NARI Generator Protection: Complete Engineering Guide to Protection Functions, PCS-985 Relays, Settings, Applications, Commissioning and Testing
- 1. Introduction to NARI Generator Protection
- 2. NARI PCS-985 Generator Protection Relay
- 3. Generator Differential Protection (ANSI 87G)
- 4. Stator Earth Fault Protection (ANSI 64G)
- 5. Rotor Earth Fault Protection (ANSI 64R)
- 6. Loss of Excitation Protection (ANSI 40)
- 7. Reverse Power Protection (ANSI 32)
- 8. Negative Sequence Protection (ANSI 46)
- 9. Generator Overvoltage Protection (ANSI 59)
- 10. Generator Overfrequency and Underfrequency Protection (ANSI 81)
- 11. Generator Backup Protection
- 11.1 Introduction
- 11.2 Voltage-controlled and voltage-restrained overcurrent protection (ANSI 50/51)
- 11.3 Impedance protection (ANSI 21)
- 11.4 Stator overload protection (ANSI 49)
- 11.5 Overexcitation protection (ANSI 24)
- 11.6 Inadvertent energization protection (ANSI 50/27)
- 11.7 Breaker failure protection (ANSI 50BF)
- 11.8 Out-of-step protection (ANSI 78)
- 12. Generator CT and VT Connections
- 13. NARI Relay Configuration and Parameter Engineering
- 14. Generator Protection Setting Calculations
- 15. IEC 61850 and Substation Automation Integration
- 16. NARI Generator Protection Testing Using Omicron CMC
- 16.1 Introduction
- 16.2 Differential protection testing
- 16.3 Stator earth fault testing
- 16.4 Rotor earth fault testing
- 16.5 Loss of excitation testing
- 16.6 Reverse power testing
- 16.7 Negative sequence testing
- 16.8 Voltage and frequency testing
- 16.9 Backup protection testing
- 16.10 Binary input and output testing
- 16.11 End-to-end functional testing
- 17. Commissioning and Troubleshooting
- 18. Practical Generator Protection Engineering Checklist
- 19. NARI Generator Protection Training by Elec-Engg
- 20. Conclusion
- References and Technical Documentation
1. Introduction to NARI Generator Protection
Generator protection is one of the most critical areas of power system protection engineering. Synchronous generators are expensive and essential power plant assets. Internal electrical faults, insulation failures, abnormal operating conditions, and external network disturbances can cause severe damage to generator stator windings, rotor windings, excitation systems, and associated equipment.
A comprehensive generator protection system must identify internal faults rapidly, detect abnormal operating conditions, provide backup protection against external faults, and initiate appropriate alarm and tripping actions.
NARI (Nanjing NARI-Relays) develops numerical protection and control devices for power generation, transmission, and distribution applications. Its PCS-985 generator protection family provides integrated protection functions for large synchronous generators and generator-transformer units.
The PCS-985 series incorporates several important protection principles, including differential protection, stator earth fault protection, rotor earth fault protection, loss of excitation, reverse power, negative sequence, voltage protection, frequency protection, and backup protection.
This article provides a comprehensive engineering explanation of NARI generator protection, covering protection principles, measurement circuits, relay configuration, setting considerations, protection coordination, IEC 61850 integration, commissioning, and secondary injection testing.
2. NARI PCS-985 Generator Protection Relay
2.1 Overview
The NARI PCS-985 family is designed for generator protection applications in power plants.
Depending on the specific model, the relay can integrate main and backup protection functions, measurement, supervision, disturbance recording, event recording, and communication facilities.
The PCS-985 family can be applied to different generator technologies, including:
- Steam turbine generators.
- Gas turbine generators.
- Hydroelectric generators.
- Other synchronous generator applications.
- Generator-transformer unit configurations.
The PCS-985G and PCS-985GE are examples of product variants with documented generator protection capabilities. The exact protection functions, hardware arrangement, and application limitations must be verified against the relevant model-specific instruction manual.
2.2 Main protection functions
The protection functions available in the PCS-985 family, depending on the variant and configuration, include:
| Protection function | ANSI designation |
|---|---|
| Generator differential protection | 87G |
| Generator transverse differential protection | 87G / application-specific |
| Stator earth fault protection | 64G / 64S |
| Rotor earth fault protection | 64R |
| Generator inter-turn protection | Application-specific |
| Stator overload protection | 49 |
| Negative sequence protection | 46 |
| Loss of excitation | 40 |
| Reverse power | 32 |
| Low forward power | 37 |
| Overvoltage | 59 |
| Undervoltage | 27 |
| Overfrequency | 81O |
| Underfrequency | 81U |
| Overexcitation | 24 |
| Impedance protection | 21 |
| Breaker failure | 50BF |
| Inadvertent energization | 50/27 |
| Out-of-step protection | 78 |
| Voltage transformer supervision | 60 / VTS |
| Current transformer supervision | CTS |
The ANSI numbering shown above identifies common protection functions. The exact naming and allocation used in a NARI relay should be checked against the applicable manufacturer’s documentation and project protection philosophy.
2.3 Main and backup protection architecture
Large generators normally require a high level of protection availability and dependability.
A typical arrangement uses two independent protection systems:
- Main Protection A.
- Main Protection B.
Each system may contain a separate numerical protection relay, independent DC supply arrangements, separate trip circuits, and appropriately allocated measurement circuits.
The design must consider:
- Independence of protection systems.
- CT core allocation.
- VT circuit allocation.
- DC supply redundancy.
- Separate trip coils where available.
- Circuit breaker failure protection.
- Generator-transformer protection coordination.
- Communication and time synchronization.
- Protection system supervision.
- Common-mode failure risks.
It is important to distinguish between a relay that integrates main and backup functions and a protection architecture that provides two genuinely independent protection systems. Integration within one device does not automatically provide the same redundancy as two independent protection systems.
3. Generator Differential Protection (ANSI 87G)
3.1 Protection principle
Generator differential protection is the principal protection against internal phase-to-phase faults within the stator differential protection zone.
The principle is based on comparing the currents entering and leaving the protected generator zone.
Under normal operating conditions, the differential current should be close to zero after considering CT ratios, polarity, and measurement conventions.
During an internal fault, the current balance changes and a differential current develops.
The protection detects this difference and initiates a trip when the operating criterion is satisfied.
3.2 Differential current calculation
For a simplified two-ended differential scheme:
[
I_{\mathrm{diff}}=|I_1-I_2|
]
Where:
- (I_1) = current measured at one boundary of the protected zone.
- (I_2) = corresponding current at the other boundary, referred to the same current direction.
The restraint current can be calculated using different manufacturer-specific definitions. A common example is:
[
I_{\mathrm{rest}}=\frac{|I_1|+|I_2|}{2}
]
The relay compares the differential current with its operating characteristic.
3.3 Percentage-biased differential protection
Percentage differential protection improves stability during external faults and CT saturation.
A simplified operating characteristic can be represented as:
[
I_{\mathrm{diff}}>I_{\mathrm{pickup}}+S I_{\mathrm{rest}}
]
Where:
- (I_{\mathrm{pickup}}) = minimum differential pickup.
- (S) = restraint slope.
- (I_{\mathrm{rest}}) = restraint current.
Modern relays may use multiple slopes and additional stabilization or supervision features.
The actual operating equation must be taken from the relevant NARI instruction manual.
3.4 CT selection and connections
The reliability of differential protection depends heavily on correct CT engineering.
Important considerations include:
- CT ratio.
- CT accuracy class.
- CT knee-point voltage where applicable.
- CT secondary burden.
- CT polarity.
- CT core allocation.
- CT saturation performance.
- Secondary cable resistance.
- CT earthing arrangement.
For a generator with CTs at the terminal and neutral ends, both measurement groups must be correctly configured and connected.
Incorrect CT polarity can produce unwanted differential current during normal operation.
3.5 CT saturation during external faults
During external faults, high through-current may cause CT saturation.
Unequal saturation between CTs can create a false differential current and cause unwanted operation.
Percentage restraint, appropriate CT selection, and manufacturer-specific stabilization algorithms help maintain protection security.
3.6 Differential protection testing
Testing should include:
- Balanced three-phase current injection.
- Differential current injection.
- Restraint characteristic verification.
- Pickup measurement.
- Slope verification.
- Unrestrained differential element testing.
- CT polarity and phase sequence verification.
- Trip output verification.
- Disturbance record analysis.
Omicron CMC equipment can be used to perform differential protection tests using appropriate current injection configurations.
4. Stator Earth Fault Protection (ANSI 64G)
4.1 Introduction
Stator earth faults are among the most important generator insulation faults.
They may occur because of:
- Winding insulation deterioration.
- Moisture ingress.
- Thermal ageing.
- Mechanical vibration.
- Contamination.
- Electrical insulation breakdown.
- Manufacturing defects.
The severity of a stator earth fault depends on its location, neutral grounding arrangement, and available fault current.
4.2 Fundamental-frequency neutral overvoltage protection
In resistance-grounded or other suitably grounded generator systems, an earth fault can produce neutral displacement voltage.
The protection measures residual or neutral voltage and identifies an earth fault when the measured quantity exceeds the configured threshold.
The fundamental-frequency principle is commonly used for detecting stator earth faults away from the neutral point.
4.3 Third-harmonic voltage protection
Third-harmonic voltage is generated within synchronous machines.
Its distribution between the generator terminal and neutral changes with operating conditions and can be used to detect earth faults close to the neutral point.
NARI PCS-985 documentation describes third-harmonic voltage ratio and third-harmonic voltage differential methods.
These methods require careful consideration of:
- Generator loading.
- Generator voltage.
- Third-harmonic voltage characteristics.
- VT measurement accuracy.
- Operating conditions.
- Blocking and supervision logic.
4.4 Voltage injection stator earth fault protection
An injection-based protection scheme can provide additional coverage of the stator winding.
The principle involves injecting a suitable signal into the generator neutral circuit and monitoring the response to estimate insulation condition.
The injection method can improve protection coverage, including near-neutral winding regions, depending on the design and implementation.
4.5 Stator earth fault coverage
No single protection method should automatically be assumed to provide complete winding coverage.
The protection engineer must evaluate the combination of fundamental-frequency, third-harmonic, and injection-based methods.
The coverage must be verified against generator grounding design and manufacturer’s application requirements.
4.6 Testing stator earth fault protection
Testing should include:
- Neutral voltage measurement verification.
- Residual voltage injection.
- Third-harmonic measurement verification.
- Ratio characteristic verification.
- Differential characteristic verification, where applicable.
- Injection circuit supervision.
- Alarm and trip logic testing.
- Blocking and interlocking verification.
Testing injection-based schemes requires suitable equipment and strict compliance with the generator and relay manufacturer’s instructions.
5. Rotor Earth Fault Protection (ANSI 64R)
5.1 Introduction
The generator rotor winding is normally operated as an unearthed DC excitation circuit.
A single earth fault may not immediately produce a significant fault current. However, a second earth fault at another location can short-circuit part of the rotor winding.
This can produce:
- Magnetic field distortion.
- Unequal air-gap flux.
- Rotor heating.
- Mechanical vibration.
- Electromagnetic imbalance.
- Serious generator damage.
Rotor earth fault protection is therefore essential for generator safety.
5.2 One-point rotor earth fault
One-point rotor earth fault protection detects deterioration of insulation between the excitation circuit and earth.
The protection may use a voltage-switching or voltage-injection principle, depending on the relay design.
The protection can generate an alarm when rotor insulation resistance decreases below the configured threshold.
5.3 Voltage injection principle
In an injection-based scheme, an auxiliary voltage is applied through a measuring circuit between the rotor winding and earth.
The relay evaluates the resulting measurement to determine rotor insulation resistance.
Important parameters include:
- Injection voltage.
- Rotor circuit capacitance.
- Measuring circuit resistance.
- Insulation resistance.
- Injection circuit supervision.
- Detection sensitivity.
NARI documentation describes rotor earth fault detection using external voltage injection.
5.4 Two-point rotor earth fault
A second earth fault may create a short circuit involving part of the rotor winding.
This condition can be more dangerous than the initial insulation fault.
Depending on the protection implementation, the relay can provide two-point rotor earth fault detection or associated logic.
5.5 Testing rotor earth fault protection
The testing procedure should include:
- Verification of rotor measuring circuit connections.
- Verification of auxiliary injection supply.
- Insulation resistance simulation.
- Pickup threshold verification.
- Alarm time delay testing.
- Two-point fault detection logic verification, where supported.
- External supervision and blocking checks.
- Final trip or alarm output verification.
Never apply test voltages directly to an operating rotor circuit without an approved test procedure.
6. Loss of Excitation Protection (ANSI 40)
6.1 Introduction
Loss of excitation occurs when a synchronous generator loses its field excitation or experiences a significant reduction in excitation.
Possible causes include:
- Excitation system failure.
- AVR malfunction.
- Field breaker opening.
- Excitation circuit interruption.
- Rotor circuit faults.
- Incorrect excitation control operation.
When excitation is lost, the generator may absorb reactive power from the network and operate asynchronously.
This can result in:
- Rotor and stator heating.
- Increased reactive power demand.
- Power system voltage depression.
- Loss of synchronism.
- Instability.
- Mechanical stress.
6.2 Impedance-based protection principle
Loss of excitation protection commonly uses impedance measurement based on generator terminal voltage and current.
The apparent impedance is calculated as:
[
Z=\frac{V}{I}
]
The relay evaluates the measured impedance trajectory against configured operating characteristics.
The impedance may enter a defined operating region when excitation is lost or significantly reduced.
6.3 Mho characteristic
A common loss of excitation protection arrangement uses offset mho characteristics.
Depending on the application, multiple zones can be configured with different operating times.
The characteristic must be selected based on:
- Generator rated MVA.
- Rated voltage.
- Synchronous reactance.
- Transient reactance.
- Generator capability curve.
- System impedance.
- Operating conditions.
6.4 Undervoltage supervision
Voltage supervision can be used to distinguish abnormal voltage conditions and improve the security of loss of excitation protection.
Some NARI implementations include voltage criteria and additional supervision.
6.5 Setting considerations
The protection engineer must consider:
- Generator impedance base.
- Per-unit conversion.
- Generator reactance.
- Offset and reach.
- Zone operating times.
- Power system stability.
- Coordination with excitation control.
- VT circuit failure supervision.
6.6 Testing loss of excitation
Using Omicron CMC and appropriate software, engineers can test the protection by injecting voltage and current quantities representing different impedance points.
The test should include:
- Stable operating points outside the operating zone.
- Points inside the first operating zone.
- Points inside the second operating zone, where configured.
- Boundary measurements.
- Operating time verification.
- Undervoltage supervision.
- VT failure blocking.
- Trip output verification.
The test characteristic should be plotted and compared with the approved relay settings.
7. Reverse Power Protection (ANSI 32)
7.1 Introduction
Reverse power protection detects when the generator absorbs active power from the electrical network instead of supplying active power.
Under normal operation, the prime mover supplies mechanical power to the generator.
If the prime mover fails or mechanical input becomes insufficient, the generator may begin operating as a motor.
This condition is known as motoring.
7.2 Causes of reverse power
Typical causes include:
- Steam turbine mechanical input failure.
- Fuel supply interruption.
- Turbine trip.
- Governor malfunction.
- Mechanical drive failure.
- Incorrect generator operating sequence.
7.3 Operating principle
The relay calculates active power using voltage and current measurements.
For a balanced three-phase system:
[
P=\sqrt{3}V_L I_L\cos\varphi
]
The relay evaluates the direction of active power according to its configured measurement convention.
When reverse power exceeds the pickup threshold for the configured time, the protection operates.
7.4 Setting considerations
Important parameters include:
- Reverse power pickup.
- Time delay.
- CT ratio.
- VT ratio.
- Active power measurement direction.
- Generator operating conditions.
- Prime mover motoring characteristics.
The reverse power threshold must be selected using the turbine manufacturer’s recommendations and generator operating requirements.
7.5 Sequential tripping
Some generator protection arrangements use sequential tripping.
In this arrangement, the generator circuit breaker and prime mover trip sequence are coordinated to prevent unnecessary damage and avoid inappropriate operation of the protection system.
The exact sequence depends on plant design and turbine requirements.
7.6 Testing reverse power protection
A secondary injection test should verify:
- Correct three-phase voltage and current measurements.
- Correct phase sequence.
- Correct power direction.
- Forward power operation.
- Reverse power pickup.
- Operating time.
- Alarm and trip logic.
- Breaker and turbine interface signals.
Testing both positive and negative power directions is essential.
8. Negative Sequence Protection (ANSI 46)
8.1 Introduction
Negative sequence current is produced when three-phase currents become unbalanced.
In a synchronous generator, negative sequence current creates a magnetic field rotating opposite to the rotor.
This induces double-frequency currents in the rotor body and other rotor components.
The resulting heating can damage the rotor.
8.2 Causes of negative sequence current
Common causes include:
- Unbalanced external faults.
- Phase-to-phase faults.
- Open-phase conditions.
- Unequal phase loading.
- Transmission line asymmetry.
- Incorrect switching operations.
- Unbalanced system conditions.
8.3 Negative sequence current calculation
Using symmetrical components:
[
I_2=\frac{1}{3}(I_A+a^2 I_B+a I_C)
]
Where:
[
a=1\angle120^\circ
]
(I_2) represents the negative sequence current.
The relay calculates negative sequence current from measured phase currents.
8.4 Thermal withstand characteristic
Generator manufacturers normally specify the permissible negative sequence withstand capability.
A commonly used representation is:
[
I_2^2t=K
]
Where:
- (I_2) = negative sequence current in per unit.
- (t) = operating time.
- (K) = generator negative sequence withstand constant.
The protection must be coordinated with the generator’s permissible thermal limits.
8.5 Definite-time and inverse-time protection
A generator protection relay may provide:
- Definite-time negative sequence protection.
- Inverse-time negative sequence overload protection.
Definite-time protection can provide an alarm or trip for a selected current threshold.
Inverse-time protection provides thermal protection by accumulating the effect of negative sequence current.
8.6 Testing negative sequence protection
Testing should include:
- Balanced three-phase current injection.
- Unbalanced current injection.
- Negative sequence measurement verification.
- Pickup verification.
- Thermal characteristic verification.
- Time delay verification.
- Alarm and trip logic verification.
The test should include several points on the inverse-time curve.
9. Generator Overvoltage Protection (ANSI 59)
9.1 Introduction
Overvoltage occurs when generator terminal voltage exceeds its permitted operating range.
Possible causes include:
- Sudden load rejection.
- AVR malfunction.
- Excitation control failure.
- Incorrect voltage regulator settings.
- Abnormal network conditions.
- Islanded operation.
Excessive voltage can increase electrical stress on generator winding insulation and associated equipment.
9.2 Operating principle
The relay continuously monitors the generator voltage.
When the measured voltage exceeds the configured threshold, the overvoltage element starts.
If the voltage remains above the threshold for the selected time, the relay issues an alarm or trip.
9.3 Setting considerations
The engineer should consider:
- Generator rated voltage.
- Generator voltage operating limits.
- VT ratio.
- Maximum permissible voltage.
- AVR operating range.
- Time delays.
- Coordination with excitation control.
- Generator and transformer insulation requirements.
9.4 Testing overvoltage protection
Testing should include:
- Normal voltage measurement.
- Pickup threshold.
- Drop-off threshold.
- Time delay.
- Three-phase voltage supervision.
- Alarm and trip outputs.
- VT circuit failure supervision.
10. Generator Overfrequency and Underfrequency Protection (ANSI 81)
10.1 Introduction
Frequency protection detects abnormal generator frequency.
Frequency deviations may result from an imbalance between mechanical power input and electrical power output.
Overfrequency generally occurs when generation exceeds the connected load.
Underfrequency generally occurs when electrical demand exceeds available generation.
10.2 Underfrequency protection (81U)
Underfrequency may occur because of:
- Generation shortage.
- System disturbances.
- Islanded operation.
- Loss of generation.
- Sudden increase in electrical load.
The protection measures system frequency and operates when the measured frequency falls below the configured threshold.
10.3 Overfrequency protection (81O)
Overfrequency may occur because of:
- Sudden load rejection.
- Turbine governor failure.
- Islanded operation.
- Excess mechanical input.
The protection operates when frequency exceeds the configured threshold for the specified time.
10.4 Frequency protection setting considerations
Important settings include:
- Pickup frequency.
- Operating time.
- Number of stages.
- Voltage supervision.
- Measurement quality.
- Generator operating limits.
- Turbine frequency withstand capability.
- Grid code requirements.
10.5 Testing frequency protection
Frequency protection can be tested using a relay test set capable of generating variable-frequency voltage signals.
Testing should include:
- Nominal frequency.
- Underfrequency pickup.
- Underfrequency dropout.
- Overfrequency pickup.
- Overfrequency dropout.
- Operating time verification.
- Frequency measurement accuracy.
- Alarm and trip logic.
11. Generator Backup Protection
11.1 Introduction
Backup protection is essential when the main protection fails to detect a fault or when external network protection does not clear a fault within the required time.
Generator backup protection must be coordinated with:
- Generator differential protection.
- Generator-transformer protection.
- Transformer backup protection.
- Transmission line protection.
- Busbar protection.
- Circuit breaker failure protection.
11.2 Voltage-controlled and voltage-restrained overcurrent protection (ANSI 50/51)
Generator overcurrent protection can be affected by the generator’s fault current characteristics.
During external faults, generator terminal voltage may decrease, and fault current may not remain sufficiently high for conventional overcurrent protection.
Voltage-controlled or voltage-restrained overcurrent protection can improve sensitivity under such conditions.
The exact operating logic depends on the selected relay implementation.
11.3 Impedance protection (ANSI 21)
Impedance protection can provide backup protection against external phase faults.
The relay calculates apparent impedance using voltage and current measurements.
When the measured impedance enters the configured operating region, the protection initiates after the selected time delay.
Settings must be coordinated with the network protection system and generator operating characteristics.
11.4 Stator overload protection (ANSI 49)
Stator overload protection monitors generator current and estimates thermal stress.
The relay may provide definite-time and inverse-time characteristics.
The thermal model should reflect the generator’s permissible continuous and short-time loading conditions.
11.5 Overexcitation protection (ANSI 24)
Overexcitation occurs when the ratio of voltage to frequency becomes excessive.
The magnetic flux in generator and transformer cores is approximately proportional to:
[
\Phi \propto \frac{V}{f}
]
Excessive V/Hz can cause core saturation, increased losses, and overheating.
Overexcitation protection monitors the V/Hz ratio and operates according to the configured definite-time or inverse-time characteristic.
11.6 Inadvertent energization protection (ANSI 50/27)
Inadvertent energization occurs when a generator is accidentally connected to the electrical network while it is stationary or not operating under normal synchronization conditions.
Possible causes include:
- Incorrect breaker operation.
- Control circuit failure.
- Synchronizing system malfunction.
- Incorrect switching sequence.
This condition can produce high currents and mechanical stress.
Protection typically uses a combination of voltage, current, frequency, and breaker status information.
11.7 Breaker failure protection (ANSI 50BF)
Breaker failure protection operates when a circuit breaker receives a trip command but fails to interrupt the fault current.
The relay supervises the trip command and checks whether current continues to flow or other configured breaker failure criteria are satisfied.
If the breaker fails to open, the breaker failure logic initiates backup tripping of the necessary surrounding breakers.
11.8 Out-of-step protection (ANSI 78)
Loss of synchronism can occur when the generator experiences severe system disturbances or unstable power transfer.
Out-of-step protection detects the relevant impedance trajectory and determines whether the generator is experiencing an unstable pole slip condition.
Its application requires careful power system stability studies.
12. Generator CT and VT Connections
12.1 Current transformer engineering
CT circuits are fundamental to generator protection.
Incorrect CT selection or wiring can affect differential, overcurrent, negative sequence, earth fault, and power measurement functions.
Important checks include:
- CT ratio.
- CT secondary rating.
- CT accuracy class.
- CT polarity.
- CT burden.
- CT core allocation.
- CT earthing.
- Secondary wiring continuity.
Differential and backup protection may use separate CT cores.
12.2 Voltage transformer engineering
VT circuits supply the relay with voltage signals required for:
- Loss of excitation.
- Reverse power.
- Overvoltage.
- Undervoltage.
- Frequency protection.
- Impedance protection.
- Voltage-controlled overcurrent protection.
The voltage measurement scheme must be consistent with the generator connection and grounding arrangement.
12.3 CT and VT supervision
CT and VT circuit supervision can detect measurement circuit abnormalities.
Possible problems include:
- Open CT secondary circuit.
- Shorted CT secondary circuit.
- Blown VT fuse.
- Open VT secondary wiring.
- Incorrect phase connections.
- Loss of voltage measurement.
Protection blocking and alarm logic must be designed carefully to avoid disabling essential protection unnecessarily.
Important: CT secondary circuits must never be opened while primary current is flowing. Use approved shorting facilities and safe isolation procedures.
13. NARI Relay Configuration and Parameter Engineering
13.1 Configuration process
The configuration process should begin with reviewing the approved protection design and the specific relay instruction manual.
Typical engineering activities include:
- Confirm relay model and hardware version.
- Verify firmware compatibility.
- Review generator technical data.
- Enter rated current and voltage.
- Configure CT and VT ratios.
- Select applicable protection functions.
- Enter protection settings.
- Configure binary inputs.
- Configure binary outputs.
- Develop trip and alarm logic.
- Configure disturbance recording.
- Configure communication parameters.
- Verify the final configuration against approved documents.
13.2 Protection setting groups
Where supported, different setting groups may be used for different operating conditions.
However, changing setting groups must be controlled and supervised.
The protection engineer should verify:
- Setting group selection logic.
- Operating condition supervision.
- Switching permissions.
- Setting group indication.
- Event recording.
- Protection continuity during group changes.
13.3 Trip matrix engineering
The trip matrix defines which protection functions initiate which outputs.
A typical arrangement may include:
| Protection function | Alarm | Generator breaker trip | Field trip | Prime mover trip |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Differential 87G | Yes | Yes | According to scheme | According to scheme |
| Stator earth fault | Yes | Yes | According to scheme | According to scheme |
| Rotor earth fault | Yes | According to scheme | According to scheme | According to scheme |
| Loss of excitation 40 | Yes | According to scheme | According to scheme | According to scheme |
| Reverse power 32 | Yes | Yes | According to scheme | According to sequence |
| Negative sequence 46 | Yes | According to stage | According to scheme | According to scheme |
| Overvoltage 59 | Yes | According to stage | According to scheme | According to scheme |
| Overfrequency 81O | Yes | According to stage | According to scheme | According to scheme |
| Breaker failure 50BF | Yes | Backup trip | According to scheme | According to scheme |
The table is illustrative only. Actual trip allocation must follow the plant protection philosophy, generator manufacturer’s requirements, and approved cause-and-effect documentation.
14. Generator Protection Setting Calculations
Protection settings must be calculated from actual generator data and system studies.
Important generator parameters include:
- Rated apparent power.
- Rated active power.
- Rated voltage.
- Rated current.
- Power factor.
- Synchronous reactance.
- Transient reactance.
- Subtransient reactance.
- Neutral grounding impedance.
- Negative sequence withstand constant.
- Short-circuit characteristics.
- Generator capability curve.
14.1 Rated current calculation
For a three-phase generator:
[
I_n=\frac{S_n}{\sqrt{3}V_n}
]
Where:
- (S_n) = rated apparent power.
- (V_n) = rated line-to-line voltage.
- (I_n) = rated line current.
14.2 Per-unit conversion
The per-unit system is widely used in generator protection calculations.
[
Z_{\mathrm{base}}=\frac{V_{\mathrm{base}}^2}{S_{\mathrm{base}}}
]
[
I_{\mathrm{base}}=\frac{S_{\mathrm{base}}}{\sqrt{3}V_{\mathrm{base}}}
]
The selected voltage and power bases must be consistent.
14.3 CT secondary current
For a CT with primary rating (I_P) and secondary rating (I_S):
[
I_{\mathrm{sec}}=I_{\mathrm{pri}}\frac{I_S}{I_P}
]
The relay setting must be converted to the appropriate primary or secondary reference according to the manufacturer’s setting conventions.
14.4 Differential protection settings
The differential pickup and bias characteristics must consider:
- Maximum load current.
- CT errors.
- CT saturation.
- Generator internal fault sensitivity.
- CT transient performance.
- Protection stability during external faults.
14.5 Negative sequence settings
The negative sequence protection characteristic should be coordinated with the generator manufacturer’s (I_2^2t) withstand limit.
14.6 Reverse power settings
Reverse power settings should be selected according to prime mover motoring requirements and the expected reverse power during abnormal mechanical input conditions.
14.7 Loss of excitation settings
Impedance characteristics should be established using generator reactances, capability curves, system impedance, and stability studies.
Engineering warning: The equations in this article explain the calculation principles. They are not substitutes for manufacturer-specific algorithms, approved setting studies, or commissioning procedures.
15. IEC 61850 and Substation Automation Integration
Modern generator protection relays can be integrated into power plant substation automation systems.
Depending on the NARI relay model and communication hardware, available interfaces and protocols may include:
- IEC 61850.
- IEC 60870-5-103.
- Modbus.
- DNP3.
15.1 IEC 61850 MMS
MMS is commonly used for supervisory communication between IEDs and station-level systems.
Typical information includes:
- Protection indications.
- Measurements.
- Alarm status.
- Breaker status.
- Disturbance records.
- Device health information.
15.2 IEC 61850 GOOSE
GOOSE can be used for fast peer-to-peer communication between protection and control IEDs.
Possible applications include:
- Interlocking.
- Breaker status exchange.
- Trip signal exchange.
- Blocking signals.
- Protection coordination.
GOOSE engineering requires correct configuration of datasets, control blocks, communication parameters, and subscriptions.
15.3 SCL engineering
The IEC 61850 engineering process involves SCL files, including ICD, CID, IID, and SCD files, depending on the system workflow.
The engineer must verify:
- IED descriptions.
- Logical devices.
- Logical nodes.
- Data objects.
- Datasets.
- Report control blocks.
- GOOSE control blocks.
- Communication addressing.
- Network configuration.
15.4 Communication testing
Testing should include:
- Communication connection verification.
- MMS client connection.
- Measurement verification.
- Report configuration.
- GOOSE publishing.
- GOOSE subscription.
- Dataset verification.
- Network supervision.
- Time synchronization.
- Communication failure response.
Communication testing must not replace hardwired protection circuit testing where hardwired circuits are part of the approved protection architecture.
16. NARI Generator Protection Testing Using Omicron CMC
16.1 Introduction
Secondary injection testing is essential for verifying the correct operation of numerical generator protection relays.
Omicron CMC test equipment, together with suitable test software, can be used to simulate electrical faults and verify relay response.
The test plan should be prepared using the approved protection settings and manufacturer’s testing instructions.
16.2 Differential protection testing
Test cases should include:
- Balanced load condition.
- Internal fault condition.
- Differential pickup.
- Restraint characteristic.
- Slope verification.
- Unrestrained differential operation.
- Trip output verification.
16.3 Stator earth fault testing
Test cases should include:
- Fundamental residual voltage.
- Neutral voltage pickup.
- Third-harmonic ratio.
- Third-harmonic differential.
- Injection-based protection, where applicable.
- Blocking and supervision logic.
16.4 Rotor earth fault testing
Test cases should include:
- Insulation resistance simulation.
- Injection circuit supervision.
- One-point earth fault.
- Two-point earth fault logic, where supported.
- Alarm and trip output verification.
16.5 Loss of excitation testing
Test cases should include:
- Impedance measurement.
- Zone boundary verification.
- Zone operating time.
- Undervoltage supervision.
- Blocking logic.
16.6 Reverse power testing
Test cases should include:
- Forward power.
- Zero power.
- Reverse power.
- Pickup measurement.
- Operating time.
- Sequential tripping logic, where applicable.
16.7 Negative sequence testing
Test cases should include:
- Balanced three-phase current.
- Unbalanced phase current.
- Negative sequence measurement.
- Definite-time operation.
- Inverse-time characteristic.
- Thermal memory behavior, where applicable.
16.8 Voltage and frequency testing
Test cases should include:
- Overvoltage.
- Undervoltage.
- Overfrequency.
- Underfrequency.
- Pickup and dropout.
- Operating time.
- Alarm and trip outputs.
16.9 Backup protection testing
Test cases should include:
- Phase overcurrent.
- Voltage-controlled overcurrent.
- Impedance protection.
- Stator overload.
- Overexcitation.
- Inadvertent energization.
- Breaker failure.
16.10 Binary input and output testing
Verify all configured inputs and outputs, including:
- Generator circuit breaker status.
- Protection enable and block signals.
- External trip signals.
- Excitation system signals.
- Turbine protection signals.
- Trip circuit supervision.
- Alarm outputs.
- Lockout relay interfaces.
16.11 End-to-end functional testing
After individual protection elements are tested, complete functional testing should verify the full protection chain.
The test should include:
- Test quantity injection.
- Protection element pickup.
- Internal logic operation.
- Trip matrix response.
- Binary output operation.
- Trip relay operation.
- Circuit breaker interface.
- Alarm indication.
- Event recording.
- Disturbance recording.
Testing must be performed under an approved isolation and safety procedure. Secondary injection alone does not establish that the entire primary protection system is operational.
17. Commissioning and Troubleshooting
17.1 Pre-commissioning inspection
Before energization, verify:
- Correct relay model.
- Correct hardware configuration.
- Approved firmware.
- Approved setting file.
- Auxiliary supply.
- CT and VT circuits.
- Binary inputs.
- Binary outputs.
- Communication connections.
- Earthing arrangements.
- Trip circuit wiring.
17.2 Protection setting verification
Compare the relay configuration with the approved setting calculation and protection coordination study.
Verify that no unintended protection function is enabled or disabled.
17.3 Common problems
Unexpected differential protection operation
Possible causes:
- CT polarity error.
- Incorrect CT ratio.
- Incorrect phase assignment.
- CT secondary wiring error.
- Incorrect differential settings.
- CT saturation.
Stator earth fault alarm
Possible causes:
- Actual insulation deterioration.
- VT circuit abnormality.
- Incorrect neutral voltage measurement.
- Third-harmonic measurement problems.
- Incorrect protection configuration.
Rotor earth fault alarm
Possible causes:
- Rotor insulation deterioration.
- Injection circuit fault.
- Incorrect measuring circuit connection.
- Auxiliary supply problem.
- Measuring circuit supervision alarm.
Loss of excitation operation
Possible causes:
- Actual excitation system failure.
- Incorrect impedance settings.
- VT circuit failure.
- Incorrect CT or VT polarity.
- Incorrect measurement configuration.
Reverse power operation
Possible causes:
- Actual generator motoring.
- Incorrect CT polarity.
- Incorrect VT phase connections.
- Incorrect power direction configuration.
- Incorrect pickup setting.
Negative sequence operation
Possible causes:
- Actual current unbalance.
- CT measurement error.
- Open-phase condition.
- Incorrect phase connection.
- Incorrect thermal settings.
17.4 Event and disturbance analysis
NARI relay event records and oscillographic disturbance records can help engineers identify the sequence of events during a fault.
The investigation should examine:
- Protection start signals.
- Protection operate signals.
- Phase currents.
- Phase voltages.
- Residual quantities.
- Positive and negative sequence components.
- Active and reactive power.
- Breaker status.
- Trip outputs.
- Time synchronization.
A proper disturbance analysis should identify the initiating event, protection response, trip sequence, and any abnormal operation.
18. Practical Generator Protection Engineering Checklist
A generator protection engineer should review the following items before commissioning:
| No. | Engineering activity |
|---|---|
| 1 | Review generator single-line diagram |
| 2 | Review generator technical data |
| 3 | Confirm PCS-985 model and firmware |
| 4 | Verify CT and VT ratios |
| 5 | Verify CT polarity and phase sequence |
| 6 | Review generator neutral grounding |
| 7 | Check differential protection zones |
| 8 | Review stator earth fault coverage |
| 9 | Review rotor earth fault protection |
| 10 | Calculate loss of excitation settings |
| 11 | Calculate reverse power settings |
| 12 | Review negative sequence withstand data |
| 13 | Review voltage and frequency protection |
| 14 | Coordinate backup protection |
| 15 | Verify trip matrix and logic |
| 16 | Test binary inputs and outputs |
| 17 | Perform secondary injection testing |
| 18 | Verify IEC 61850 communication |
| 19 | Test disturbance recording |
| 20 | Prepare final commissioning report |
19. NARI Generator Protection Training by Elec-Engg
Elec-Engg provides professional technical education in power system protection, protection and control, numerical protection relays, substation automation, and relay testing.
Our training approach focuses on practical engineering knowledge rather than only theoretical descriptions of protection functions.
Relevant training subjects include:
- Generator protection principles.
- Numerical generator protection relay engineering.
- NARI PCS-985 generator protection.
- Generator differential protection.
- Stator and rotor earth fault protection.
- Loss of excitation and reverse power protection.
- Negative sequence and thermal protection.
- Generator protection setting calculations.
- Protection coordination.
- CT and VT circuit engineering.
- Protection logic and trip matrix configuration.
- IEC 61850 engineering.
- Omicron CMC secondary injection testing.
- Protection commissioning and troubleshooting.
- Fault and disturbance record analysis.
Training delivery options include:
- Structured self-paced technical training.
- Video-based courses.
- Online technical training.
- Customized company training.
- Face-to-face technical courses.
Our objective is to help protection, commissioning, operation, and maintenance engineers understand how numerical protection systems work and how to apply, configure, test, and troubleshoot them in real power plant applications.
Practical courses by Dr. Saeed Roostaee / Elec-Engg.
Website: https://elec-engg.com/
20. Conclusion
NARI generator protection systems provide a comprehensive range of protection functions for synchronous generators and generator-transformer applications.
The PCS-985 family integrates important protection principles, including differential protection, stator and rotor earth fault protection, loss of excitation, reverse power, negative sequence, voltage protection, frequency protection, and backup protection.
However, reliable generator protection requires more than selecting and enabling individual protection functions.
Engineers must understand generator characteristics, CT and VT circuits, protection algorithms, setting calculations, coordination, trip logic, communication architecture, and commissioning requirements.
A properly designed, configured, tested, and maintained generator protection system is essential for protecting expensive generating equipment, improving power plant availability, and maintaining power system stability.
References and Technical Documentation
The following documents should be consulted for detailed relay-specific engineering:
- NARI PCS-985G Generator Protection Relay — Instruction Manual.
- NARI PCS-985GE Generator Protection Relay — Instruction Manual.
- NARI PCS-985 series technical specifications and application documentation.
- IEC 60255 — Measuring relays and protection equipment.
- IEC 61850 — Communication networks and systems for power utility automation.
- IEEE C37.102 — Guide for AC Generator Protection.
- IEEE C50.12 and IEEE C50.13 — Requirements for synchronous machines, as applicable.
- Generator manufacturer’s technical data, capability curves, and protection recommendations.
Important technical note: Protection function availability, ANSI allocation, measurement methods, setting ranges, logic, and testing procedures vary between PCS-985 models and firmware versions. Always use the exact instruction manual and approved project documentation for the installed relay.
