NARI Relay Settings, Testing & Commissioning: Complete Engineering Guide to Protection Settings, Secondary Injection, Binary I/O, CT/VT Verification, GOOSE Testing, End-to-End Testing and Fault Analysis
- 1. Understanding NARI Relay Setting Files
- 2. Protection Setting Calculation and Verification
- 3. Setting Group Management
- 4. Binary Input and Output Testing
- 5. CT and VT Circuit Verification
- 6. Secondary Injection Testing
- 7. Protection Function Testing
- 7.1 Overcurrent Protection Testing (50/51)
- 7.2 Earth Fault Protection Testing (50N/51N)
- 7.3 Directional Overcurrent Testing (67)
- 7.4 Differential Protection Testing (87)
- 7.5 Distance Protection Testing (21)
- 7.6 Under/Overvoltage Testing (27/59)
- 7.7 Frequency Protection Testing (81)
- 7.8 Breaker Failure Protection Testing (50BF)
- 7.9 Protection Function Test Matrix
- 8. Trip Circuit Verification
- 9. GOOSE Testing
- 10. End-to-End Protection Testing
- 11. Fault Record Analysis
- 12. Commissioning Checklist and Test Reports
- NARI relay testing and commissioning checklist
- 13. Best Practices for NARI Relay Testing and Commissioning
- 14. Applicable IEC Standards and Technical References
- 15. NARI Protection Relay Testing and Commissioning Training by Elec-Engg
- 16. Conclusion
NARI Relay Settings, Testing & Commissioning is an essential part of the engineering lifecycle of modern electrical protection systems. Correct relay settings, accurate instrument transformer connections, reliable binary input and output circuits, properly configured communication signals and systematic commissioning tests are necessary to ensure that protection systems operate correctly during normal operating conditions and electrical faults.
NARI provides protection and control equipment for applications including transmission lines, distribution feeders, power transformers, generators, busbars and other electrical installations. Its PCS protection and control product families include different relay models designed for specific protection applications.
However, protection functions, setting parameters, setting-file formats, engineering software, test interfaces and communication capabilities vary between NARI models and firmware versions. Engineers must therefore use the applicable product manuals and approved project documentation rather than assume that all PCS relays have identical settings or testing procedures.
This comprehensive article explains the practical engineering workflow for NARI protection relay settings, testing and commissioning. It covers setting calculations, setting-file management, protection coordination, CT and VT circuit verification, secondary injection, binary I/O testing, trip circuit verification, GOOSE testing, end-to-end protection testing, fault record analysis and final commissioning documentation.
1. Understanding NARI Relay Setting Files
1.1 Introduction to Protection Relay Settings
Protection relay settings define how a relay detects abnormal electrical conditions and initiates the appropriate protection response.
A protection relay continuously monitors electrical quantities such as:
- Phase currents.
- Residual and earth fault currents.
- Phase voltages.
- Frequency.
- Active and reactive power.
- Impedance.
- Differential current.
- Negative-sequence quantities.
When the measured quantities satisfy the configured protection operating criteria, the relay initiates an alarm, trip command, blocking signal or another configured action.
The settings determine the operating characteristics of each protection function.
For example, an overcurrent protection function may include:
- Pickup current.
- Time delay.
- Operating curve.
- High-set current.
- High-set time delay.
- Directional supervision.
- Blocking conditions.
- Reset characteristics.
1.2 NARI Protection Relay Setting Structure
Depending on the product, a NARI relay configuration may include several categories of parameters.
| Setting category | Typical parameters |
|---|---|
| System configuration | Rated frequency, CT and VT ratios |
| Protection settings | Pickup values and time delays |
| Protection characteristics | Curves, slopes and operating zones |
| Logic settings | Blocking, permissive and trip logic |
| Binary inputs | Signal assignments and polarity |
| Binary outputs | Trip, alarm and indication mapping |
| Communication | IP addresses and communication services |
| IEC 61850 | Datasets, GOOSE and reporting |
| Control | Breaker and switchgear control |
| Recording | Event and disturbance recording |
Not every parameter category is available in every NARI relay.
1.3 Understanding Setting Files
A setting file contains the configuration information used by a protection relay or its engineering software.
Depending on the model and engineering platform, settings may be stored in manufacturer-specific project files, device configuration files, exported reports or other supported formats.
A typical engineering project should maintain:
- Original relay configuration.
- Approved protection setting calculations.
- Final setting file.
- Relay configuration backup.
- Binary input/output mapping.
- Communication configuration.
- IEC 61850 configuration, where applicable.
- Commissioning test results.
1.4 Setting File Management
A recommended file management structure is:
Substation_Project
|
+-- 01_Design
| |
| +-- Single_Line_Diagram
| +-- Protection_Philosophy
|
+-- 02_Settings
| |
| +-- Calculation_Report
| +-- Approved_Settings
| +-- Relay_Setting_Files
|
+-- 03_Configuration
| |
| +-- Binary_IO
| +-- Communication
| +-- IEC61850
|
+-- 04_Testing
| |
| +-- Secondary_Injection
| +-- Protection_Functions
| +-- GOOSE
|
+-- 05_Commissioning
|
+-- Test_Reports
+-- As_Built_Configuration
+-- Final_Backups
1.5 Before Modifying a Relay Setting File
Before making any changes:
- Identify the exact NARI relay model.
- Verify the firmware version.
- Obtain the correct engineering software.
- Back up the existing configuration.
- Obtain the approved setting calculation.
- Confirm CT and VT ratios.
- Confirm system frequency.
- Check the relay’s current configuration.
- Record the existing setting group.
- Obtain the necessary authorization.
Never modify an in-service relay configuration without an approved engineering and operational procedure.
1.6 Setting File Comparison
Comparing the existing and revised settings is an important quality-control activity.
For example:
| Parameter | Existing | Revised |
|---|---|---|
| Phase OC pickup | 1.20 A | 1.50 A |
| Earth fault pickup | 0.20 A | 0.25 A |
| Time multiplier | 0.10 | 0.15 |
| High-set pickup | 8.0 A | 10.0 A |
These are illustrative values only.
The engineer should identify:
- Changed parameters.
- Unchanged parameters.
- New protection functions.
- Disabled functions.
- Changed logic.
- Changed CT/VT ratios.
- Changed communication parameters.
Every modification should be checked against the approved calculation and setting document.
2. Protection Setting Calculation and Verification
2.1 Introduction
Protection setting calculation is the process of determining suitable operating parameters for protection functions.
The objective is to ensure that the protection system:
- Detects faults reliably.
- Operates within the required time.
- Remains stable during normal operating conditions.
- Coordinates with upstream and downstream protection.
- Avoids unnecessary tripping.
- Provides adequate backup protection.
The settings must be based on the electrical network design, equipment ratings, fault studies and protection philosophy.
2.2 Required Engineering Information
Before calculating settings, collect:
- Single-line diagram.
- Transformer ratings.
- Generator ratings, where applicable.
- Cable and overhead line data.
- CT ratios and classes.
- VT ratios.
- Minimum and maximum fault currents.
- Maximum load current.
- System grounding arrangement.
- Neutral earthing impedance.
- Circuit breaker operating times.
- Upstream and downstream protection settings.
- Network operating configurations.
2.3 Overcurrent Protection (ANSI 50/51)
Overcurrent protection is commonly used for feeder, transformer and backup protection.
The main settings include:
- Pickup current.
- Operating time.
- Time-current characteristic.
- Time multiplier setting.
- High-set instantaneous pickup.
- Directional supervision, where required.
For a secondary-current-based relay, the conversion from primary to secondary current is:
\[ I_s=\frac{I_p}{CTR} \]
Where:
- \(I_s\) = Secondary current.
- \(I_p\) = Primary current.
- \(CTR\) = CT ratio.
Example
Consider a feeder with:
- CT ratio: 600/1 A.
- Required primary pickup: 480 A.
The secondary pickup is:
\[ I_s=\frac{480}{600}=0.8A \]
Therefore, the relay pickup setting is 0.8 A, assuming the relay setting is expressed in secondary amperes and the CT ratio is correctly configured.
2.4 Inverse-Time Overcurrent Protection
IEC inverse-time protection curves are commonly used for coordination.
A general IEC inverse-time equation is:
\[ t=TMS\times\frac{k}{(I/I_s)^\alpha-1} \]
Where:
- \(t\) = Operating time.
- \(TMS\) = Time multiplier setting.
- \(I\) = Measured current.
- \(I_s\) = Pickup current.
- \(k\) and \(\alpha\) = Curve constants.
Typical IEC curve characteristics include:
| Curve | \(k\) | \(\alpha\) |
|---|---|---|
| Standard inverse | 0.14 | 0.02 |
| Very inverse | 13.5 | 1 |
| Extremely inverse | 80 | 2 |
The exact curve implementation and equation must be checked against the relay manual and selected standard.
2.5 Earth Fault Protection (ANSI 50N/51N)
Earth fault protection detects current flowing through the neutral or residual current path.
The setting calculation depends on:
- System grounding.
- CT arrangement.
- Minimum earth fault current.
- Maximum residual current under normal conditions.
- Protection sensitivity.
- Coordination requirements.
For a three-phase residual connection:
\[ 3I_0=I_A+I_B+I_C \]
The relay may obtain the residual current from three phase CTs or a dedicated neutral CT, depending on the application.
2.6 Differential Protection (ANSI 87)
Differential protection compares currents entering and leaving a protected zone.
The operating principle is based on the difference between the compensated currents.
A simplified differential current expression is:
\[ I_{diff}=|I_1-I_2| \]
Practical differential protection uses restraint or bias characteristics to maintain stability during external faults and CT saturation.
Important settings include:
- Minimum differential pickup.
- Bias slope.
- High-set differential pickup.
- CT ratio compensation.
- Vector group compensation.
- Zero-sequence compensation.
- Inrush restraint or blocking.
- Overexcitation restraint, where applicable.
For NARI transformer and line differential relays, the exact compensation method and characteristic must be taken from the model-specific documentation.
2.7 Distance Protection (ANSI 21)
Distance protection measures the apparent impedance between the relay location and the fault.
The basic relationship is:
\[ Z=\frac{V}{I} \]
Typical settings include:
- Zone 1 reach.
- Zone 2 reach.
- Zone 3 reach.
- Zone operating times.
- Resistive reach.
- Directional characteristics.
- Power swing blocking.
- Load encroachment.
- Teleprotection logic.
Setting calculations must consider line impedance, adjacent line sections, remote infeed, fault resistance and network operating conditions.
2.8 Verification of Protection Settings
Every setting should be verified using:
- Approved protection calculations.
- Equipment nameplate data.
- CT and VT ratios.
- Network fault studies.
- Coordination studies.
- Relay setting reports.
- Independent engineering review.
- Secondary injection tests.
Protection setting verification should include both numerical values and functional logic.
3. Setting Group Management
3.1 What Are Setting Groups?
Setting groups allow a protection relay to operate with different protection settings under different network conditions.
For example, a feeder relay may require different settings depending on whether:
- The network operates in parallel.
- One transformer is out of service.
- The system operates in an alternative configuration.
- A particular busbar arrangement is selected.
The relay can store multiple setting groups, where supported.
3.2 Typical Setting Group Applications
| Operating condition | Possible setting requirement |
|---|---|
| Normal network operation | Normal protection settings |
| Alternative network configuration | Modified coordination |
| Transformer parallel operation | Revised fault level assumptions |
| Generator connected | Different directional conditions |
| Maintenance configuration | Approved alternative protection arrangement |
3.3 Setting Group Changeover
Setting group selection may be controlled through:
- Local operator command.
- Binary input.
- SCADA command.
- Communication service.
- Internal relay logic.
The available selection methods depend on the NARI relay.
3.4 Setting Group Testing
During commissioning, verify:
- All required groups are available.
- Each group contains the approved settings.
- The correct group is active.
- The selection method operates correctly.
- Group changeover is indicated.
- Protection functions respond according to the active group.
- The active group is correctly reported to SCADA, where configured.
An incorrect setting group can compromise protection coordination even if individual setting values are correct.
4. Binary Input and Output Testing
4.1 Introduction to Binary Inputs and Outputs
Binary inputs and outputs are essential interfaces between protection relays, circuit breakers, auxiliary relays, control panels and substation automation systems.
A binary input receives a digital signal from external equipment.
A binary output sends a control or indication signal to external equipment.
NARI protection relays use binary I/O for functions such as:
- Circuit breaker position monitoring.
- Disconnector status monitoring.
- Protection blocking.
- External trip initiation.
- Circuit breaker failure initiation.
- Trip circuit supervision.
- Protection alarm indication.
- Remote control.
- Interlocking.
- External protection signals.
4.2 Binary Input Applications
Typical binary inputs include:
| Binary input | Typical application |
|---|---|
| BI1 | Circuit breaker closed |
| BI2 | Circuit breaker open |
| BI3 | External protection trip |
| BI4 | Protection blocking |
| BI5 | Breaker failure initiation |
| BI6 | Local/remote selection |
| BI7 | External alarm |
| BI8 | Circuit breaker spring charged |
These assignments are illustrative. Actual assignments depend on the relay configuration and project wiring diagrams.
4.3 Binary Output Applications
Typical binary outputs include:
| Binary output | Typical application |
|---|---|
| BO1 | Circuit breaker trip |
| BO2 | Circuit breaker close |
| BO3 | Protection alarm |
| BO4 | Protection start |
| BO5 | Breaker failure output |
| BO6 | External blocking |
| BO7 | General relay alarm |
4.4 Binary Input Testing Procedure
The following procedure can be used during relay testing:
- Review the approved binary input assignment.
- Identify the corresponding terminal numbers.
- Verify the external wiring.
- Confirm the rated input voltage.
- Isolate external circuits where required by the approved test procedure.
- Apply the appropriate test voltage using a suitable test source.
- Monitor the input status on the relay.
- Verify the corresponding internal logic.
- Confirm event recording.
- Restore the circuit and verify normal status.
4.5 Binary Output Testing Procedure
Binary output testing verifies that the relay operates the correct physical output when the corresponding protection or control condition occurs.
The procedure includes:
- Review the binary output matrix.
- Identify the output relay contacts.
- Verify terminal numbers.
- Check normally open and normally closed contact arrangements.
- Apply a controlled test condition.
- Monitor the output contact using suitable test equipment.
- Verify the associated external signal, where appropriate.
- Confirm event recording.
- Restore all circuits.
4.6 Binary I/O Test Matrix
| Test item | Expected result |
|---|---|
| BI1 activation | Correct input indication |
| BI2 activation | Correct input indication |
| External trip input | Correct trip logic response |
| Blocking input | Correct blocking response |
| Local/remote input | Correct control mode |
| Protection trip output | Correct output contact |
| Alarm output | Correct alarm contact |
| Breaker close output | Correct close command contact |
| Output reset | Correct return to normal |
4.7 Important Engineering Considerations
During binary I/O testing, check:
- DC supply voltage.
- Input threshold.
- Input polarity.
- Contact wetting arrangements.
- Contact ratings.
- Contact bounce.
- Input debounce settings, where available.
- Output contact isolation.
- Interposing relay requirements.
- External circuit supervision.
Never apply an assumed voltage to a binary input without checking its rated operating range.
5. CT and VT Circuit Verification
5.1 Importance of CT and VT Verification
Current transformers and voltage transformers provide the electrical signals used by protection relays.
Incorrect CT or VT connections can cause:
- Incorrect current measurements.
- Incorrect voltage measurements.
- Differential protection maloperation.
- Incorrect directional protection operation.
- Distance protection errors.
- Incorrect residual current measurement.
- Unwanted protection trips.
CT and VT verification is therefore a critical commissioning activity.
5.2 CT Circuit Verification
Before energizing a protection system, verify:
- CT ratio.
- CT secondary rating.
- CT polarity.
- Phase identification.
- Core allocation.
- Terminal connections.
- CT secondary earthing.
- Secondary circuit continuity.
- Shorting terminal arrangements.
- Burden and circuit suitability.
5.3 CT Ratio Verification
Consider a CT with a ratio of:
\[ 600/1A \]
When the primary current is 300 A, the expected secondary current is:
\[ I_s=\frac{300}{600}=0.5A \]
The measured relay current should correspond to the expected value, allowing for test equipment accuracy and circuit conditions.
5.4 CT Polarity Verification
CT polarity is important for directional and differential protection.
The polarity markings P1/P2 and S1/S2 define the intended relationship between primary and secondary current directions.
Incorrect polarity can cause differential current to appear during normal load or external faults.
Polarity should be verified using an appropriate test method and the approved wiring drawings.
5.5 CT Phase Identification
Verify the phase sequence and phase assignment.
For example:
| Primary phase | Relay current input |
|---|---|
| Phase A | IA |
| Phase B | IB |
| Phase C | IC |
| Neutral or residual | IN, where applicable |
The actual terminal designations must be taken from the relay wiring diagram.
5.6 CT Secondary Earthing
CT secondary circuits should be earthed at the designated point in accordance with the project design and applicable standards.
Multiple unintended earth connections can create circulating currents and measurement errors.
Important safety requirement: Never open-circuit an energized CT secondary circuit. Before disconnecting or testing CT circuits, use approved shorting arrangements and follow the site’s isolation and safety procedures.
5.7 VT Circuit Verification
VT circuit verification should include:
- Primary-to-secondary ratio.
- Phase identification.
- Phase sequence.
- Polarity.
- Neutral connection.
- Fuse and MCB arrangements.
- Secondary earthing.
- Voltage circuit continuity.
- Relay voltage input mapping.
5.8 VT Ratio Example
Consider a voltage transformer:
\[ 132kV/110V \]
The ratio is:
\[ CTR_V=\frac{132000}{110}=1200 \]
If the primary voltage is 66 kV, the expected secondary voltage is:
\[ V_s=\frac{66000}{1200}=55V \]
The relay voltage measurement should correspond to the expected secondary voltage, considering the configured voltage ratio and connection arrangement.
5.9 Phase Sequence Verification
A three-phase voltage system should have the correct phase sequence.
Incorrect phase sequence can affect:
- Directional overcurrent protection.
- Distance protection.
- Power measurement.
- Synchronism check.
- Directional earth fault protection.
5.10 CT/VT Verification Checklist
| Check | Expected result |
|---|---|
| CT ratio | Matches approved design |
| CT polarity | Correct |
| CT phase identification | Correct |
| CT secondary continuity | Satisfactory |
| CT earthing | Correct designated point |
| VT ratio | Matches approved design |
| VT polarity | Correct |
| VT phase sequence | Correct |
| VT fuses | Correct rating and condition |
| Relay measurement | Correct magnitude and phase |
6. Secondary Injection Testing
6.1 What Is Secondary Injection Testing?
Secondary injection testing is a method of testing protection relays by injecting simulated current and voltage signals directly into their secondary measurement inputs.
It allows engineers to verify the relay’s measurement accuracy, protection pickup values, operating times and logic behavior without injecting primary current into the power system.
Common test equipment includes:
- OMICRON CMC test sets.
- OMICRON Test Universe.
- Other compatible secondary injection systems.
6.2 Objectives of Secondary Injection
Secondary injection tests can verify:
- Current measurement.
- Voltage measurement.
- Frequency measurement.
- Phase angle measurement.
- Protection pickup.
- Protection operating time.
- Protection reset.
- Directional characteristics.
- Differential characteristics.
- Distance protection zones.
- Binary input response.
- Binary output response.
6.3 Test Equipment Connections
A typical secondary injection test arrangement includes:
OMICRON CMC TEST SET
|
Current Outputs
|
Voltage Outputs
|
v
NARI PROTECTION
RELAY
|
+--------+--------+
| |
Binary Inputs Binary Outputs
| |
+--------+--------+
|
Test Software
The exact test connections depend on the relay input configuration and the selected test equipment.
6.4 Current Measurement Test
For a three-phase overcurrent relay, inject balanced three-phase currents.
Example:
| Phase | Injected current |
|---|---|
| IA | 1.00 A |
| IB | 1.00 A |
| IC | 1.00 A |
Verify that the relay displays the correct phase currents.
Repeat the test at several current levels.
6.5 Voltage Measurement Test
Inject balanced three-phase voltages according to the relay’s nominal secondary voltage and configured measurement convention.
Verify:
- Phase voltage.
- Line voltage.
- Voltage magnitude.
- Phase angle.
- Frequency.
6.6 Phase Angle Verification
Inject three-phase voltage and current signals with known phase angles.
For a balanced system with positive phase sequence, the voltage angles can be represented as:
\[ V_A=0^\circ \]
\[ V_B=-120^\circ \]
\[ V_C=120^\circ \]
The corresponding current angles should be set according to the required power factor and test objective.
Check that the relay displays the expected phase relationships.
6.7 Operating Time Testing
For a protection function, increase the injected current above the pickup value and measure the time between the start of the test condition and the relay trip output.
Compare the measured operating time against the expected characteristic and permitted tolerance.
6.8 Secondary Injection Test Report
A typical test record includes:
| Test parameter | Recorded information |
|---|---|
| Relay model | Actual NARI model |
| Serial number | Device identification |
| Firmware | Installed version |
| Test equipment | Manufacturer and model |
| Test current | Injected value |
| Test voltage | Injected value |
| Pickup value | Measured result |
| Operating time | Measured result |
| Output status | Pass/fail |
| Test date | Date of testing |
| Engineer | Responsible person |
6.9 Important Testing Precautions
- Use the correct test plug and terminal arrangement.
- Confirm relay input ratings.
- Prevent unintended circuit breaker operation.
- Isolate trip outputs where required.
- Verify CT and VT isolation arrangements.
- Check the active setting group.
- Record the original relay configuration.
- Restore all test connections after testing.
7. Protection Function Testing
Protection function testing verifies that each protection element operates according to its approved settings and operating characteristics.
The test engineer should select test methods appropriate to the specific NARI relay and protection application.
7.1 Overcurrent Protection Testing (50/51)
The test should verify:
- Pickup current.
- Reset behavior.
- Operating time.
- Inverse-time characteristic.
- High-set operation.
- Directional supervision, where applicable.
- Trip output.
Example test matrix:
| Test current | Expected result |
|---|---|
| Below pickup | No operation |
| Near pickup | Pickup at specified threshold |
| Above pickup | Protection operates |
| High current | High-set function responds, if configured |
For inverse-time testing, use multiple current points and compare measured times with the configured curve.
7.2 Earth Fault Protection Testing (50N/51N)
Verify:
- Residual current measurement.
- Pickup threshold.
- Time delay.
- Directional supervision, where applicable.
- Trip output.
- Blocking conditions.
The test must reproduce the intended residual or neutral current input arrangement.
7.3 Directional Overcurrent Testing (67)
Directional overcurrent testing verifies both current magnitude and directional decision.
The test should include:
- Forward fault condition.
- Reverse fault condition.
- Polarizing voltage.
- Current phase angle.
- Pickup current.
- Operating time.
- Directional blocking.
7.4 Differential Protection Testing (87)
Differential protection testing is particularly important for transformer, generator and line protection.
Verify:
- Differential pickup.
- Restraint characteristic.
- Bias slope.
- High-set differential operation.
- External fault stability.
- CT ratio compensation.
- Phase compensation.
- Trip output.
For transformer differential protection, additional tests may include:
- Vector group compensation.
- Zero-sequence elimination.
- Magnetizing inrush restraint.
- Overexcitation restraint, where applicable.
7.5 Distance Protection Testing (21)
Distance protection testing verifies the relay’s impedance measurement and operating zones.
Typical tests include:
- Zone 1 reach.
- Zone 2 reach.
- Zone 3 reach.
- Resistive reach.
- Forward direction.
- Reverse direction.
- Operating time.
- Load encroachment.
- Power swing blocking, where configured.
A distance relay test set can simulate voltage and current conditions corresponding to specific impedance points.
7.6 Under/Overvoltage Testing (27/59)
Verify:
- Pickup voltage.
- Dropout voltage.
- Operating time.
- Voltage phase selection.
- Blocking conditions.
- Alarm and trip outputs.
7.7 Frequency Protection Testing (81)
Verify:
- Underfrequency pickup.
- Overfrequency pickup.
- Time delay.
- Frequency measurement accuracy.
- Stage coordination.
- Blocking conditions.
7.8 Breaker Failure Protection Testing (50BF)
Breaker failure protection should be tested according to the approved breaker failure philosophy.
Typical checks include:
- Breaker failure initiation.
- Current supervision.
- Breaker auxiliary contact supervision.
- Time delay.
- Retrip logic.
- Backup trip output.
7.9 Protection Function Test Matrix
| Protection function | Main test |
|---|---|
| 50/51 | Pickup and operating time |
| 50N/51N | Residual current response |
| 67 | Directional characteristic |
| 21 | Impedance zones |
| 87 | Differential characteristic |
| 27 | Undervoltage pickup |
| 59 | Overvoltage pickup |
| 81 | Frequency response |
| 50BF | Breaker failure logic |
| 49 | Thermal characteristic |
| 46 | Negative-sequence response |
| 32 | Directional power response |
| 40 | Loss-of-excitation characteristic |
Only functions actually implemented and enabled in the selected NARI relay should be included in the test plan.
8. Trip Circuit Verification
8.1 Introduction
The trip circuit is responsible for transferring the protection relay’s trip command to the circuit breaker trip coil.
A protection relay may detect a fault correctly, but if the trip circuit is defective, the circuit breaker may fail to open.
Therefore, trip circuit verification is a critical commissioning activity.
8.2 Typical Trip Circuit Architecture
NARI PROTECTION RELAY
|
Trip Output
|
Interposing
Relay
|
Trip Circuit
|
Circuit Breaker
|
Trip Coil 1
A second trip circuit may be provided where required by the protection and switchgear design.
8.3 Trip Circuit Components
Typical components include:
- Protection relay trip contact.
- Auxiliary trip relay.
- Trip circuit fuse or MCB.
- Trip coil.
- Circuit breaker auxiliary contacts.
- Trip circuit supervision relay.
- DC supply.
- Terminal blocks and wiring.
8.4 Trip Circuit Checks
Verify:
- Correct DC supply.
- Correct trip coil voltage rating.
- Correct trip relay output contact.
- Correct interposing relay connections.
- Correct circuit breaker trip coil connections.
- Auxiliary contact operation.
- Trip circuit supervision.
- Correct alarm generation.
- Correct trip indication.
- Correct breaker position feedback.
8.5 Trip Circuit Supervision
Trip Circuit Supervision (TCS) monitors the integrity of the trip circuit.
It can detect conditions such as:
- Loss of DC supply.
- Open trip circuit.
- Trip coil circuit interruption.
- Blown fuse.
- Wiring failure.
The exact supervision method depends on the circuit design and relay implementation.
8.6 Trip Circuit Functional Testing
Under an approved commissioning procedure:
- Verify the trip circuit wiring.
- Check the supervision indication.
- Simulate appropriate supervision faults.
- Verify the corresponding alarm.
- Restore the normal circuit.
- Perform a controlled trip test.
- Confirm breaker operation.
- Verify breaker auxiliary feedback.
8.7 Trip Circuit Test Matrix
| Test | Expected result |
|---|---|
| Normal DC supply | Healthy indication |
| Trip circuit interruption | TCS alarm |
| Trip command | Correct trip contact |
| Trip coil energization | Breaker operates |
| Breaker open feedback | Correct indication |
| Trip reset | Correct return to normal |
Actual circuit interruption tests must be planned to avoid unintended operation and must follow the manufacturer’s test procedure.
9. GOOSE Testing
9.1 Introduction
GOOSE is an IEC 61850 communication service used for fast exchange of event information between IEDs.
In NARI-based digital substations, GOOSE can be used for:
- Protection trip signals.
- Breaker status.
- Interlocking.
- Blocking.
- Breaker failure signals.
- Busbar protection signals.
- Transfer trip.
- Other configured binary and status information.
9.2 GOOSE Test Objectives
The commissioning engineer should verify:
- Publisher configuration.
- Subscriber configuration.
- Dataset correctness.
- GOOSE control block.
- Destination multicast MAC.
- APPID.
- VLAN ID.
- VLAN priority.
- Configuration revision.
- Signal value.
- Signal quality.
- Subscriber application response.
9.3 GOOSE Test Architecture
NARI IED - BAY 1
|
GOOSE Publisher
|
Ethernet Network
|
GOOSE Subscriber
|
NARI IED - BAY 2
|
Application Logic
|
Expected Response
9.4 GOOSE Testing with IEDScout
IEDScout can be used, subject to the supported features and device configuration, to inspect IEC 61850 data models and GOOSE communication.
A typical test includes:
- Connect the engineering workstation to the station network.
- Identify the GOOSE publisher.
- Verify the dataset.
- Inspect the GOOSE control block.
- Monitor the transmitted signal.
- Trigger a controlled change.
- Verify the received information.
- Check signal quality.
- Verify the application response.
9.5 GOOSE Testing with Wireshark
Wireshark can capture and decode GOOSE traffic.
Useful display filters include:
goose
For MMS communication:
tcp.port == 102
During analysis, verify:
- Source MAC address.
- Destination MAC address.
- APPID.
- VLAN ID.
- gocbRef.
- datSet.
- stNum.
- sqNum.
- confRev.
- timeAllowedToLive.
- Dataset values.
9.6 GOOSE Failure Testing
A complete commissioning plan should also consider communication failure.
Tests may include:
- Publisher communication loss.
- Network path interruption.
- Subscriber communication supervision.
- Invalid quality.
- Test mode.
- Recovery after communication restoration.
The expected fail-safe response must be defined in the approved protection and control design.
9.7 GOOSE Test Report
Record:
| Parameter | Result |
|---|---|
| Publisher IED | Identified |
| Subscriber IED | Identified |
| Dataset | Verified |
| APPID | Verified |
| VLAN | Verified |
| Multicast MAC | Verified |
| Signal value | Verified |
| Quality | Verified |
| Subscriber response | Verified |
| Communication failure response | Verified |
10. End-to-End Protection Testing
10.1 What Is End-to-End Testing?
End-to-end protection testing verifies the complete protection system from the measurement inputs to the final circuit breaker operation.
Unlike an individual relay test, end-to-end testing examines the interaction between multiple devices and protection system components.
It is particularly important for:
- Transmission line protection.
- Line differential protection.
- Transformer differential protection.
- Busbar protection.
- Teleprotection schemes.
- GOOSE-based protection systems.
- Interconnected protection and control systems.
10.2 Typical End-to-End Test Architecture
For a transmission line with protection relays at both terminals:
SUBSTATION A
|
OMICRON CMC A
|
NARI RELAY A
|
Communication
Channel
|
NARI RELAY B
|
OMICRON CMC B
|
SUBSTATION B
The two test systems simulate electrical conditions at both ends of the protected circuit.
10.3 Line Differential Protection Testing
For line differential protection, the test verifies that the protection relays at both ends correctly compare the measured currents.
Typical tests include:
- Normal load current.
- External fault.
- Internal fault.
- Differential pickup.
- Differential restraint.
- CT polarity verification.
- Communication channel interruption.
- Communication channel restoration.
- Trip output at both terminals.
For an internal fault, the protection system should operate according to the approved differential protection characteristic.
For an external fault, the protection should remain stable within its specified operating limits.
10.4 Distance Protection with Teleprotection
For transmission line distance protection, end-to-end tests may verify:
- Zone 1 operation.
- Zone 2 operation.
- Zone 3 operation.
- Permissive overreach transfer trip.
- Permissive underreach transfer trip.
- Blocking schemes.
- Direct transfer trip.
- Communication channel failure.
The test engineer must confirm the actual teleprotection scheme implemented in the project.
10.5 GOOSE-Based End-to-End Testing
For digital substations, end-to-end testing can verify the complete GOOSE signal chain.
Example:
- Simulate a protection pickup in Bay 1.
- Verify the internal relay signal.
- Confirm GOOSE publication.
- Verify network transmission.
- Confirm GOOSE reception in Bay 2.
- Verify the receiving logic.
- Confirm the intended output or blocking action.
- Record event timestamps.
10.6 End-to-End Test Matrix
| Test scenario | Expected response |
|---|---|
| Normal load | No unwanted operation |
| Internal fault | Correct protection operation |
| External fault | Protection stability |
| Communication interruption | Defined backup or fail-safe response |
| Communication restoration | Normal operation restored |
| GOOSE trip | Correct receiving response |
| Teleprotection command | Correct remote response |
| Breaker failure | Correct backup action |
10.7 Important Commissioning Considerations
End-to-end testing must be planned carefully.
The test team should:
- Coordinate both substations.
- Verify communication channel availability.
- Confirm protection settings at both terminals.
- Check test equipment synchronization.
- Verify current polarity and phase reference.
- Isolate actual trip circuits where required.
- Confirm test and normal operating modes.
- Record all test results.
For differential protection, current direction and reference conventions must be checked carefully. Incorrect test connections can produce misleading results.
11. Fault Record Analysis
11.1 Introduction
Fault record analysis is an essential activity following protection relay operation and during commissioning.
Modern protection relays record information about faults, protection element operation, measured quantities and trip events.
This information helps engineers understand why a relay operated and whether the protection system behaved correctly.
NARI relay recording capabilities and supported file formats depend on the individual model.
11.2 Types of Relay Records
Typical records include:
Event Records
Event records may contain:
- Protection element pickup.
- Protection trip.
- Breaker open.
- Breaker close.
- Binary input changes.
- Binary output operation.
- Communication alarms.
- Setting group changes.
Disturbance Records
Disturbance records may contain sampled electrical quantities such as:
- Phase currents.
- Phase voltages.
- Residual current.
- Frequency.
- Digital status signals.
- Protection element signals.
Fault Records
Fault records may include calculated values such as:
- Fault current.
- Fault voltage.
- Fault impedance.
- Fault type.
- Fault direction.
- Protection zone.
- Fault duration.
The exact contents depend on the relay model and recording configuration.
11.3 COMTRADE Records
COMTRADE is a standard format for exchanging transient data records from power system protection and measurement equipment.
The relevant standard is IEC 60255-24.
Common COMTRADE file components include:
| File extension | Purpose |
|---|---|
| .CFG | Configuration information |
| .DAT | Recorded sample data |
| .HDR | Optional descriptive information |
| .INF | Optional additional information |
The availability of COMTRADE export should be confirmed for the specific NARI relay.
11.4 Fault Record Analysis Workflow
A practical analysis process includes:
- Retrieve the fault record from the relay.
- Identify the fault date and time.
- Determine the protection function that operated.
- Examine phase current waveforms.
- Examine phase voltage waveforms.
- Check residual and negative-sequence quantities.
- Identify the fault type.
- Examine protection pickup and trip signals.
- Verify circuit breaker operation.
- Compare the actual operation with the approved settings.
- Determine whether the operation was correct.
- Prepare an engineering report.
11.5 Fault Type Identification
Different faults produce different current and voltage patterns.
| Fault type | Typical characteristics |
|---|---|
| Phase A to earth | High phase A and residual current |
| Phase B to earth | High phase B and residual current |
| Phase C to earth | High phase C and residual current |
| Phase A to B | High currents in phases A and B |
| Phase B to C | High currents in phases B and C |
| Phase C to A | High currents in phases C and A |
| Three-phase fault | High balanced or near-balanced phase currents |
These are simplified characteristics. Actual waveforms depend on fault location, system grounding, fault impedance, network configuration and CT behavior.
11.6 Example: Overcurrent Protection Operation
Consider a feeder relay with:
- CT ratio: 600/1 A.
- Phase overcurrent pickup: 0.8 A secondary.
- Measured fault current: 720 A primary.
The equivalent secondary current is:
\[ I_s=\frac{720}{600}=1.2A \]
The operating current is:
\[ \frac{1.2}{0.8}=1.5 \]
Therefore, the measured current is 1.5 times the configured pickup.
The engineer should compare the recorded operating time with the expected time-current characteristic.
11.7 Waveform Analysis
Waveform analysis should examine:
- Fault inception.
- Current magnitude.
- Voltage collapse.
- DC offset.
- Harmonic content.
- CT saturation.
- Protection pickup.
- Trip command.
- Circuit breaker opening.
- Fault clearance.
11.8 Sequence-of-Events Analysis
Sequence-of-events records are particularly useful for identifying the order of protection and switching operations.
For example:
| Event | Illustrative time |
|---|---|
| Overcurrent pickup | 10:15:20.100 |
| Protection trip | 10:15:20.450 |
| Breaker trip command | 10:15:20.455 |
| Breaker open indication | 10:15:20.520 |
The time differences can help engineers assess protection operation and breaker response.
Accurate time synchronization is essential when comparing events from multiple IEDs.
11.9 Common Fault Analysis Problems
| Problem | Possible cause |
|---|---|
| Incorrect current waveform | CT polarity or ratio issue |
| Incorrect voltage waveform | VT wiring or ratio issue |
| Unexpected differential current | CT compensation or wiring error |
| Incorrect directional decision | Phase sequence or polarization problem |
| Missing trip record | Recording configuration |
| Incorrect event sequence | Time synchronization issue |
| Distorted fault current | CT saturation or actual fault characteristics |
| Unexpected protection trip | Settings or logic problem |
11.10 Engineering Tools
Useful tools for fault record analysis include:
- NARI-supported relay software.
- SIGRA, where the exported record format is supported.
- OMICRON Test Universe.
- COMTRADE analysis software.
- Wireshark for communication event correlation.
- Spreadsheet tools for calculations and comparisons.
Engineers should confirm file-format compatibility before selecting an analysis application.
12. Commissioning Checklist and Test Reports
12.1 Introduction
A complete commissioning process should produce documented evidence that the NARI protection system has been configured, tested and verified according to the project requirements.
The test report should identify the equipment, test procedure, test conditions, measured results, acceptance criteria and any outstanding issues.
12.2 Relay Identification
Every test report should include:
| Information | Description |
|---|---|
| Manufacturer | NARI / NR Electric |
| Relay model | Actual device model |
| Serial number | Device serial number |
| Firmware | Installed firmware |
| Bay name | Protected equipment |
| Voltage level | System voltage |
| CT ratio | Configured ratio |
| VT ratio | Configured ratio |
| Frequency | 50 Hz or 60 Hz |
| Setting group | Active group |
| Setting file | Approved revision |
| Test date | Date of testing |
| Test engineer | Responsible person |
12.3 Recommended Test Report Structure
A professional relay testing report should include:
- Project identification.
- Equipment identification.
- Applicable drawings.
- Approved protection settings.
- Test equipment details.
- Calibration information.
- Test procedure.
- Test connections.
- Test results.
- Acceptance criteria.
- Deviations and corrective actions.
- Final assessment.
- Engineer and client approval.
12.4 Protection Relay Test Matrix
| Test category | Main verification |
|---|---|
| Visual inspection | Physical condition |
| Configuration | Correct relay settings |
| CT circuits | Ratio, polarity and continuity |
| VT circuits | Ratio, polarity and phase sequence |
| Binary inputs | Correct input operation |
| Binary outputs | Correct contact operation |
| Measurements | Current and voltage accuracy |
| Overcurrent | Pickup and time |
| Earth fault | Pickup and time |
| Directional protection | Directional characteristic |
| Differential | Bias and differential operation |
| Distance | Impedance zones |
| Voltage protection | Pickup and time |
| Frequency protection | Frequency thresholds |
| Trip circuit | Complete trip path |
| GOOSE | Publisher/subscriber operation |
| MMS | Monitoring and reporting |
| End-to-end | Complete protection scheme |
| Fault records | Record retrieval and analysis |
12.5 Final Commissioning Checklist
NARI relay testing and commissioning checklist
Interactive engineering checklist
Test completion
0/27
Relay model and firmware verifiedOriginal setting file backed upApproved setting calculations reviewedActive setting group verifiedCT ratio and polarity verifiedVT ratio and phase sequence verifiedCT and VT secondary wiring checkedBinary input tests completedBinary output tests completedCurrent measurement testedVoltage measurement testedOvercurrent protection testedEarth fault protection testedDirectional protection tested, if applicableDifferential protection tested, if applicableDistance protection tested, if applicableOther enabled protection functions testedTrip circuit supervision verifiedCircuit breaker trip circuit testedGOOSE publisher and subscriber testedMMS communication testedEnd-to-end protection tested, if applicableFault and event records retrievedFinal relay settings comparedAll test connections restoredFinal commissioning report approvedAs-built configuration backed up
Reset checklist
12.6 Acceptance Criteria
Each test should be assessed against the applicable acceptance criteria.
These may include:
- Manufacturer specifications.
- Approved protection settings.
- Project technical requirements.
- Applicable IEC standards.
- Approved testing procedures.
- Relay accuracy specifications.
- Protection coordination requirements.
A test should not be declared successful merely because the relay displays an expected value. Its functional response and the complete associated signal path must also be verified where required.
12.7 Restoration After Testing
Before returning the protection system to service, verify:
- All test plugs removed.
- All temporary test connections removed.
- CT shorting arrangements restored correctly.
- VT fuses and MCBs restored.
- Trip circuits restored.
- Binary inputs and outputs restored.
- GOOSE and MMS configurations restored.
- Correct setting group selected.
- Correct protection functions enabled.
- All temporary blocks removed.
- Relay alarms cleared.
- Final configuration backed up.
- Operational authorization obtained.
The final restoration check is essential to prevent protection systems being left in an incomplete or test condition.
13. Best Practices for NARI Relay Testing and Commissioning
Successful commissioning requires coordination between protection engineers, commissioning engineers, control engineers and substation operators.
The following practices are recommended.
13.1 Always Verify the Approved Settings
Do not rely only on the settings already stored in the relay.
Compare the actual configuration against the approved setting calculation and revision.
13.2 Test the Complete Protection Chain
Testing should cover the complete path:
CT / VT
|
v
Protection Relay
|
v
Protection Logic
|
v
Trip Output
|
v
Trip Circuit
|
v
Circuit Breaker
|
v
Breaker Feedback
|
v
SCADA / Event Recording
13.3 Maintain Test Records
Record all test results, including:
- Injected values.
- Measured values.
- Pickup thresholds.
- Operating times.
- Binary input states.
- Binary output states.
- Communication results.
- Deviations.
- Corrective actions.
13.4 Use Appropriate Test Equipment
Select test equipment according to the protection function and required test accuracy.
For example:
- Secondary injection test sets for current and voltage protection tests.
- Binary I/O test equipment for control circuit verification.
- Network analyzers for IEC 61850 communication.
- Suitable primary injection equipment for CT circuit tests, where required.
- End-to-end test systems for line differential and teleprotection applications.
13.5 Understand the Protection Philosophy
A relay can pass an individual injection test and still be incorrectly integrated into the overall protection system.
Engineers must understand:
- Protection zones.
- Main and backup protection.
- Trip matrices.
- Interlocking.
- Blocking logic.
- Breaker failure logic.
- Communication failure behavior.
- System restoration philosophy.
13.6 Maintain Configuration Control
Every setting modification should have:
- An approved change request.
- A revision number.
- An engineering justification.
- A backup of the previous configuration.
- A verification record.
- Final approval.
14. Applicable IEC Standards and Technical References
The following standards are relevant to NARI protection relay settings, testing and commissioning.
| Standard | Engineering subject |
|---|---|
| IEC 60255 series | Measuring relays and protection equipment |
| IEC 60255-1 | Common requirements |
| IEC 60255-24 | COMTRADE transient data exchange |
| IEC 61850 series | Substation communication and automation |
| IEC 61850-6 | SCL engineering |
| IEC 61850-8-1 | MMS and Ethernet mapping |
| IEC 61850-10 | Conformance testing |
| IEC 61869 series | Instrument transformers |
| IEC 60044 series | Legacy instrument transformer standards |
| IEC 60870-5-103 | Protection equipment communication |
| IEC 60870-5-104 | Telecontrol communication |
| IEC 62439-3 | PRP and HSR network redundancy |
| IEC 62351 | Power system communication security |
Additional references should include:
- NARI protection relay user manuals.
- NARI communication manuals.
- NARI engineering software documentation.
- Approved protection setting calculations.
- CT and VT test reports.
- Circuit breaker manufacturer’s documentation.
- Approved single-line diagrams.
- Protection coordination studies.
- Project commissioning specifications.
The applicable editions and project-specific requirements should always be checked.
15. NARI Protection Relay Testing and Commissioning Training by Elec-Engg
Protection Relay Testing – OMICRON
Practical relay testing and commissioning require more than understanding protection functions and reading relay manuals.
Engineers must be able to calculate settings, configure protection devices, perform secondary injection tests, verify binary circuits, analyze fault records and validate the complete protection system.
Elec-Engg provides practical training in power system protection, relay engineering, protection testing and substation automation by Dr Saeed Roostaee / Elec-Engg.
Relevant training subjects include:
- Protection relay fundamentals.
- Protection setting calculations.
- Overcurrent and earth fault protection.
- Directional overcurrent protection.
- Transformer differential protection.
- Generator protection.
- Distance protection.
- CT and VT circuit engineering.
- Secondary injection using OMICRON CMC.
- OMICRON Test Universe.
- Binary input and output testing.
- Trip circuit verification.
- Protection coordination.
- IEC 61850 communication.
- GOOSE testing.
- IEDScout and Wireshark.
- End-to-end protection testing.
- COMTRADE and fault record analysis.
- Protection relay commissioning documentation.
Training is available through structured online learning, recorded technical courses, live online sessions and customized face-to-face or in-house training.
For NARI-specific training programs, exercises can be adapted to the actual relay models, available engineering software, firmware versions and technical documentation supplied by the organization.
Explore Elec-Engg training:
- Elec-Engg — Power System Protection and Substation Automation
- Substation Automation Training
- Structured Self-Paced Training
- Pre-Recorded Video Training
16. Conclusion
NARI protection relay settings, testing and commissioning are essential activities for ensuring the reliability, selectivity and operational performance of electrical protection systems.
Successful commissioning requires a systematic approach covering the complete protection chain, from instrument transformer circuits and relay settings to trip circuits, communication systems and circuit breaker operation.
The most important engineering activities include:
- Understanding NARI relay setting files and configuration.
- Calculating and verifying protection settings.
- Managing setting groups.
- Testing binary inputs and outputs.
- Verifying CT and VT circuits.
- Performing secondary injection testing.
- Testing individual protection functions.
- Verifying trip circuits.
- Testing IEC 61850 GOOSE communication.
- Performing end-to-end protection tests.
- Analyzing fault and disturbance records.
- Preparing complete commissioning checklists and test reports.
Engineers who combine protection theory, setting calculations, practical testing and communication engineering can commission and maintain NARI protection systems more effectively.
A properly commissioned protection system is not simply a relay that passes an injection test. It is a complete, verified protection chain that detects faults, makes the correct protection decision, operates the intended circuit breaker and provides reliable event information for system operation and fault investigation.
