- 1. Introduction
- 2. Objectives of Protection Relay Testing
- 3. GE Multilin Relay Families and Testing Applications
- 4. Preparation Before Testing
- 5. Visual Inspection and Hardware Verification
- 6. CT and VT Input Verification
- 7. Secondary Injection Testing
- 8. Overcurrent Protection Testing (ANSI 50/51)
- 9. Earth Fault Protection Testing (ANSI 50N/51N)
- 10. Directional Overcurrent Testing (ANSI 67/67N)
- 11. Transformer Differential Protection Testing (ANSI 87T)
- 12. Line Differential Protection Testing (ANSI 87L)
- 13. Distance Protection Testing (ANSI 21)
- 14. Generator Protection Testing
- 15. Motor Protection Testing
- 16. Binary Input and Output Testing
- 17. Trip Circuit and Circuit-Breaker Verification
- 18. Autoreclosing and Synchronism Check Testing
- 19. IEC 61850 Communication Testing
- 20. Using EnerVista During Commissioning
- 21. Practical Commissioning Example: GE Multilin Feeder Relay
- 22. Common Testing and Commissioning Problems
- 23. Protection Relay Commissioning Report
- 24. Best Practices for GE Multilin Relay Testing
- 25. Conclusion
- 26. Training on GE Multilin Protection Relays and Testing by Elec-Engg
- 27. Frequently Asked Questions
- What is secondary injection testing?
- Which test equipment can be used for GE Multilin relays?
- Is secondary injection enough for relay commissioning?
- How do you test GE Multilin overcurrent protection?
- How do you test transformer differential protection?
- Why should the circuit-breaker trip circuit be tested?
- Should IEC 61850 communication be included in commissioning?
1. Introduction
Protection relay testing and commissioning are essential activities in the installation, maintenance and operation of electrical power systems. A protection relay may have sophisticated algorithms and advanced communication capabilities, but its reliability depends on correct configuration, wiring, settings, logic and interaction with the complete protection system.
GE Multilin protection relays are used in applications such as:
- Distribution feeder protection.
- Transformer differential protection.
- Generator protection.
- Motor protection.
- Transmission line protection.
- Busbar protection.
- Industrial power system protection.
Depending on the relay model, engineers may use EnerVista software to configure settings, monitor measurements, inspect event records and manage relay configuration files.
Commissioning must verify more than whether the relay operates during a secondary injection test. It should establish that the complete protection chain works correctly, from the instrument transformer inputs through the relay logic and output contacts to the circuit-breaker trip circuit.
This article presents a practical approach to GE Multilin protection relay testing and commissioning, covering preparation, secondary injection, functional testing, trip circuit verification, communication checks, troubleshooting and documentation.
Important safety note: Testing must be performed by qualified personnel using approved procedures, suitable test equipment and the site’s safety rules. Primary equipment must be placed in an appropriate safe condition before any test that could initiate a trip or affect protection availability.
2. Objectives of Protection Relay Testing
Protection relay testing has several objectives.
2.1 Verify Correct Relay Configuration
The relay must contain the correct application configuration, including:
- Relay identification.
- CT and VT ratios.
- Protection functions.
- Pickup settings.
- Time delays.
- Protection characteristics.
- Input and output assignments.
- Programmable logic.
- Trip matrix.
- Communication configuration.
2.2 Verify Protection Element Operation
The test must establish that each required protection function responds correctly to its operating conditions.
Examples include:
| Protection function | ANSI number | Typical test objective |
|---|---|---|
| Phase overcurrent | 50/51 | Verify pickup and operating time |
| Earth fault | 50N/51N | Verify residual or neutral current response |
| Directional overcurrent | 67/67N | Verify forward and reverse operation |
| Transformer differential | 87T | Verify differential operation and stability |
| Line differential | 87L | Verify internal and external fault response |
| Distance protection | 21 | Verify impedance zones and timing |
| Generator differential | 87G | Verify stator differential operation |
| Thermal overload | 49 | Verify thermal model response |
| Negative sequence | 46 | Verify negative-sequence response |
| Under/overvoltage | 27/59 | Verify voltage thresholds and delays |
| Under/overfrequency | 81 | Verify frequency thresholds and delays |
| Breaker failure | 50BF | Verify breaker failure initiation and timing |
| Autoreclosing | 79 | Verify reclosing sequence and permissives |
| Synchronism check | 25 | Verify voltage, angle and frequency conditions |
The actual protection functions available depend on the relay model and firmware.
2.3 Verify the Complete Trip Chain
A protection function can operate correctly inside the relay while the circuit-breaker fails to trip because of an external problem.
The complete chain may include:
- CT or VT secondary circuit.
- Relay measurement input.
- Protection element.
- Programmable logic.
- Output contact.
- Interposing relay, where applicable.
- Trip circuit supervision.
- Circuit-breaker trip coil.
- Circuit-breaker mechanism.
- Auxiliary contacts and status feedback.
Commissioning must verify the relevant parts of this chain.
3. GE Multilin Relay Families and Testing Applications
Different GE Multilin relay families require different testing approaches.
| Relay or family | Typical application | Main testing focus |
|---|---|---|
| 350 | Feeder protection | Overcurrent, earth fault, breaker control |
| 850 | Feeder protection | Protection, automation and control |
| 339 | Motor protection | Thermal, starting, overload and fault protection |
| 369 | Motor protection | Thermal model, RTDs and motor starting |
| 469 | Motor protection | Motor protection and thermal monitoring |
| 869 | Motor protection | Advanced motor protection functions |
| T60 | Transformer protection | Differential, REF and transformer backup |
| 845 | Transformer protection | Transformer differential and associated functions |
| D60 | Distance protection | Impedance zones and distance elements |
| D30 | Distance protection | Distance protection and backup functions |
| L90 | Line differential | Differential protection and channel supervision |
| G60 | Generator protection | Generator differential and generator protection |
| G30 | Generator protection | Generator protection functions |
| B30 | Busbar protection | Bus differential and zone logic |
| B90 | Busbar protection | Bus differential and associated logic |
This table is a general application guide, not a statement that all functions or test methods are identical across models.
4. Preparation Before Testing
A well-planned test reduces commissioning time and helps prevent incorrect conclusions.
4.1 Collect the Required Documents
Before connecting the test equipment, obtain:
- Approved single-line diagram.
- Protection coordination study.
- Protection relay settings.
- Relay logic diagrams.
- AC schematic drawings.
- DC schematic drawings.
- CT and VT wiring diagrams.
- Circuit-breaker control drawings.
- Trip matrix.
- Communication architecture.
- Manufacturer relay manual.
- Applicable test procedures.
The engineer should use the latest approved revision of the settings and drawings.
4.2 Verify Relay Identification
Record:
- Manufacturer.
- Relay model.
- Serial number.
- Hardware revision, where applicable.
- Firmware version.
- Application or settings file revision.
- Panel and bay identification.
- CT and VT ratios.
- Auxiliary supply rating.
This information is particularly important when testing a replacement relay or comparing results between maintenance periods.
4.3 Check the Test Equipment
Typical equipment includes:
- Secondary injection test set.
- Current and voltage injection leads.
- Binary input and output connections.
- Laptop with the applicable EnerVista software.
- Communication cables.
- Multimeter.
- Approved test leads and accessories.
- Insulation and continuity test equipment where appropriate.
- Oscilloscope or network analyzer for specialized tests.
An Omicron CMC test set with an appropriate Test Universe configuration is one example of equipment that can be used for relay testing. Other compatible test systems may also be suitable.
4.4 Safety and Isolation
Before testing:
- Obtain the required work permit.
- Identify all possible sources of current and voltage.
- Apply the approved isolation procedure.
- Isolate trip outputs where required by the test plan.
- Confirm that no unintended breaker operation can occur.
- Apply CT shorting procedures before disconnecting CT secondary circuits.
- Verify the test equipment connections.
- Confirm that the relay is in the intended test condition.
Never open-circuit an energized CT secondary circuit. CT secondary circuits must be handled using approved shorting and isolation procedures.
5. Visual Inspection and Hardware Verification
Before applying injection signals, inspect the relay and its installation.
5.1 Front Panel Inspection
Check:
- Display condition.
- Keypad operation.
- LEDs.
- Alarm indications.
- Relay identification.
- Communication port condition.
- Any visible physical damage.
5.2 Rear Panel Inspection
Inspect:
- CT input terminals.
- VT input terminals.
- Binary input terminals.
- Output relay terminals.
- Auxiliary supply terminals.
- Communication ports.
- Earthing connections.
- Terminal tightness according to the approved installation procedure.
5.3 Auxiliary Supply
Verify the relay auxiliary supply against its nameplate and technical documentation.
Check:
- Correct DC or AC supply type.
- Correct nominal voltage.
- Correct polarity where applicable.
- Fuse or miniature circuit-breaker rating.
- Supply stability.
- Protective earthing.
Do not assume that all GE Multilin relays use the same auxiliary supply range.
5.4 Hardware Configuration
For modular devices, confirm that the installed modules match the approved configuration.
This may include:
- CPU module.
- Power supply module.
- CT input module.
- VT input module.
- Binary input module.
- Output relay module.
- Communication module.
Incorrect module selection or an incompatible hardware configuration may affect available functions and I/O assignments.
6. CT and VT Input Verification
Incorrect CT or VT configuration is a common cause of protection misoperation.
6.1 CT Ratio Verification
Assume a feeder uses a CT ratio of:
[
600/1\text{ A}
]
If the primary current is 300 A, the relay secondary current should be:
[
I_s=\frac{300}{600}=0.5\text{ A}
]
During testing, inject a suitable secondary current and compare the relay’s displayed measurement with the expected value.
For example, injecting 0.5 A should produce a corresponding measurement based on the configured ratio and measurement scaling.
6.2 Phase Assignment
Verify that:
- Phase A current is connected to the correct input.
- Phase B current is connected to the correct input.
- Phase C current is connected to the correct input.
- Residual or neutral current is connected correctly.
- Phase sequence is correct.
A phase assignment error may affect directional, differential and other phase-dependent functions.
6.3 CT Polarity
CT polarity must be checked against the approved wiring diagram.
Incorrect polarity can cause:
- Incorrect directional measurements.
- False differential current.
- Incorrect residual current.
- Unwanted protection operation.
6.4 VT Ratio and Phase Assignment
Verify the configured VT ratio and the actual secondary voltage connection.
For a 33 kV/110 V phase-to-phase VT ratio:
[
V_s=\frac{V_p}{300}
]
For a primary voltage of 33 kV:
[
V_s=110\text{ V}
]
The relay’s voltage measurement should be consistent with the actual VT connection and configured scaling.
6.5 Phase Rotation
Inject balanced three-phase voltage signals and verify:
- Phase sequence.
- Voltage magnitude.
- Phase angle relationships.
- Correct phase identification.
This is particularly important for directional protection, distance protection, synchronism check and power measurement functions.
7. Secondary Injection Testing
Secondary injection is one of the main methods used to verify protection relay performance.
The test equipment supplies controlled current and voltage signals directly to the relay’s secondary input circuits.
This allows the engineer to test protection elements without creating an actual primary system fault.
7.1 General Secondary Injection Procedure
A typical procedure is:
- Confirm the approved settings.
- Verify CT and VT configuration.
- Connect the test equipment to the appropriate relay inputs.
- Verify the test set output configuration.
- Apply the required current and voltage.
- Monitor the relay measurements.
- Confirm the protection element pickup.
- Measure the operating time.
- Verify the relay output or assigned logic signal.
- Record the results.
- Restore the relay and associated circuits to the approved service condition.
The exact procedure depends on the relay model and protection function.
7.2 Current Injection
Current injection is used for testing:
- Phase overcurrent.
- Earth fault.
- Negative sequence.
- Differential protection.
- Thermal protection.
- Current-based directional elements.
- Other current-dependent functions.
7.3 Voltage Injection
Voltage injection is used for testing:
- Undervoltage.
- Overvoltage.
- Frequency functions where voltage input is required.
- Distance protection.
- Directional polarization.
- Synchronism check.
- Loss-of-potential supervision.
7.4 Combined Current and Voltage Injection
Some functions require both current and voltage signals.
Examples include:
- Directional overcurrent.
- Distance protection.
- Power protection.
- Loss-of-excitation protection.
- Synchronism check.
These tests require careful control of phase angles, magnitudes and sequence components.
8. Overcurrent Protection Testing (ANSI 50/51)
Overcurrent testing verifies that the relay operates when the measured current exceeds the configured pickup value.
8.1 Pickup Test
Assume the configured phase overcurrent pickup is:
[
I_{pickup}=1.2\text{ A}
]
The engineer gradually increases the injected current and records the value at which the relay indicates pickup.
The measured pickup should be compared with the approved acceptance criteria and manufacturer’s specified tolerance.
8.2 Instantaneous Overcurrent Test (ANSI 50)
For instantaneous protection:
- Verify the configured pickup.
- Apply current below pickup.
- Confirm that the element does not operate.
- Increase current above pickup.
- Record the pickup value.
- Measure operating time.
- Verify the correct output logic.
The test must consider any intentional delay or additional logic associated with the element.
8.3 Inverse-Time Overcurrent Test (ANSI 51)
Inverse-time protection requires verification of the operating time at selected current multiples.
A commonly used IEC standard inverse-time equation is:
[
t=\frac{0.14 \times TMS}{M^{0.02}-1}
]
Where:
- (t) = operating time in seconds.
- (TMS) = time multiplier setting.
- (M) = fault current divided by pickup current.
This equation applies to the IEC standard inverse characteristic. Other curve families use different equations.
8.4 Practical Example
Assume:
- Pickup current = 1 A.
- Injected current = 5 A.
- Time multiplier = 0.1.
- Curve = IEC standard inverse.
Then:
[
M=\frac{5}{1}=5
]
[
t=\frac{0.14\times0.1}{5^{0.02}-1}
]
[
t\approx0.43\text{ s}
]
The expected operating time is approximately 0.43 seconds before considering additional delays or implementation-specific effects.
The measured result should be compared against the relay’s specified tolerance and the approved test criteria.
9. Earth Fault Protection Testing (ANSI 50N/51N)
Earth fault protection can use residual current calculated from phase currents or a separate neutral/core-balance CT input.
9.1 Residual Current Calculation
Residual current is:
[
I_N=I_A+I_B+I_C
]
Under balanced load conditions:
[
I_N\approx0
]
For an earth fault, residual current may become significant.
9.2 Testing Residual Earth Fault
A typical test procedure is:
- Confirm the relay’s earth fault measurement method.
- Verify the CT configuration.
- Apply the required phase-current combination.
- Confirm the calculated residual current.
- Increase current above pickup.
- Record the pickup value.
- Measure the operating time.
- Verify the correct output.
9.3 Core-Balance CT Testing
Where a core-balance CT is used, test the correct input circuit and confirm that the relay displays and processes the signal as intended.
Do not assume that a residual current calculated from three phase CTs behaves identically to a separate core-balance CT input.
10. Directional Overcurrent Testing (ANSI 67/67N)
Directional overcurrent testing requires controlled current and voltage injection.
The relay evaluates the relationship between operating current and its polarizing quantity.
10.1 Test Objectives
Verify:
- Correct current input.
- Correct voltage input.
- Phase rotation.
- CT polarity.
- VT polarity.
- Directional characteristic.
- Forward operation.
- Reverse operation.
- Pickup and timing.
10.2 Test Procedure
- Configure the test set for the correct phase relationship.
- Apply the required polarizing voltage.
- Inject current above the overcurrent pickup.
- Set the phase angle to the expected forward operating region.
- Verify directional permission and element operation.
- Change the angle to the reverse region.
- Verify that the forward element does not operate.
- Repeat for the relevant phases and earth fault directional elements.
The actual operating angle and polarizing method must be taken from the relay configuration and manufacturer documentation.
11. Transformer Differential Protection Testing (ANSI 87T)
Transformer differential testing verifies the relay’s ability to distinguish internal faults from external faults and normal operating conditions.
GE Multilin transformer protection applications may use relays such as T60 and 845, depending on the project and model capabilities.
11.1 Differential Protection Principle
The basic differential current is derived from the compensated currents entering and leaving the protected zone.
For a simplified two-terminal example:
[
I_{diff}=|I_1-I_2|
]
The actual relay calculation may include ratio matching, phase compensation, zero-sequence compensation and restraint calculations.
11.2 Test Objectives
Verify:
- CT ratio configuration.
- Transformer vector-group compensation.
- Phase compensation.
- Differential pickup.
- Bias or restraint characteristic.
- External fault stability.
- Inrush restraint, where applicable.
- Overexcitation restraint, where applicable.
- REF protection, where configured.
- Trip output operation.
11.3 Differential Pickup Test
Inject currents representing an internal fault condition.
Gradually increase the differential current and determine the pickup threshold.
Compare the result with the configured characteristic and specified acceptance criteria.
11.4 Restraint Test
Apply current combinations representing external faults or through-current conditions.
Verify that the relay remains stable under the expected restraint conditions.
11.5 Inrush Restraint Test
Where supported, test the inrush restraint logic using an approved test method.
The test should verify that the relay responds according to its configured inrush discrimination method.
The exact procedure depends on the relay’s implementation and available test functions.
12. Line Differential Protection Testing (ANSI 87L)
Line differential protection requires particular attention to communication between terminal relays.
A line differential system compares current information from different ends of the protected line.
12.1 Main Test Objectives
- Local current measurement.
- Remote current measurement.
- Differential operating characteristic.
- External fault stability.
- Communication channel supervision.
- Channel failure response.
- Trip output.
- End-to-end operation.
12.2 Local Secondary Injection
Local injection can verify the local current inputs and selected relay functions.
However, it does not replace end-to-end testing of the complete differential scheme.
12.3 End-to-End Testing
An end-to-end test should coordinate test equipment at both line terminals.
The test plan should include:
- Normal through-current conditions.
- Internal fault conditions.
- External fault conditions.
- Different fault types.
- Communication interruption.
- Restoration of communication.
- Trip logic verification.
The test equipment and method must support the required synchronization and coordination between test locations.
12.4 Communication Channel Testing
Verify:
- Channel availability.
- Correct terminal identification.
- Communication delay and quality.
- Channel supervision.
- Alarm generation.
- Behavior during channel interruption.
13. Distance Protection Testing (ANSI 21)
Distance protection is based on the apparent impedance calculated from measured voltage and current.
[
Z=\frac{V}{I}
]
Testing verifies the relay’s impedance measurement and operating characteristics.
13.1 Test Objectives
- Correct CT and VT scaling.
- Correct phase selection.
- Positive-sequence impedance configuration.
- Zero-sequence compensation.
- Zone reach.
- Zone timing.
- Mho or quadrilateral characteristics.
- Fault resistance coverage.
- Load encroachment.
- Power swing blocking, where applicable.
- Communication-assisted schemes, where applicable.
13.2 Impedance Injection
A distance relay test set applies voltage and current signals corresponding to a selected impedance point.
The engineer can test points:
- Inside Zone 1.
- Outside Zone 1 but inside Zone 2.
- Inside Zone 3.
- Outside the protection characteristic.
- Within the reverse zone, where configured.
13.3 Zone Timing
For each zone:
- Select the intended impedance point.
- Apply the corresponding voltage and current.
- Verify pickup.
- Measure operating time.
- Compare the result with the configured delay.
- Confirm the correct trip logic.
A complete test should include points near the characteristic boundaries according to the approved test specification.
14. Generator Protection Testing
Generator protection requires careful testing because the protection system may include several independent functions with different operating quantities and time characteristics.
GE Multilin generator protection applications may include G60, G30 and 889 models, depending on the installation.
Typical functions include:
- Generator differential (87G).
- Stator earth fault protection (64G).
- Loss of excitation (40).
- Reverse power (32).
- Negative sequence (46).
- Thermal protection (49).
- Overvoltage and undervoltage (59/27).
- Underfrequency and overfrequency (81).
- Out-of-step protection (78).
14.1 Reverse Power Test
Reverse power protection detects active power flowing into the generator under defined conditions.
Testing requires controlled current and voltage signals with the appropriate phase relationship.
Verify:
- Forward power measurement.
- Reverse power measurement.
- Pickup threshold.
- Time delay.
- Trip logic.
14.2 Negative Sequence Test
Negative sequence protection detects unbalanced current conditions.
The test set must generate the required negative-sequence current components.
Verify pickup, timing and alarm/trip behavior.
14.3 Loss-of-Excitation Test
Loss-of-excitation protection may use impedance-based characteristics.
Testing requires controlled voltage and current phasors to simulate the intended operating points.
The engineer must verify the configured characteristics and time delays.
14.4 Stator Differential Test
Verify current input polarity, phase matching, differential pickup, restraint and trip logic.
The test must account for the generator’s CT locations and the approved protection zone.
15. Motor Protection Testing
Motor protection testing must consider both electrical protection and thermal behavior.
GE Multilin motor protection relays may include 339, 369, 469 and 869 models.
Typical functions include:
- Thermal overload (49).
- Phase overcurrent (50/51).
- Earth fault protection.
- Negative sequence (46).
- Locked rotor protection.
- Starting supervision (48).
- Starts-per-hour limitation (66).
- Undercurrent (37).
- Voltage protection.
- RTD temperature monitoring, where supported.
15.1 Thermal Overload Testing
Verify the configured motor thermal model using the manufacturer’s recommended test procedure.
The test may involve current injection, thermal capacity monitoring and controlled thermal reset behavior.
15.2 Starting Protection
Verify:
- Starting current supervision.
- Starting time.
- Acceleration time.
- Locked rotor threshold.
- Starts-per-hour logic.
- Restart inhibition.
15.3 RTD Testing
Where RTD inputs are installed, use a suitable resistance simulator or approved sensor test method.
Verify:
- Correct RTD type.
- Temperature indication.
- Alarm threshold.
- Trip threshold.
- Sensor failure indication.
16. Binary Input and Output Testing
Binary I/O testing is essential because protection logic depends on correct external signals.
16.1 Binary Input Testing
Typical binary inputs include:
- Circuit-breaker auxiliary contacts.
- Isolator status.
- Disconnector status.
- External trip.
- Protection blocking.
- Remote permissive.
- Local/remote selection.
- Reset input.
A typical test procedure is:
- Identify the input from the approved schematic.
- Confirm the required input voltage.
- Apply the appropriate test signal.
- Verify the relay input indication.
- Verify the associated logic.
- Confirm the expected alarm or control response.
The input voltage range and polarity must match the specific relay hardware.
16.2 Binary Output Testing
Binary outputs may be assigned to:
- Main trip.
- Backup trip.
- Alarm.
- Breaker close.
- Breaker open.
- Lockout.
- External interlocking.
Verify the correct output contact and its assigned function.
16.3 Output Contact Verification
Use a suitable continuity or contact monitoring method to confirm the output state.
Where the output operates an external circuit, verify the complete external path under an approved test arrangement.
17. Trip Circuit and Circuit-Breaker Verification
The relay trip output is only one part of the complete trip system.
The trip circuit must be tested to establish that the circuit-breaker receives and executes the trip command.
17.1 Trip Circuit Components
A typical trip circuit may include:
- DC supply.
- Protective fuse or circuit-breaker.
- Relay output contact.
- Interposing relay.
- Trip coil.
- Circuit-breaker auxiliary contacts.
- Trip circuit supervision.
- Associated wiring and terminals.
17.2 Trip Output Test
Verify:
- The protection element operates.
- The correct logic signal is generated.
- The assigned output contact changes state.
- The trip circuit receives the command.
- The breaker responds as intended.
- The breaker auxiliary contact changes state.
- The relay receives the correct breaker status feedback.
17.3 Trip Circuit Supervision
Where trip circuit supervision is implemented, verify the supervision function according to the circuit design and relay documentation.
The test should confirm that the system identifies the specified open-circuit or abnormal trip circuit conditions.
17.4 Breaker Failure Protection (ANSI 50BF)
Breaker failure testing should verify:
- Initiation signal.
- Current supervision, where used.
- Breaker status supervision, where used.
- Timer operation.
- Retrip logic.
- Backup trip output.
- Reset conditions.
The test must confirm the actual configured scheme, not just the timer operation.
18. Autoreclosing and Synchronism Check Testing
18.1 Autoreclosing (ANSI 79)
Autoreclosing testing may include:
- Initiation conditions.
- Dead time.
- Reclaim time.
- Reclose attempts.
- Lockout conditions.
- Breaker ready status.
- Voltage supervision.
- Blocking signals.
The engineer should test the complete sequence under controlled conditions.
18.2 Synchronism Check (ANSI 25)
Synchronism check verifies that two electrical systems satisfy defined conditions before closing a circuit-breaker.
Typical quantities include:
- Voltage magnitude difference.
- Frequency difference.
- Phase angle difference.
- Closing-time compensation, where supported.
The test should verify both permissive and blocking conditions.
19. IEC 61850 Communication Testing
Where the relay is used in an IEC 61850 system, commissioning should include communication testing.
19.1 MMS Tests
Verify:
- Server availability.
- Client association.
- Logical device and logical node access.
- Required data attributes.
- Dataset configuration.
- Buffered and unbuffered reports, where supported.
- Event reporting.
- Control services, where used.
19.2 GOOSE Tests
Verify:
- Publisher configuration.
- Subscriber configuration.
- Dataset mapping.
- APPID.
- Multicast MAC address.
- VLAN settings.
- Message transmission.
- Subscriber reception.
- Application logic response.
- Communication failure behavior.
19.3 Tools
Tools may include:
- IEDScout.
- Wireshark.
- Manufacturer engineering software.
- Station automation engineering tools.
- Suitable IEC 61850 test equipment.
A successful packet capture does not prove that the protection scheme works correctly. Functional testing must verify the subscriber logic and final application response.
20. Using EnerVista During Commissioning
EnerVista is used with supported GE Multilin products for relay engineering, configuration and monitoring.
Depending on the relay model and software version, the engineer may use it to:
- Connect to the relay.
- Retrieve settings.
- Inspect measurements.
- Review protection element status.
- Monitor binary inputs and outputs.
- Review event records.
- Retrieve oscillography.
- Upload approved settings.
- Save configuration backups.
20.1 Before Testing
Retrieve and save the existing relay configuration where possible.
Record:
- Relay identification.
- Firmware version.
- Settings revision.
- Communication configuration.
- Date and time.
- Existing alarms.
20.2 During Testing
Monitor:
- Measured currents.
- Measured voltages.
- Protection element pickup.
- Protection element operation.
- Logic status.
- Binary inputs.
- Binary outputs.
- Event records.
20.3 After Testing
Save the final approved configuration and verify that no unintended setting or logic changes remain.
The exact software functions and connection procedures depend on the relay model and EnerVista version.
21. Practical Commissioning Example: GE Multilin Feeder Relay
Consider an 11 kV feeder protected by a GE Multilin feeder relay.
Assume:
- CT ratio: 300/1 A.
- Maximum feeder load: 180 A.
- Phase overcurrent pickup: 1.2 A secondary.
- Earth fault pickup: 0.2 A secondary.
- Instantaneous overcurrent enabled according to the approved study.
The commissioning procedure may include the following stages.
Stage 1: Configuration Verification
Confirm the relay model, CT ratio, pickup settings, curve type, time multiplier and trip logic.
Stage 2: Measurement Verification
Inject 0.5 A secondary current.
The expected primary current indication is:
[
I_p=0.5\times300=150\text{ A}
]
Compare the relay measurement with the expected value.
Stage 3: Phase Overcurrent Pickup
Apply current gradually and verify pickup around the configured 1.2 A threshold, subject to the relay’s specified tolerance.
Stage 4: Time-Current Test
Inject a selected current multiple and measure the operating time.
Compare the measured result with the selected curve and time multiplier.
Stage 5: Earth Fault Test
Apply the appropriate residual or neutral current test signal and verify the earth fault element.
Stage 6: Binary I/O Test
Verify breaker status inputs, trip outputs and required alarms.
Stage 7: Trip Circuit Test
Under the approved isolation and test procedure, verify the trip output and breaker response.
Stage 8: Final Verification
Restore all circuits, verify relay status, confirm the final settings revision and complete the commissioning report.
The numerical values above are illustrative. Actual settings and acceptance limits must be based on the approved protection study, relay documentation and project test specification.
22. Common Testing and Commissioning Problems
Problem 1: Relay Does Not Pick Up
Possible causes:
- Incorrect injection connection.
- Incorrect CT input selection.
- Wrong pickup setting.
- Incorrect phase assignment.
- Wrong current scaling.
- Element disabled.
- Blocking logic active.
Recommended checks:
- Verify the injection circuit.
- Inspect live measurements.
- Confirm the active settings group.
- Check element enable status.
- Inspect the logic and blocking conditions.
Problem 2: Relay Picks Up at the Wrong Current
Possible causes:
- Incorrect CT ratio.
- Incorrect input rating.
- Incorrect test set scaling.
- Wrong setting group.
- Measurement scaling or wiring problem.
Check the configured ratio, the actual input connection and the test equipment output.
Problem 3: Operating Time Is Incorrect
Possible causes:
- Incorrect curve selection.
- Wrong time multiplier.
- Additional logic delay.
- Definite-time setting.
- Test current not as expected.
- Incorrect timing method.
Check the complete protection characteristic and any associated timers.
Problem 4: Protection Operates but No Trip Output Occurs
Possible causes:
- Incorrect programmable logic.
- Output contact not assigned.
- Output contact disabled.
- Trip matrix error.
- Blocking condition.
- Incorrect output terminal wiring.
Monitor the element status, logic signal and physical output contact separately.
Problem 5: Relay Trips but Breaker Does Not Open
Possible causes:
- Open trip circuit.
- DC supply failure.
- Incorrect trip coil wiring.
- Defective trip coil.
- Incorrect interposing relay wiring.
- Breaker mechanical problem.
Investigate the complete trip circuit and breaker mechanism using the approved procedures.
Problem 6: Incorrect Current or Voltage Measurements
Possible causes:
- Incorrect CT/VT ratio.
- Incorrect phase assignment.
- Wrong polarity.
- Wiring errors.
- Incorrect test set connection.
- Incorrect relay configuration.
Verify each input against the approved schematic.
23. Protection Relay Commissioning Report
A professional commissioning report should contain sufficient information to reproduce and review the test.
Recommended contents include:
General Information
- Project name.
- Substation name.
- Bay identification.
- Relay manufacturer.
- Relay model.
- Serial number.
- Firmware version.
- Test date.
- Test engineer.
Test Equipment
- Test equipment manufacturer.
- Model.
- Serial number.
- Calibration status.
- Software version, where applicable.
Settings Information
- CT ratio.
- VT ratio.
- Protection settings.
- Active settings group.
- Settings revision.
- Logic revision.
- Communication configuration.
Test Results
For each protection function, record:
- Test objective.
- Applied current.
- Applied voltage.
- Phase angle.
- Expected pickup.
- Measured pickup.
- Expected operating time.
- Measured operating time.
- Output contact status.
- Pass/fail result.
- Comments.
Final Commissioning Status
Record:
- Outstanding defects.
- Corrective actions.
- Restored circuit status.
- Final configuration backup.
- Test engineer approval.
- Client or commissioning authority approval.
24. Best Practices for GE Multilin Relay Testing
- Always use the approved relay settings.
- Verify the relay model and firmware before selecting a test procedure.
- Check CT and VT wiring before functional testing.
- Confirm the active settings group.
- Test each protection function individually before testing combined logic.
- Verify the physical output contacts.
- Test the complete trip chain where required.
- Include communication testing for IEC 61850 applications.
- Verify breaker failure and autoreclosing logic where installed.
- Record actual measurements and operating times.
- Save the original and final relay configuration.
- Restore all protection circuits after testing.
- Confirm that temporary blocks and test links are removed.
- Perform an independent review of critical protection settings and trip logic.
- Never rely on a single successful injection test as proof of complete protection system integrity.
25. Conclusion
Testing and commissioning GE Multilin protection relays requires a structured approach that covers hardware, configuration, measurements, protection elements, programmable logic, communication and circuit-breaker operation.
Secondary injection is an essential tool for verifying relay performance, but it must be combined with wiring checks, binary I/O testing, functional logic verification and complete trip circuit testing.
For advanced applications such as transformer differential, line differential, distance protection, generator protection and IEC 61850 communication, the test procedure must be designed around the actual protection scheme and relay implementation.
A reliable commissioning process produces more than a relay that operates during a test. It provides documented evidence that the protection system performs its intended function under normal, abnormal and fault conditions.
26. Training on GE Multilin Protection Relays and Testing by Elec-Engg
Elec-Engg provides practical technical training by Dr Saeed Roostaee (Electrical Engineering), focusing on protection relay engineering, testing, commissioning and substation automation.
Relevant training subjects include:
- GE Multilin relay architecture and configuration.
- EnerVista software.
- CT and VT circuit verification.
- Secondary injection testing.
- Overcurrent and earth fault protection testing.
- Directional protection testing.
- Transformer differential protection testing.
- Line differential and distance protection testing.
- Generator and motor protection testing.
- Binary input and output verification.
- Trip circuit and breaker failure testing.
- IEC 61850 MMS and GOOSE communication testing.
- Practical test procedures using Omicron CMC and Test Universe.
Training delivery options include:
- Pre-recorded technical video courses.
- Structured self-paced training.
- Live online training.
- Face-to-face technical training.
- Customized in-house programs for utilities, industries and engineering companies.
Explore technical training: https://elec-engg.com/
Contact Elec-Engg: https://elec-engg.com/contact/
27. Frequently Asked Questions
What is secondary injection testing?
Secondary injection testing applies controlled current and voltage signals directly to a protection relay’s secondary input circuits. It verifies measurement accuracy, protection pickup, operating time and selected logic functions without injecting current into the primary power system.
Which test equipment can be used for GE Multilin relays?
Suitable relay test equipment can include Omicron CMC test sets with appropriate Test Universe modules, as well as other compatible secondary injection systems. The test equipment must support the required current, voltage, phase angle, timing and binary I/O tests.
Is secondary injection enough for relay commissioning?
No. Commissioning may also require wiring verification, CT/VT circuit checks, binary I/O tests, trip circuit tests, communication tests and end-to-end functional testing.
How do you test GE Multilin overcurrent protection?
Inject current into the appropriate relay input, verify pickup, measure operating time and compare the results with the configured characteristic and approved acceptance criteria.
How do you test transformer differential protection?
Apply current combinations representing internal and external fault conditions. Verify differential pickup, restraint stability, bias characteristics and associated trip logic using the manufacturer’s recommended test method.
Why should the circuit-breaker trip circuit be tested?
A relay can operate correctly while the breaker fails to trip because of a wiring defect, DC supply problem, output contact problem, trip coil defect or mechanical failure. Testing the complete trip chain helps identify these problems.
Should IEC 61850 communication be included in commissioning?
Yes, when the relay participates in an IEC 61850 system. MMS, GOOSE, datasets, reporting, time synchronization and communication failure behavior should be tested according to the approved project specification.
