- 1. Introduction
- 2. What Are Protection Relay Settings?
- 3. Understanding Protection Pickup Current
- 4. Time Overcurrent Protection – ANSI 51
- 5. Instantaneous Overcurrent Protection – ANSI 50
- 6. Earth Fault Protection Settings – ANSI 50N and 51N
- 7. Directional Overcurrent Protection – ANSI 67
- 8. Time-Current Coordination
- 9. Understanding Time-Current Characteristic Curves
- 10. Transformer Protection Settings
- 11. Motor Protection Settings
- 12. Generator Protection Settings
- 13. Breaker Failure Protection – ANSI 50BF
- 14. Protection Logic and Output Configuration
- 15. Practical Example: Feeder Overcurrent Setting Study
- 16. Implementing Settings Using EnerVista
- 17. Testing Protection Relay Settings
- 18. Common Protection Setting Mistakes
- 19. Protection Setting Documentation and Management
- 20. Conclusion
- 21. Training on GE Multilin Protection Relays by Elec-Engg
1. Introduction
Protection relay settings determine how a protection system responds to abnormal operating conditions and electrical faults. Correct settings are essential for protecting transformers, generators, motors, feeders, transmission lines, and other power system equipment.
GE Multilin numerical protection relays provide a wide range of configurable protection functions. Depending on the relay model, these may include phase overcurrent, earth fault, directional overcurrent, differential, distance, thermal overload, voltage, frequency, and breaker failure protection.
However, installing a numerical relay and enabling its protection functions are not sufficient to guarantee reliable protection. Each function must be configured using appropriate engineering calculations, system data, equipment characteristics, and coordination requirements.
This article explains the principles of GE Multilin protection relay settings, including pickup current, operating time, time-current characteristics, instantaneous protection, earth fault settings, coordination, and practical commissioning considerations.
The examples are intended to explain the engineering principles. Final settings must be calculated and approved for the actual power system and the specific relay model.
2. What Are Protection Relay Settings?
Protection relay settings are parameters that define the operating behavior of a protection function.
For an overcurrent protection element, for example, settings may include:
- Protection function enable or disable.
- Pickup current.
- Operating time.
- Time-current curve.
- Time multiplier or time dial.
- Instantaneous pickup.
- Reset characteristic.
- Directional supervision.
- Logic inputs.
- Output assignments.
Other protection functions require different parameters.
For example, transformer differential protection may require transformer rating, winding voltage, vector group, CT information, differential pickup, restraint characteristics, and harmonic restraint settings.
The available parameters depend on the relay model and its implemented protection functions.
3. Understanding Protection Pickup Current
Pickup current is the current level at which a protection element detects that its operating threshold has been reached.
For phase overcurrent protection, the pickup setting must be high enough to avoid unwanted operation during permissible loading, but sufficiently low to detect the minimum fault current within the required protection zone.
3.1 Load Current and Pickup Selection
Consider a feeder with the following data:
- Nominal voltage: 11 kV.
- Maximum expected load: 400 A.
- CT ratio: 600/1 A.
The relay receives the secondary current corresponding to the primary load current.
For a 600/1 A CT:
400 A primary = 0.667 A secondary.
The phase overcurrent pickup must be selected with consideration of:
- Maximum expected load.
- Permissible overload.
- Transformer or motor starting current, where relevant.
- Minimum fault current.
- Downstream protection.
- Upstream protection.
- Required sensitivity.
- Relay measurement and setting ranges.
A pickup setting should not be selected simply by applying an arbitrary percentage above the load current.
3.2 Primary and Secondary Pickup Values
Some engineering documents express pickup values in primary amperes, while relay setting interfaces may use secondary amperes, per-unit quantities, or multiples of rated current.
The engineer must understand the relay’s setting convention.
Example:
- CT ratio: 600/1 A.
- Required primary pickup: 480 A.
The corresponding secondary current is:
Isecondary = 480 / 600 = 0.8 A
If the relay setting is expressed in secondary amperes, the equivalent pickup is 0.8 A, subject to the relay’s actual setting definition and scaling.
Always confirm whether a displayed setting represents primary current, secondary current, or a multiple of the relay’s rated input.
4. Time Overcurrent Protection – ANSI 51
Time overcurrent protection operates when the measured current exceeds a configured pickup threshold for a period determined by its operating characteristic.
The ANSI device number 51 is commonly used for AC time overcurrent protection.
The relay may provide several time-current curve characteristics, depending on the model.
Typical curve families include:
- Standard inverse.
- Very inverse.
- Extremely inverse.
- Long-time inverse.
- Definite time.
- Other manufacturer-specific characteristics.
The exact available curves must be checked in the applicable GE Multilin relay manual.
4.1 Inverse-Time Characteristics
An inverse-time protection element generally operates faster as the fault current increases.
This is useful in distribution networks because high-current faults can be cleared quickly, while lower fault currents may require longer operating times to maintain coordination.
A commonly used IEC inverse-time equation is:
[
t = TMS \times \frac{k}{(I/I_s)^\alpha – 1}
]
Where:
- (t) = operating time.
- (TMS) = time multiplier setting.
- (I) = measured current.
- (I_s) = pickup current.
- (k) and (\alpha) = curve constants.
The constants depend on the selected curve.
This equation illustrates the IEC curve family. Do not assume that every GE Multilin relay implements every IEC curve or uses the same equation for all available characteristics. Consult the model-specific documentation.
4.2 Definite-Time Overcurrent
In definite-time overcurrent protection, the relay operates after a configured delay once current exceeds the pickup threshold.
For example:
- Pickup: 400 A.
- Time delay: 0.5 seconds.
If the current exceeds the pickup threshold and the element remains in its operating state for the configured delay, the protection element operates, subject to its logic and supervision.
Definite-time protection can be useful where a fixed time grading strategy is required.
5. Instantaneous Overcurrent Protection – ANSI 50
Instantaneous overcurrent protection operates without an intentional inverse-time delay once the current exceeds its configured threshold.
The ANSI device number 50 identifies instantaneous overcurrent protection.
It is commonly used for high-current faults within a defined protection zone.
5.1 Selecting Instantaneous Pickup
The instantaneous pickup must be selected with consideration of:
- Maximum external fault current.
- Minimum internal fault current.
- Feeder length.
- Transformer impedance.
- Downstream equipment.
- CT performance.
- Protection coordination.
- Required operating speed.
If the pickup is too low, the relay may operate for faults outside its intended zone.
If the pickup is too high, it may fail to detect some faults within the intended zone.
5.2 Practical Example
Consider a feeder where:
- Maximum load current is 400 A.
- CT ratio is 600/1 A.
- The calculated maximum external fault current is 5 kA.
- The minimum internal fault current is 2 kA.
The instantaneous element must be studied against the complete fault-current range and the upstream/downstream protection arrangement.
A suitable pickup cannot be selected from these four values alone. The engineer must also consider fault location, fault type, system operating conditions, CT behavior, and the required selectivity.
6. Earth Fault Protection Settings – ANSI 50N and 51N
Earth fault protection detects current associated with faults involving earth.
Depending on the relay and installation, the measured earth fault current may be obtained from:
- Residual current calculated from three phase CT inputs.
- A separate neutral CT.
- A core-balance CT.
- A dedicated ground-current input.
6.1 Residual Current Calculation
The residual current is calculated from the vector sum of the three phase currents:
[
3I_0 = I_A + I_B + I_C
]
For a balanced three-phase system, the vector sum should be approximately zero.
During an earth fault, residual current may become significant.
6.2 Earth Fault Pickup Selection
Earth fault pickup depends on:
- System earthing arrangement.
- Minimum earth fault current.
- Maximum permissible residual current.
- CT arrangement and accuracy.
- Feeder and equipment requirements.
- Downstream protection.
- Required sensitivity.
A solidly earthed system may produce relatively high earth fault currents, while resistance-earthed or isolated systems may require different protection approaches.
The engineer must understand the system earthing method before selecting earth fault settings.
6.3 Sensitive Earth Fault Protection
Some applications require sensitive earth fault detection.
This may be achieved using a suitable core-balance CT or a dedicated neutral current input.
The engineer must confirm that the relay’s input sensitivity, measurement accuracy, and available protection function are suitable for the required application.
7. Directional Overcurrent Protection – ANSI 67
Directional overcurrent protection determines whether the fault current is flowing in the configured forward or reverse direction.
It is particularly useful in:
- Ring networks.
- Parallel feeders.
- Networks with multiple sources.
- Distributed generation systems.
- Interconnected power systems.
Directional protection normally uses current and a suitable polarizing voltage quantity.
7.1 Directional Settings
Depending on the relay, configuration may include:
- Directional element enablement.
- Forward or reverse operating direction.
- Polarizing voltage selection.
- Maximum torque angle or equivalent characteristic parameter.
- Current pickup.
- Time-current characteristic.
- Directional supervision.
The terminology and implementation vary by relay model.
7.2 Engineering Considerations
Before enabling directional overcurrent protection, verify:
- CT polarity.
- VT polarity.
- Phase assignment.
- Phase sequence.
- System grounding arrangement.
- Expected fault-current direction.
- Polarizing quantity.
- Forward and reverse operating characteristics.
A correct overcurrent pickup test does not prove that the directional function is correctly configured.
8. Time-Current Coordination
Protection coordination ensures that the protection device closest to the fault operates first, while upstream devices provide backup protection.
This principle is known as selectivity.
For example, in a radial distribution system, a downstream feeder relay should normally clear a fault on its feeder before the upstream incomer relay operates.
8.1 Primary and Backup Protection
Consider a radial system with:
- Incomer protection.
- Distribution transformer protection.
- Downstream feeder protection.
For a fault on the downstream feeder:
- The feeder relay detects the fault.
- The feeder circuit breaker trips.
- The upstream protection remains stable if the fault is cleared successfully.
- The upstream relay provides backup if the feeder protection or breaker fails.
The coordination study must consider the full protection chain, not just the relay operating times.
8.2 Coordination Time Interval
A coordination time interval (CTI) is the time separation between primary and backup protection operation.
The required interval depends on the application and must account for factors such as:
- Circuit breaker opening time.
- Relay timing tolerances.
- Overtravel or reset behavior where relevant.
- CT errors and saturation.
- Protection scheme design.
- Applicable standards and utility requirements.
There is no single universal CTI that is suitable for every system.
9. Understanding Time-Current Characteristic Curves
Time-current characteristic curves are used to assess the coordination between protection devices.
A typical coordination study plots:
- Current on the horizontal axis.
- Operating time on the vertical axis.
- Relay characteristics.
- Fuse characteristics, where applicable.
- Transformer damage curves.
- Cable thermal limits.
- Motor starting and thermal curves, where relevant.
9.1 Why Curves Are Important
The curves help engineers determine whether:
- Downstream protection operates first.
- Upstream backup protection has sufficient time margin.
- Equipment thermal limits are respected.
- Motor starting is permitted without unwanted tripping.
- Transformer inrush is considered appropriately.
- High-current faults are cleared within the required time.
9.2 Relay Curve Selection
The curve type should be selected according to the system application.
For example:
- Standard inverse curves may suit many distribution applications.
- Very inverse curves may be useful where coordination with downstream fuses or other inverse-time devices is required.
- Extremely inverse curves may be appropriate for certain distribution and equipment coordination applications.
- Definite-time characteristics may suit specific grading schemes.
The actual choice must be verified using the complete time-current coordination study.
10. Transformer Protection Settings
Transformer protection requires several functions to work together.
Depending on transformer rating, voltage level, grounding, and protection philosophy, a transformer relay may include:
- Transformer differential protection (87T).
- Restricted earth fault protection (64REF).
- Phase overcurrent protection (50/51).
- Earth fault protection (50N/51N).
- Thermal overload protection (49).
- Overexcitation protection (24).
- Overvoltage and undervoltage protection.
- Breaker failure protection.
10.1 Transformer Differential Settings
Differential protection compares currents from the transformer windings after compensation for transformer ratio and vector group.
Typical engineering considerations include:
- Transformer rated power.
- Winding rated voltages.
- Transformer vector group.
- CT ratios.
- Differential pickup.
- Restraint characteristic.
- Harmonic restraint or blocking, where available.
- Zero-sequence compensation.
- External fault stability.
The differential settings must be calculated using the actual transformer and CT data.
10.2 Transformer Overcurrent Backup
Overcurrent protection may provide backup for transformer internal and external faults.
Settings should consider:
- Transformer rated current.
- Permissible loading.
- Through-fault current.
- Downstream protection.
- Transformer thermal capability.
- Inrush behavior.
- Upstream protection coordination.
The protection design must avoid unnecessary operation during permissible transformer energization and loading conditions.
11. Motor Protection Settings
Motor protection requires special attention because motors have high starting currents and specific thermal limits.
Depending on the relay model, available motor protection functions may include:
- Thermal overload (49).
- Phase overcurrent (50/51).
- Earth fault (50N/51N).
- Negative-sequence protection (46).
- Locked rotor or stall protection.
- Start supervision.
- Undercurrent or loss-of-load protection.
- Starts-per-hour supervision (66).
- Undervoltage protection (27).
11.1 Motor Full-Load Current
For a three-phase motor:
[
I = \frac{P}{\sqrt{3} \times V \times \eta \times \cos\phi}
]
Where:
- (P) = mechanical output power.
- (V) = line-to-line voltage.
- (\eta) = efficiency.
- (\cos\phi) = power factor.
The calculated full-load current should be checked against the motor nameplate.
11.2 Motor Starting Current
Motor starting current may be several times the rated full-load current.
The protection engineer must consider:
- Motor starting method.
- Starting current profile.
- Starting duration.
- Hot and cold thermal limits.
- Number of permitted starts.
- Load characteristics.
- Acceleration time.
- Locked-rotor withstand capability.
A phase overcurrent setting that ignores motor starting behavior can cause nuisance tripping.
11.3 Thermal Protection
Thermal protection models the heating effect of current and, depending on the relay, may include thermal memory and other operating conditions.
The thermal settings should be based on manufacturer motor data and the relay’s supported thermal model.
12. Generator Protection Settings
Generator protection requires a coordinated set of protection functions that respond to electrical faults and abnormal operating conditions.
Depending on the generator and relay model, these may include:
- Generator differential protection (87G).
- Stator earth fault protection (64G).
- Negative-sequence protection (46).
- Reverse power protection (32).
- Loss of excitation (40).
- Overvoltage and undervoltage (59/27).
- Underfrequency and overfrequency (81U/81O).
- Thermal overload (49).
- Overcurrent backup protection.
12.1 Generator Setting Considerations
Generator protection settings depend on:
- Generator rated voltage and current.
- Rated apparent power.
- Neutral grounding method.
- Generator capability curves.
- Excitation system behavior.
- Network operating conditions.
- Generator manufacturer limits.
- Protection philosophy.
The settings should be coordinated with the generator capability curve and relevant manufacturer recommendations.
13. Breaker Failure Protection – ANSI 50BF
Breaker failure protection operates when a circuit breaker fails to interrupt current after receiving a trip command.
The function may supervise:
- Breaker trip command.
- Current persistence.
- Breaker auxiliary contact status.
- Retrip logic.
- Backup trip logic.
The actual implementation depends on the relay model and protection scheme.
13.1 Breaker Failure Timer
The breaker failure timer must account for:
- Breaker opening time.
- Relay output time.
- Current interruption.
- Required safety margin.
- Backup trip requirements.
A timer that is too short may cause unnecessary backup tripping. A timer that is too long may delay fault clearance.
The engineer must use breaker manufacturer data and the approved protection coordination study.
14. Protection Logic and Output Configuration
Numerical relays often include programmable logic that connects protection elements to physical outputs, alarms, and other control functions.
For example:
- Phase overcurrent pickup may initiate an alarm.
- Phase overcurrent operation may initiate a trip.
- Breaker failure logic may initiate an upstream trip.
- VT failure supervision may block selected voltage-dependent elements.
- Protection lockout logic may require manual reset.
The engineer should review the entire logic chain, including:
- Protection element output.
- Logic gates.
- Timers.
- Latches.
- Blocking inputs.
- Interlocking signals.
- Physical output contacts.
- Breaker trip circuit.
A correctly configured protection pickup does not guarantee successful breaker tripping if the output logic or wiring is incorrect.
15. Practical Example: Feeder Overcurrent Setting Study
Consider a radial 11 kV feeder with the following illustrative data:
| Parameter | Value |
|---|---|
| Nominal voltage | 11 kV |
| Maximum load current | 400 A |
| CT ratio | 600/1 A |
| Maximum three-phase fault current | 6 kA |
| Minimum fault current at the remote end | 1.2 kA |
| Downstream protection | Feeder relay |
| Upstream protection | Incomer relay |
The engineering process should include:
Step 1 – Verify the CT Ratio
The CT ratio is 600/1 A.
A 400 A load corresponds to approximately 0.667 A secondary current.
Step 2 – Select a Suitable Pickup
The pickup must be above the maximum expected load, with appropriate consideration of overload and operating conditions.
The selected setting must also remain sensitive to the minimum fault current.
Step 3 – Select the Operating Characteristic
Choose an appropriate inverse-time or definite-time characteristic based on the coordination study.
Step 4 – Check the Minimum Fault Current
Verify that the minimum fault current is sufficient to operate the protection element within the required time.
Step 5 – Check the Maximum Fault Current
Confirm that the protection system clears high-current faults within the required equipment and system limits.
Step 6 – Coordinate with Upstream Protection
Plot the feeder and incomer relay characteristics to confirm suitable grading and backup operation.
Step 7 – Verify by Testing
Use secondary injection to confirm the pickup and operating time of the configured protection element.
This example demonstrates the engineering process, not a final recommended setting for a real feeder.
16. Implementing Settings Using EnerVista
After the protection study has been completed and approved, the settings can be implemented using the compatible EnerVista software.
A general workflow is:
- Identify the exact GE Multilin relay model.
- Open the corresponding EnerVista application.
- Connect to the relay or open the engineering settings file.
- Configure CT and VT data.
- Enable the required protection functions.
- Enter pickup values.
- Configure time-current characteristics.
- Configure timers and directional parameters where applicable.
- Review logic and output assignments.
- Save the settings file.
- Compare the settings against the approved study.
- Download only through the approved commissioning or maintenance procedure.
- Verify the final configuration and test the protection functions.
The exact software screens and parameter names differ across GE Multilin products.
17. Testing Protection Relay Settings
Protection settings must be verified through suitable testing.
17.1 Pickup Test
The purpose of a pickup test is to confirm that the protection element responds at the intended threshold.
A typical procedure is:
- Connect the relay test equipment.
- Apply a current below pickup.
- Confirm that the element remains reset.
- Increase current gradually.
- Record the pickup value.
- Compare the measured value with the approved setting.
17.2 Operating Time Test
For time overcurrent protection:
- Select the required test current.
- Apply the current above pickup.
- Measure the relay operating time.
- Compare the result with the expected curve or definite-time setting.
- Repeat at suitable test points.
17.3 Directional Test
Where directional protection is used, test both forward and reverse operating conditions.
The test must verify the current and voltage phase-angle relationships and the selected directional characteristic.
17.4 Trip Circuit Test
The final test should verify that the protection element and associated logic operate the intended trip output and circuit breaker trip circuit according to the approved test procedure.
Testing only the software indication is not sufficient to prove the complete protection chain.
18. Common Protection Setting Mistakes
| Mistake | Possible consequence |
|---|---|
| Pickup below maximum load | Unwanted operation during normal loading |
| Pickup above minimum fault current | Reduced sensitivity or failure to detect faults |
| Incorrect CT ratio | Incorrect current scaling |
| Incorrect curve selection | Poor protection coordination |
| Incorrect time multiplier | Unwanted grading or delayed operation |
| Instantaneous pickup too low | Operation for external faults |
| Instantaneous pickup too high | Failure to provide intended fast fault clearance |
| Earth fault setting unsuitable for system earthing | Missed or unwanted earth fault operation |
| Incorrect directional reference | Incorrect forward/reverse decision |
| Inadequate breaker failure timer | Unnecessary or delayed backup operation |
| Incorrect trip logic | Protection element operates without the intended breaker trip |
| Missing coordination review | Loss of selectivity |
19. Protection Setting Documentation and Management
A professional protection engineering process should maintain controlled documentation.
Recommended records include:
- Protection philosophy.
- System study data.
- Short-circuit calculations.
- Protection coordination curves.
- Relay setting calculation sheets.
- Approved relay settings.
- Relay configuration files.
- Commissioning test reports.
- Settings revision history.
- Protection change records.
Each setting change should have a clear technical justification and approval record.
The final settings file should be backed up and associated with the correct relay identification and revision.
20. Conclusion
GE Multilin protection relay settings must be developed through a structured engineering process that combines system studies, equipment data, protection principles, coordination requirements, and commissioning verification.
Pickup current, operating time, time-current curves, directional characteristics, differential settings, thermal limits, and breaker failure logic must all be considered in the context of the actual installation.
EnerVista provides the tools to implement and manage settings, but the reliability of the protection system depends on the quality of the engineering calculations, configuration review, testing, and documentation.
21. Training on GE Multilin Protection Relays by Elec-Engg
Elec-Engg provides practical technical training in power system protection, relay engineering, protection coordination, testing, and commissioning.
Training by Dr Saeed Roostaee (Electrical Engineering) is designed for practicing engineers who work with protection systems in utilities, substations, power plants, and industrial facilities.
Relevant training topics include:
- GE Multilin relay families and protection applications.
- Protection setting calculations and engineering.
- Phase overcurrent and earth fault protection.
- Directional overcurrent protection.
- Time-current characteristic curves.
- Protection coordination and grading.
- Transformer differential and restricted earth fault protection.
- Generator and motor protection.
- Breaker failure protection.
- EnerVista configuration and settings management.
- Secondary injection testing and commissioning.
- Event records, oscillography, and troubleshooting.
Training is available through pre-recorded video courses, structured self-paced training, live online sessions, face-to-face courses, and customized in-house programs.
For more information:
Website: https://elec-engg.com/
Contact: https://elec-engg.com/contact/
