance occurs, the electrical power transferred between generators and network areas changes. The rotor angles begin to oscillate as the machines respond dynamically.

Power swings can be classified into two main categories:

  • Stable power swings.
  • Unstable power swings.

2.1 Causes of power swings

Common causes include:

  • Three-phase transmission-line faults.
  • Single-phase-to-ground faults followed by successful clearing.
  • Loss of a major transmission circuit.
  • Generator tripping.
  • Sudden loss of a large load.
  • Large generation changes.
  • Switching of major transmission corridors.
  • Fault clearing with delayed breaker operation.
  • Weak interconnections between power-system areas.

2.2 Why power swings matter to protection engineers

During a power swing, voltage and current magnitudes and their phase relationships change continuously.

The apparent impedance seen by a distance relay is:

[
Z_{app}=\frac{V}{I}
]

As the system operating point changes, the apparent impedance may enter one or more distance protection zones.

Without suitable power swing discrimination, the distance protection may trip a healthy transmission line during a stable swing.

3. Stable and Unstable Power Swings

Understanding the difference between stable and unstable swings is fundamental to protection design.

3.1 Stable power swing

A stable power swing occurs when synchronous machines remain in synchronism following a disturbance.

The rotor angles oscillate but eventually settle toward a stable operating condition.

During a stable swing, the distance protection system may need to block selected distance elements to prevent unnecessary tripping.

3.2 Unstable power swing

An unstable power swing occurs when the system cannot maintain synchronism.

The relative rotor angle continues to increase, and the interconnected machines may lose synchronism.

This condition may result in:

  • Large power oscillations.
  • Severe voltage variations.
  • Increased equipment stress.
  • Separation of synchronous areas.
  • System instability.
  • Potential cascading outages.

An out-of-step protection scheme may be required to separate the system at predetermined locations and prevent uncontrolled disturbances.

3.3 Comparison

CharacteristicStable swingUnstable swing
SynchronismMaintainedLost or expected to be lost
Rotor angleOscillates and recoversContinues to diverge
System responseReturns toward stabilityRequires corrective action
Distance protectionMay require blockingMay require controlled tripping
Protection objectiveAvoid unnecessary tripsPrevent uncontrolled system separation

4. Why Distance Protection Can Operate During a Power Swing

Distance protection measures the apparent impedance between the relay location and the electrical system.

For a simplified single-phase representation:

[
Z_{app}=\frac{V}{I}
]

During a fault, current increases and voltage generally decreases, causing the measured impedance to move toward the fault impedance.

During a power swing, however, the apparent impedance can also move significantly because the voltage and current phasors change as the power transfer angle changes.

The relay may therefore see an impedance trajectory that enters its Zone 1, Zone 2 or Zone 3 characteristics.

This is why power swing blocking is particularly important for long transmission lines and heavily interconnected systems.

5. The Electrical Centre of a Power Swing

The electrical centre is an important concept in power swing analysis.

In a simplified two-source equivalent system, the electrical centre is the location where the voltage magnitude may become very low during a severe power swing.

The apparent impedance trajectory can pass through this region as the angle between the equivalent sources changes.

The location of the electrical centre depends on:

  • Equivalent source impedances.
  • Generator and network reactances.
  • Transmission-line impedance.
  • System operating conditions.
  • Network configuration.

Distance relay characteristics should be reviewed in relation to the expected swing trajectory and electrical-centre location.

6. Power Swing Impedance Trajectory

Power swing detection commonly uses the rate of change of measured impedance.

During a power swing, the impedance trajectory generally moves more slowly than it does during a short-circuit fault.

A power swing detection scheme can use this difference to distinguish between a gradual impedance movement and a rapid fault-related impedance change.

6.1 Impedance plane

The impedance plane contains:

  • Resistance on the horizontal axis.
  • Reactance on the vertical axis.

Distance relay characteristics are represented on this plane.

The power swing trajectory may cross different impedance regions as the relative voltage angle changes.

6.2 Impedance movement

A typical detection scheme monitors the time taken for apparent impedance to move between two defined impedance boundaries.

If the movement is sufficiently slow, the relay may identify a power swing.

If the impedance movement is rapid, the condition may be classified as a fault rather than a power swing.

The exact detection algorithm and characteristic are manufacturer-dependent.

7. Power Swing Blocking – ANSI 68

ANSI device number 68 is associated with blocking or other control functions related to power swings, depending on the protection scheme and implementation.

Power swing blocking prevents selected distance protection elements from operating during a detected power swing.

The purpose is to maintain line protection security during stable electromechanical oscillations.

7.1 Basic operating principle

A simplified power swing blocking sequence is:

  1. The relay continuously measures voltage and current.
  2. It calculates the apparent impedance.
  3. The impedance enters the configured detection region.
  4. The relay monitors the movement of the impedance trajectory.
  5. The movement meets the power swing detection criteria.
  6. The relay identifies a power swing.
  7. Selected distance elements are blocked.
  8. The blocking condition is removed when the swing has cleared or the configured release criteria are met.

The exact sequence depends on the relay design.

7.2 Which protection elements may be blocked?

Depending on the protection philosophy and relay implementation, power swing blocking may affect:

  • Phase distance elements.
  • Selected distance zones.
  • Communication-assisted distance schemes.
  • Other protection logic associated with the distance function.

Blocking must be engineered carefully. It should not disable essential fault protection or prevent the relay from clearing a genuine fault during a power swing.

7.3 Fault during a power swing

A short circuit can occur while a power swing is already in progress.

The protection scheme must distinguish this condition from the swing itself and provide a suitable fault-clearing response.

Some relays provide dedicated power swing detection and fault-during-swing logic. The exact capabilities must be verified for the installed model.

8. Out-of-Step Protection – ANSI 78

ANSI 78 is associated with out-of-step or pole-slipping protection.

Unlike power swing blocking, which aims to prevent unnecessary distance trips during stable swings, out-of-step protection identifies unstable operating conditions and may initiate controlled system separation.

8.1 Purpose of out-of-step protection

The purpose is to separate an unstable generator or system area at an appropriate location before uncontrolled cascading outages occur.

The protection scheme must consider:

  • Generator stability.
  • Transmission network configuration.
  • System separation requirements.
  • Load-generation balance.
  • Critical clearing times.
  • Breaker operating times.
  • System restoration strategy.

8.2 Generator out-of-step protection

A generator may lose synchronism with the electrical network following a severe disturbance.

The apparent impedance measured at the generator terminals can move through configured out-of-step characteristics.

Depending on the protection design, the relay may detect the pole-slipping condition and initiate generator tripping.

8.3 Transmission-system out-of-step protection

In transmission networks, out-of-step protection may be used to separate two unstable electrical areas at designated locations.

The separation point should be selected through system stability studies rather than simply choosing the location where a relay first detects an impedance movement.

9. Difference Between ANSI 68 and ANSI 78

FunctionANSI 68ANSI 78
Main purposePower swing-related blocking or controlOut-of-step or pole-slip protection
Typical applicationDistance protection securityGenerator and system stability protection
Stable swingUsually blocks selected distance elementsNormally does not require separation
Unstable swingMay detect or supervise the conditionMay initiate controlled tripping
Engineering objectivePrevent unwanted operationSeparate unstable system sections

The exact ANSI designation and function naming should be checked against the applicable relay documentation and project protection philosophy.

10. Power Swing Detection Methods

Different relay platforms may use different methods to identify power swings.

10.1 Dual-blinder method

A common approach uses two impedance boundaries, often called blinders.

The relay measures the time required for the impedance trajectory to move between the boundaries.

A slow movement may indicate a power swing.

A rapid movement may indicate a fault.

The precise implementation, geometry and timing criteria depend on the manufacturer.

10.2 Concentric characteristic method

Some schemes use impedance characteristics arranged around a central operating region.

The relay evaluates the movement and timing of the impedance trajectory across these boundaries.

10.3 Rate-of-change detection

A power swing can also be identified using the rate of change of impedance or related electrical quantities.

The general concept is:

[
\frac{\Delta Z}{\Delta t}
]

A relatively slow impedance movement can be characteristic of a power swing, while a rapid movement may indicate a fault.

This expression describes the concept; it is not a universal relay operating equation.

11. Settings and Engineering Considerations

Power swing blocking and out-of-step protection settings must be based on system studies.

Important considerations include:

  • Maximum power transfer.
  • System source impedance.
  • Transmission-line impedance.
  • Generator transient and subtransient reactances.
  • Critical clearing time.
  • Expected swing frequency.
  • Distance protection reach.
  • Electrical-centre location.
  • Stable and unstable swing trajectories.
  • Breaker operating time.
  • Communication-assisted protection schemes.

11.1 Blinder or impedance boundary settings

Where a relay uses blinders, their positions must be selected so that:

  • Normal load impedance remains outside the operating region.
  • Expected stable swings can be detected.
  • Fault conditions remain distinguishable.
  • The detection scheme has adequate operating time.
  • The scheme coordinates with distance protection.

11.2 Power swing detection timer

The detection timer or transit time must distinguish between fault-related impedance movement and power-swing movement.

An excessively short setting may result in incorrect classification.

An excessively long setting may delay detection and blocking.

The final setting must follow the relay manufacturer’s recommendations and system study.

11.3 Load encroachment coordination

Load encroachment and power swing protection are related but different functions.

Load encroachment prevents distance protection from operating incorrectly under heavy load conditions.

Power swing blocking identifies dynamic impedance movement caused by system oscillations.

Both functions should be reviewed together during distance protection engineering.

12. Practical Engineering Example

Consider a hypothetical 400 kV transmission corridor connecting two major power-system areas.

Assume the system experiences a severe three-phase fault on a parallel transmission circuit.

After the fault is cleared:

  • Power transfer through the remaining corridor increases.
  • Generator rotor angles begin to oscillate.
  • Voltage and current phasors change.
  • The apparent impedance at the distance relay moves across the R-X plane.

Without power swing blocking, a distance element may interpret the impedance trajectory as a fault and trip the remaining healthy transmission circuit.

A properly engineered scheme may identify the slow impedance movement as a stable power swing and block selected distance elements.

If the system loses synchronism, an appropriate out-of-step scheme may initiate controlled separation at a location selected by the stability study.

This example illustrates the protection philosophy. Actual relay settings cannot be determined from voltage level alone.

13. GE Multilin Relays and Power Swing Applications

GE Multilin offers several protection platforms used in transmission and generator applications.

Potential platforms to review include:

13.1 GE Multilin D60

The D60 line distance protection system is relevant to transmission-line protection applications.

When engineering power swing blocking or out-of-step-related functions, confirm the available features and their exact implementation in the installed D60 model and firmware.

13.2 GE Multilin D30

The D30 distance protection platform may be used in line protection schemes.

Its power swing detection and blocking capabilities must be verified against the relevant product documentation.

13.3 GE Multilin G60

The G60 generator protection system may be relevant to generator stability and out-of-step protection applications, depending on its configuration and enabled functions.

13.4 GE Multilin G30

The G30 generator protection platform should also be reviewed when designing generator protection schemes involving loss of synchronism.

13.5 Model-specific engineering

Do not assume that the D60, D30, G60 and G30 have identical:

  • Power swing detection algorithms.
  • Impedance characteristics.
  • Blinder settings.
  • Blocking logic.
  • Out-of-step operating characteristics.
  • Timer parameters.
  • Fault-during-swing logic.

Always consult the exact relay manual and firmware documentation.

14. Generic EnerVista Configuration Workflow

The following workflow describes the general engineering process. Actual software menus and setting names vary by model and software version.

Step 1: Identify the relay

Record:

  • Relay model.
  • Product order code.
  • Firmware revision.
  • Hardware configuration.
  • Available protection functions.

Step 2: Review the distance protection configuration

Check:

  • CT ratios.
  • VT ratios.
  • Line impedance.
  • Positive-sequence impedance.
  • Zero-sequence impedance.
  • Distance zone reaches.
  • Mho or quadrilateral characteristics.
  • Load encroachment settings.

Step 3: Review power swing protection availability

Confirm whether the installed relay supports the required power swing detection, blocking or out-of-step functions.

Step 4: Obtain system study data

Collect:

  • Stable swing trajectories.
  • Unstable swing trajectories.
  • Maximum load impedance.
  • Fault impedance information.
  • Critical clearing time.
  • System operating scenarios.
  • Generator and network parameters.

Step 5: Enter approved settings

Configure the available impedance boundaries, timing parameters and blocking logic according to the approved study.

Step 6: Configure protection logic

Determine which distance zones or elements should be blocked and which functions must remain available during a power swing.

Step 7: Verify the trip and blocking matrix

Confirm the relationship between:

  • Power swing detection.
  • Distance protection.
  • Communication-assisted schemes.
  • Out-of-step protection.
  • Breaker trip outputs.
  • Alarm and event recording.

Step 8: Save and document

Save the final settings, verify the relay configuration and retain a controlled backup.

15. Testing and Commissioning

Power swing protection testing requires suitable test equipment and a clearly defined test plan.

The test should verify both security during stable swings and correct response to simulated unstable conditions.

15.1 Preparation

Before testing:

  • Review the approved settings.
  • Obtain the relay manual.
  • Identify the applicable protection logic.
  • Review the system stability study.
  • Confirm CT and VT configurations.
  • Isolate trip outputs as required by the approved test procedure.

15.2 Impedance trajectory testing

Use a suitable relay test set capable of generating controlled voltage and current signals.

Simulate impedance movement through the relevant R-X plane regions.

Verify:

  • Detection boundary entry.
  • Detection boundary exit.
  • Transit-time measurement.
  • Power swing identification.
  • Blocking initiation.
  • Blocking release.

15.3 Stable power swing simulation

Simulate a trajectory representing a stable power swing.

Verify that the relay identifies the condition and blocks the selected distance elements as designed.

15.4 Unstable power swing simulation

Where the relay supports out-of-step protection, simulate the specified unstable trajectory.

Verify:

  • Out-of-step detection.
  • Required operating time.
  • Trip logic.
  • Breaker output.
  • Event recording.

15.5 Fault during power swing

This is an important security and dependability test.

Simulate a power swing condition followed by a fault.

Verify that the protection scheme responds according to its design and does not unnecessarily block essential fault protection.

15.6 Distance protection coordination

Test the interaction between power swing blocking and:

  • Zone 1.
  • Zone 2.
  • Zone 3.
  • Communication-assisted tripping.
  • Permissive or blocking schemes, where applicable.

15.7 Final trip circuit verification

Verify the complete output chain, including trip relays, breaker trip coils, auxiliary contacts and event recording.

16. Common Problems and Troubleshooting

Problem 1: Distance relay trips during a stable power swing

Possible causes:

  • Power swing blocking not enabled.
  • Incorrect detection settings.
  • Incorrect impedance boundaries.
  • Incorrect distance zone blocking logic.
  • Power swing detection not operating as expected.

Recommended action: Review the oscillography, impedance trajectory and power swing logic.

Problem 2: Power swing blocking operates during a fault

Possible causes:

  • Incorrect impedance transit-time settings.
  • Inadequate fault discrimination.
  • Incorrect characteristic geometry.
  • Incorrect test or measurement configuration.

Recommended action: Review the relay’s fault-during-swing logic and verify the detection settings against the manufacturer’s recommendations.

Problem 3: Power swing blocking does not release

Possible causes:

  • Incorrect reset conditions.
  • Persistent impedance inside the blocking region.
  • Incorrect timer configuration.
  • Incorrect logic interlocking.

Recommended action: Review the release logic and event records.

Problem 4: Out-of-step protection fails to operate

Possible causes:

  • Function disabled.
  • Incorrect impedance characteristics.
  • Incorrect CT/VT scaling.
  • Incorrect trip logic.
  • Test trajectory does not represent the configured operating condition.

Recommended action: Verify the function configuration, impedance calculations and test-set injection quantities.

Problem 5: Unwanted operation during heavy loading

Possible causes:

  • Load encroachment not properly configured.
  • Distance zone reach too large.
  • Power swing and load protection not coordinated.
  • Incorrect system operating assumptions.

Recommended action: Review maximum load impedance and the coordination of distance, load encroachment and power swing functions.

17. Practical Commissioning Checklist

  • Exact GE Multilin relay model identified.
  • Firmware revision recorded.
  • Power swing function availability confirmed.
  • Distance protection settings verified.
  • CT and VT ratios checked.
  • Line impedance data verified.
  • System stability study reviewed.
  • Stable swing trajectories considered.
  • Unstable swing trajectories considered.
  • Load encroachment coordination reviewed.
  • Power swing detection boundaries verified.
  • Detection timers checked.
  • Distance zone blocking logic tested.
  • Fault-during-swing response tested.
  • Out-of-step trip logic tested, where applicable.
  • Breaker trip outputs verified.
  • Event records and oscillography checked.
  • Final settings backed up.
  • Commissioning report completed.

18. Important Engineering Recommendations

  1. Do not treat every impedance movement as a short circuit.
  2. Use system stability studies to establish stable and unstable swing trajectories.
  3. Coordinate power swing blocking with distance protection and load encroachment.
  4. Confirm which distance zones should be blocked.
  5. Ensure genuine faults can still be cleared during a power swing.
  6. Apply out-of-step protection only according to an approved system separation philosophy.
  7. Check CT and VT scaling carefully.
  8. Test both stable and unstable trajectories.
  9. Verify the complete trip and blocking logic.
  10. Use the exact GE Multilin model and firmware documentation when engineering settings.

19. Training on GE Multilin Protection Relays by Elec-Engg

Power swing blocking and out-of-step protection require a combination of distance protection knowledge, power-system stability analysis, impedance measurement and practical relay testing.

Elec-Engg provides practical technical training by Dr Saeed Roostaee (Electrical Engineering) for protection, commissioning, operation and maintenance engineers.

Relevant training subjects include:

  • GE Multilin distance protection.
  • ANSI 21 impedance protection.
  • Power swing blocking and out-of-step protection.
  • Stable and unstable power swings.
  • Mho and quadrilateral distance characteristics.
  • Load encroachment.
  • Communication-assisted distance protection.
  • GE Multilin EnerVista configuration.
  • Secondary injection and protection testing.
  • Practical fault and disturbance analysis.

Training delivery options include:

  • Pre-recorded technical video courses.
  • Structured self-paced training.
  • Live online technical training.
  • Face-to-face training.
  • Customized in-house training for utilities and industrial companies.

The focus is on practical engineering, configuration, protection coordination, testing and troubleshooting.

Website: https://elec-engg.com/

Training enquiries: https://elec-engg.com/contact/

20. Frequently Asked Questions

What is power swing blocking?

Power swing blocking identifies a power-system oscillation and blocks selected distance protection elements to prevent unnecessary tripping during a stable swing.

What is out-of-step protection?

Out-of-step protection detects unstable operation or loss of synchronism and may initiate controlled tripping to separate unstable parts of the electrical network.

What is the difference between a stable and unstable power swing?

During a stable swing, generators maintain synchronism and the oscillation eventually settles. During an unstable swing, the relative rotor angle continues to diverge and synchronism is lost.

Why can a distance relay operate during a power swing?

The apparent impedance measured by the relay changes as system voltage and current phasors move during the oscillation. The impedance trajectory may enter a distance protection zone even without a short circuit.

What is a blinder in power swing protection?

A blinder is an impedance boundary used in some power swing detection schemes. The relay monitors the movement of apparent impedance across boundaries to distinguish a power swing from a fault.

Can a fault occur during a power swing?

Yes. A genuine short circuit can occur while the system is oscillating. Protection must be designed to detect and clear such faults without allowing power swing blocking to compromise essential fault protection.

Which GE Multilin relays can be used for power swing protection?

D60, D30, G60 and G30 are relevant platforms to investigate for distance and generator stability applications. Exact power swing and out-of-step capabilities must be verified for the installed model and firmware.

Is power swing blocking the same as out-of-step protection?

No. Power swing blocking generally prevents unwanted distance relay operation during stable swings. Out-of-step protection detects unstable conditions and may initiate controlled separation.

How is power swing blocking tested?

It can be tested by injecting controlled voltage and current signals that simulate impedance movement through the R-X plane. Testing should verify detection, blocking, release and fault-during-swing behaviour.

21. Conclusion

Power swing blocking and out-of-step protection are important functions in modern transmission and generator protection schemes.

Power swing blocking helps prevent unnecessary distance relay operation during stable oscillations, while out-of-step protection supports controlled separation when synchronism cannot be maintained.

Correct engineering requires a detailed understanding of impedance trajectories, generator dynamics, network stability, distance protection characteristics and breaker operation.

For GE Multilin systems, the exact implementation must be verified against the installed relay model, firmware and approved protection philosophy.

Proper configuration and testing help improve protection security, dependability and overall power-system stability.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top