GE Multilin Overcurrent Protection: ANSI 50/51, Earth Fault Protection, Curve Selection and Practical Settings

Table Of Contents
  1. 1. Introduction
  2. 2. What Is Overcurrent Protection?
  3. 3. GE Multilin Overcurrent Protection Functions
  4. 4. Instantaneous Phase Overcurrent – ANSI 50
  5. 5. Time Overcurrent Protection – ANSI 51
  6. 6. Understanding Inverse-Time Curves
  7. 7. Phase Overcurrent Pickup Calculation
  8. 8. Earth Fault Overcurrent Protection – ANSI 50N/51N
  9. 9. Ground Fault Protection in Different Earthing Systems
  10. 10. Directional Overcurrent Protection – ANSI 67
  11. 11. Negative-Sequence Overcurrent Protection – ANSI 46
  12. 12. Overcurrent Protection Coordination
  13. 13. Overcurrent Protection for Transformer Feeders
  14. 14. Overcurrent Protection for Motor Feeders
  15. 15. Practical Example: 11 kV Feeder Overcurrent Protection
  16. 16. Configuring Overcurrent Protection in GE Multilin Relays
  17. 17. Testing GE Multilin Overcurrent Protection
  18. 18. Common Overcurrent Protection Problems
  19. 19. Engineering Checklist
  20. 20. Conclusion
  21. 21. Training on GE Multilin Protection Relays by Elec-Engg

1. Introduction

Overcurrent protection is one of the most widely used protection functions in electrical power systems. It protects feeders, transformers, motors, generators, and other electrical equipment against excessive current caused by short circuits, earth faults, and abnormal operating conditions.

GE Multilin numerical protection relays provide different overcurrent protection functions depending on the relay family and application. These may include instantaneous overcurrent (ANSI 50), time overcurrent (ANSI 51), neutral or earth fault overcurrent (ANSI 50N/51N), and directional overcurrent (ANSI 67).

Correct configuration requires more than entering a pickup current and time delay. The protection engineer must understand the system fault levels, CT ratios, load characteristics, earthing arrangement, equipment thermal limits, and coordination requirements.

This article explains the engineering principles of GE Multilin overcurrent protection, including phase overcurrent, earth fault protection, inverse-time curves, instantaneous elements, setting calculations, coordination, and commissioning tests.

The examples are illustrative. Actual settings must be calculated and approved for the installation and the specific relay model.

2. What Is Overcurrent Protection?

Overcurrent protection detects current exceeding a predefined threshold and initiates an alarm or trip command according to the configured protection characteristic and logic.

Overcurrent protection is commonly applied to:

  • Medium-voltage distribution feeders.
  • Transformer incomers and outgoing feeders.
  • Industrial distribution systems.
  • Motor feeders.
  • Generator backup protection.
  • Utility distribution networks.
  • Radial and interconnected power systems.

The basic principle is that an electrical fault generally causes current to increase above its normal operating level. The relay measures the current through its CT inputs and determines whether the protection element should operate.

However, not every high current represents a fault. Motor starting, transformer energization, permissible overloads, and other transient conditions must be considered when developing protection settings.

3. GE Multilin Overcurrent Protection Functions

The principal ANSI device numbers associated with overcurrent protection are:

ANSI numberFunction
50Instantaneous phase overcurrent
51Time phase overcurrent
50NInstantaneous neutral or earth fault overcurrent
51NTime neutral or earth fault overcurrent
50GInstantaneous ground overcurrent
51GTime ground overcurrent
67Directional phase overcurrent
67NDirectional neutral or earth fault overcurrent

The exact function names, available elements, and measurement methods vary between GE Multilin models.

For example, a feeder protection relay and a transformer differential relay may have different overcurrent functions and configuration options.

Always check the applicable relay instruction manual and firmware documentation before engineering the protection scheme.

4. Instantaneous Phase Overcurrent – ANSI 50

Instantaneous overcurrent protection operates when the measured current exceeds a configured pickup threshold, without an intentional inverse-time delay.

It is commonly used for high-current faults where fast clearance is required.

4.1 Operating Principle

The relay continuously measures the phase currents.

When a measured current exceeds the instantaneous pickup setting, the element changes state and may initiate a trip according to the configured logic.

The basic operating condition can be represented as:

[
I_{\text{measured}} \geq I_{\text{pickup}}
]

The actual relay operation also depends on enablement, supervision, blocking, output logic, and any configured operating conditions.

4.2 Selecting Instantaneous Pickup

The instantaneous pickup must be selected carefully.

The engineer should consider:

  • Maximum expected load current.
  • Maximum external fault current.
  • Minimum internal fault current.
  • Fault location.
  • Source impedance.
  • Transformer impedance.
  • Feeder impedance.
  • CT performance.
  • Downstream protection.
  • Required selectivity.

If the instantaneous pickup is too low, the relay may operate for faults outside its intended protection zone.

If it is too high, some internal faults may not be detected by the instantaneous element.

4.3 Practical Example

Consider a medium-voltage feeder with:

  • Maximum load current: 400 A.
  • CT ratio: 600/1 A.
  • Maximum calculated external fault current: 5.5 kA.
  • Minimum calculated internal fault current: 1.8 kA.

The instantaneous element must be evaluated against the fault-current distribution and coordination requirements.

These values alone are not sufficient to determine a final pickup. The engineer must assess fault locations, system configurations, CT behavior, and downstream protection.

5. Time Overcurrent Protection – ANSI 51

Time overcurrent protection operates when the current exceeds a configured pickup threshold and remains above that threshold for the required operating time.

The operating time may be:

  • Inverse time.
  • Definite time.
  • A manufacturer-specific characteristic.

The available characteristics depend on the relay model.

5.1 Definite-Time Overcurrent

In definite-time protection, the relay operates after a fixed time delay once the pickup condition is satisfied.

For example:

  • Pickup: 500 A.
  • Operating delay: 0.6 seconds.

If the measured current remains above pickup for the configured operating period, the element operates, subject to its logic and supervision.

Definite-time protection is often used in grading schemes where fixed operating delays are appropriate.

5.2 Inverse-Time Overcurrent

In inverse-time protection, the operating time generally decreases as the fault current increases.

This characteristic is useful in distribution networks where different fault-current levels must be cleared with appropriate grading.

The relay’s operating time depends on:

  • Measured current.
  • Pickup setting.
  • Selected curve.
  • Time multiplier or time dial.
  • Relay implementation and tolerances.

6. Understanding Inverse-Time Curves

Inverse-time curves define the relationship between fault current and operating time.

Common curve families include:

  • Standard inverse.
  • Very inverse.
  • Extremely inverse.
  • Long-time inverse.
  • Other manufacturer-specific characteristics.

IEC inverse-time curves are often represented by:

[
t = TMS \times \frac{k}{(I/I_s)^\alpha – 1}
]

Where:

  • (t) = operating time.
  • (TMS) = time multiplier setting.
  • (I) = measured current.
  • (I_s) = pickup current.
  • (k) and (\alpha) = constants associated with the selected curve.

This is a general IEC curve representation. GE Multilin relays may provide different curve families, definitions, and parameter implementations. Always use the exact curve equations and characteristics specified for the selected relay.

6.1 Standard Inverse Curve

Standard inverse characteristics are commonly used for feeder protection and distribution coordination.

They provide an inverse relationship between fault current and operating time.

6.2 Very Inverse Curve

Very inverse curves provide a stronger inverse characteristic over their operating range.

They may be useful in certain distribution applications and coordination with downstream devices.

6.3 Extremely Inverse Curve

Extremely inverse characteristics have a steeper inverse relationship and may be useful for specific applications where the coordination study supports their use.

6.4 Curve Selection

Curve selection must be based on the actual protection coordination study.

The engineer should compare the relay characteristic with:

  • Downstream relay curves.
  • Upstream relay curves.
  • Fuse characteristics.
  • Transformer damage curves.
  • Cable thermal limits.
  • Motor starting and thermal characteristics.
  • Circuit breaker operating times.

A curve that appears suitable for one fault-current range may not provide satisfactory coordination across the complete operating range.

7. Phase Overcurrent Pickup Calculation

The phase overcurrent pickup must be selected to provide adequate sensitivity while avoiding operation under permissible load conditions.

A practical engineering process is:

  1. Determine maximum expected load current.
  2. Identify permissible overload conditions.
  3. Determine minimum fault current.
  4. Confirm CT ratio and relay input rating.
  5. Select a suitable pickup range.
  6. Check the selected pickup against the relay’s setting convention.
  7. Verify sensitivity and coordination.

7.1 Example Using CT Ratio

Consider:

  • CT ratio: 800/1 A.
  • Required primary pickup: 640 A.

The corresponding secondary pickup is:

[
I_s = \frac{640}{800} = 0.8\text{ A}
]

If the relay setting is expressed in secondary amperes, 0.8 A is the corresponding value, subject to the model’s setting convention.

Some relays use multiples of rated current or per-unit values instead. Confirm the exact interpretation before entering the setting.

8. Earth Fault Overcurrent Protection – ANSI 50N/51N

Earth fault protection detects current associated with a connection between an energized conductor and earth or an earthed part of the system.

The method of earth fault current measurement depends on the installation and relay design.

Common arrangements include:

  • Residual current calculated from three phase CTs.
  • A separate neutral CT.
  • A core-balance CT.
  • A dedicated ground-current input.

8.1 Residual Current Calculation

The residual current is calculated as:

[
3I_0 = I_A + I_B + I_C
]

Where:

  • (I_A) = Phase A current.
  • (I_B) = Phase B current.
  • (I_C) = Phase C current.
  • (3I_0) = Residual current.

For a balanced three-phase system, the vector sum should be approximately zero.

During an earth fault, the residual current may increase significantly.

8.2 Residual Earth Fault Protection

Residual earth fault protection uses the vector sum of the phase CT measurements.

Its sensitivity depends on CT performance, wiring, relay measurement characteristics, and the magnitude of the fault current.

In some installations, residual measurement may be unsuitable for very sensitive earth fault detection.

8.3 Core-Balance CT Protection

A core-balance CT measures the residual current directly by surrounding the relevant conductors.

This arrangement can provide sensitive earth fault detection when correctly selected and installed.

The engineer should verify:

  • CT ratio.
  • CT sensitivity and accuracy.
  • Conductor arrangement.
  • Polarity.
  • Relay input compatibility.
  • Secondary wiring.
  • Protection function configuration.

8.4 Earth Fault Pickup Selection

Earth fault pickup depends on:

  • System grounding method.
  • Minimum earth fault current.
  • Maximum normal residual current.
  • CT arrangement.
  • Feeder loading and leakage conditions.
  • Required sensitivity.
  • Coordination with upstream and downstream protection.

The settings for a solidly earthed system may differ substantially from those for resistance-earthed or isolated systems.

9. Ground Fault Protection in Different Earthing Systems

The system earthing method has a major influence on earth fault current magnitude and protection philosophy.

9.1 Solidly Earthed Systems

In a solidly earthed system, earth fault current can be relatively high.

Conventional residual or neutral overcurrent protection may be suitable, depending on the installation.

9.2 Resistance-Earthed Systems

In resistance-earthed systems, the neutral grounding resistor limits earth fault current.

The earth fault protection must be sensitive enough to detect the limited current while remaining stable under normal conditions.

9.3 Isolated or Unearthed Systems

In isolated systems, the first earth fault current may be relatively small and influenced by system capacitance.

Conventional overcurrent protection may not provide the required sensitivity.

Specialized earth fault detection methods, including residual voltage or directional approaches, may be required depending on the system design and relay capabilities.

10. Directional Overcurrent Protection – ANSI 67

Directional overcurrent protection determines whether the fault current is flowing in the configured forward or reverse direction.

It is commonly used in:

  • Ring distribution systems.
  • Parallel feeders.
  • Networks with multiple sources.
  • Systems with distributed generation.
  • Interconnected industrial networks.

10.1 Operating Principle

Directional overcurrent protection combines current measurement with a suitable polarizing quantity, commonly voltage-based.

The relay evaluates the relationship between the measured quantities and the configured directional characteristic.

The protection element operates only when the required directional condition and overcurrent pickup condition are satisfied.

10.2 Important Settings

Depending on the relay model, directional configuration may include:

  • Directional element enablement.
  • Forward or reverse direction.
  • Polarizing voltage selection.
  • Characteristic angle or equivalent parameter.
  • Current pickup.
  • Operating time.
  • Directional supervision.

10.3 Commissioning Considerations

Before commissioning directional overcurrent protection, verify:

  • CT polarity.
  • VT polarity.
  • Phase assignment.
  • Phase sequence.
  • Polarizing voltage.
  • Forward and reverse definitions.
  • Current and voltage phase-angle relationships.

A relay can measure current correctly and still make an incorrect directional decision if the voltage reference or CT polarity is wrong.

11. Negative-Sequence Overcurrent Protection – ANSI 46

Negative-sequence current is associated with unbalanced three-phase conditions.

It may arise from:

  • Phase-to-phase faults.
  • Phase-to-earth faults.
  • Unbalanced loading.
  • Open-phase conditions.
  • Unequal phase impedances.

Negative-sequence protection can be useful for detecting abnormal phase-current imbalance.

In rotating machines, negative-sequence current produces additional heating effects in the rotor.

Some GE Multilin relays provide negative-sequence protection functions, depending on the model and application.

The engineer should configure the function using the relevant equipment limits and relay documentation.

12. Overcurrent Protection Coordination

Protection coordination ensures that the protection device closest to a fault operates first, while upstream protection provides backup.

Consider a radial distribution system containing:

  • An upstream incomer relay.
  • A transformer feeder relay.
  • A downstream load feeder relay.

For a fault on the downstream feeder, the downstream relay should normally clear the fault first.

The upstream relay should remain stable if the downstream protection successfully clears the fault.

12.1 Coordination Time Interval

The coordination time interval separates the primary and backup protection operating times.

It must account for:

  • Relay operating time.
  • Circuit breaker interruption time.
  • Relay tolerances.
  • CT errors.
  • Reset behavior where relevant.
  • Protection scheme requirements.

The required interval depends on the application, equipment, and applicable standards or utility practices. There is no universal CTI suitable for every installation.

12.2 Time-Current Curve Review

A coordination study should include the relevant operating characteristics on a common current-time plot.

Check that:

  • Downstream protection operates before upstream backup.
  • The required grading margin is maintained.
  • Transformer and cable limits are respected.
  • Motor starting does not cause unwanted operation.
  • Maximum and minimum fault conditions are covered.

13. Overcurrent Protection for Transformer Feeders

Overcurrent protection is often used as backup protection for transformer faults and as primary protection for associated feeders.

The setting study should consider:

  • Transformer rated current.
  • Transformer impedance.
  • Maximum permissible loading.
  • Through-fault current.
  • Transformer inrush.
  • Downstream feeder protection.
  • Upstream protection.
  • Transformer thermal withstand.

For transformers with differential protection, overcurrent protection may provide additional backup.

The coordination of these functions should be reviewed as part of the complete transformer protection scheme.

14. Overcurrent Protection for Motor Feeders

Motor feeder overcurrent settings must distinguish between fault current and normal motor starting current.

The engineer should consider:

  • Motor rated current.
  • Starting current.
  • Starting time.
  • Starting method.
  • Load torque characteristics.
  • Locked-rotor withstand time.
  • Thermal protection.
  • Number of starts.
  • Acceleration behavior.

A motor relay may provide specialized starting and thermal protection functions in addition to conventional overcurrent elements.

The settings must be based on the motor manufacturer’s data and the selected relay’s protection model.

15. Practical Example: 11 kV Feeder Overcurrent Protection

Consider the following illustrative feeder data:

ParameterValue
System voltage11 kV
Maximum load current400 A
CT ratio600/1 A
Maximum three-phase fault current6 kA
Minimum remote-end fault current1.2 kA
Protection arrangementRadial feeder
Upstream protectionIncomer relay

Step 1 – Verify the CT Ratio

The CT ratio is 600/1 A.

At maximum load:

[
I_{\text{secondary}} = \frac{400}{600} = 0.667\text{ A}
]

Step 2 – Establish the Pickup Requirement

The pickup must be above the maximum expected load, with suitable consideration of permissible overload and operating conditions.

It must also remain sensitive to the minimum fault current.

Step 3 – Select the Curve

Select an appropriate inverse-time or definite-time characteristic based on the downstream and upstream protection coordination requirements.

Step 4 – Check the Minimum Fault Current

Confirm that the remote-end fault current is sufficient to operate the protection element within the required time.

Step 5 – Check the Maximum Fault Current

Confirm that high-current faults are cleared within the required equipment and system limits.

Step 6 – Coordinate with the Incomer

Compare the feeder and incomer characteristics across the relevant fault-current range.

Step 7 – Verify by Testing

Perform secondary injection to verify pickup and operating time.

The example describes the calculation process only. It does not provide a final protection setting for a real feeder.

16. Configuring Overcurrent Protection in GE Multilin Relays

The applicable EnerVista software can be used to configure the overcurrent functions supported by the connected relay.

A general engineering workflow is:

  1. Identify the exact relay model.
  2. Open the corresponding EnerVista application.
  3. Confirm the relay hardware and firmware.
  4. Configure CT and VT information.
  5. Locate the relevant overcurrent protection settings.
  6. Enable the required elements.
  7. Enter the approved pickup values.
  8. Select the appropriate operating characteristic.
  9. Configure time multiplier or definite-time delay.
  10. Configure directional supervision where required.
  11. Review alarm and trip logic.
  12. Save the settings file.
  13. Compare the configuration with the approved protection study.
  14. Download settings only through the approved procedure.
  15. Verify the final configuration by testing.

Menu names and setting structures vary across GE Multilin relay families. Follow the correct manual for the specific device.

17. Testing GE Multilin Overcurrent Protection

Testing should confirm that the configured protection functions operate according to the approved settings.

17.1 Pickup Test

A pickup test verifies the current level at which the protection element changes state.

Typical procedure:

  1. Connect a suitable secondary injection test set.
  2. Apply current below the pickup threshold.
  3. Confirm that the element remains reset.
  4. Increase current gradually.
  5. Record the pickup value.
  6. Compare the result with the approved setting and test tolerance.

17.2 Operating Time Test

For inverse-time protection:

  1. Select a test current above pickup.
  2. Apply the current.
  3. Measure the operating time.
  4. Compare the measured time with the expected characteristic.
  5. Repeat at additional current points.

For definite-time protection, verify the configured delay.

17.3 Earth Fault Protection Test

Verify the earth fault measurement method used by the scheme.

For residual measurement, apply suitable phase-current quantities to produce the required residual current.

For a dedicated neutral or core-balance CT input, use the appropriate test connection and procedure.

17.4 Directional Protection Test

For directional elements, verify both forward and reverse operating conditions using controlled current and voltage injection.

Check the configured polarizing quantity and directional characteristic.

17.5 Trip Output Test

Verify the complete trip logic and output circuit according to the commissioning plan.

This should include the relevant relay output, trip circuit, and breaker interface where applicable.

18. Common Overcurrent Protection Problems

ProblemPossible causeEngineering check
Unwanted operation during normal loadPickup too low or incorrect scalingCheck CT ratio and load current
Failure to detect a faultPickup too high or insufficient fault currentReview minimum fault study
Incorrect operating timeWrong curve or time multiplierVerify curve and setting convention
Nuisance operation during motor startingStarting current not consideredReview motor starting data
Earth fault element remains resetIncorrect residual or neutral CT wiringCheck measurement arrangement
Directional element operates in the wrong directionIncorrect CT/VT polarity or phase assignmentPerform directional tests
Poor coordinationIncorrect grading or curve selectionReview time-current curves
Relay measures incorrect currentWrong CT ratio or input assignmentVerify hardware and settings
Trip output does not operateIncorrect logic or output wiringTest the complete trip chain

19. Engineering Checklist

Before placing a GE Multilin overcurrent protection scheme into service, verify:

System and instrument transformer data

  • System voltage and frequency confirmed.
  • Maximum load current established.
  • Minimum and maximum fault currents calculated.
  • CT ratio and secondary rating verified.
  • CT polarity and phase assignment checked.
  • Earth fault measurement arrangement confirmed.

Protection settings

  • Phase overcurrent pickup reviewed.
  • Instantaneous pickup reviewed.
  • Time-current curve selected.
  • Time multiplier or time delay checked.
  • Earth fault pickup reviewed.
  • Directional settings checked, where applicable.
  • Upstream and downstream coordination reviewed.
  • Equipment thermal limits considered.

Testing and documentation

  • Pickup tests completed.
  • Operating time tests completed.
  • Directional tests completed, where applicable.
  • Trip logic and output tests completed.
  • Final settings file backed up.
  • Test results documented.
  • Approved settings revision recorded.

20. Conclusion

GE Multilin overcurrent protection provides an important layer of protection for feeders, transformers, motors, generators, and distribution systems.

Reliable operation depends on correct CT configuration, pickup selection, curve characteristics, operating delays, earth fault measurement, directional supervision, and coordination with other protective devices.

The protection engineer must evaluate both minimum and maximum fault conditions, normal loading, equipment withstand limits, and the complete protection chain.

Using EnerVista to implement settings should always be supported by engineering calculations, independent review, secondary injection testing, and proper documentation.

21. Training on GE Multilin Protection Relays by Elec-Engg

Elec-Engg provides practical technical training in power system protection, relay engineering, protection coordination, testing, and commissioning.

Training by Dr Saeed Roostaee (Electrical Engineering) focuses on practical engineering applications for protection, commissioning, operation, and maintenance engineers.

Relevant training topics include:

  • GE Multilin relay families and applications.
  • Phase overcurrent protection (ANSI 50/51).
  • Earth fault protection (ANSI 50N/51N).
  • Directional overcurrent protection (ANSI 67/67N).
  • Negative-sequence protection (ANSI 46).
  • Inverse-time curve selection and time-current coordination.
  • Protection setting calculations.
  • Transformer, generator, and motor feeder protection.
  • EnerVista software and relay configuration.
  • Secondary injection testing and commissioning.
  • Event records, disturbance analysis, and troubleshooting.

Training is available through pre-recorded video courses, structured self-paced training, live online sessions, face-to-face training, and customized in-house programs.

For more information:

Website: https://elec-engg.com/

Contact: https://elec-engg.com/contact/

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top