Siemens SIGRA 4: Fault Record Analysis, COMTRADE Evaluation & Disturbance Analysis
SIGRA 4 is a Siemens software tool designed to analyze fault records and disturbance recordings from power system protection devices. It helps protection engineers investigate network faults by displaying recorded electrical signals graphically and calculating additional quantities to support fault analysis.
Using SIGRA 4, engineers can examine current and voltage waveforms, binary signals, operating times, phasor diagrams, impedance values, and other calculated quantities. These features make it a useful tool for protection engineers, relay testing specialists, commissioning engineers, and substation maintenance personnel.
SIGRA 4 can work with fault records in the COMTRADE format, allowing engineers to evaluate disturbance recordings from compatible Siemens and third-party recording devices.
1. Main Features of SIGRA 4
SIGRA 4 provides several tools for analyzing and interpreting fault records, including:
- Representation of indications and measured values
- Retrieval of fault records using DIGSI 4
- Import and evaluation of COMTRADE files
- Parameterization of fault record representation
- Definition of user profiles
- Angle measurement
- Fourier analysis
- Impedance calculation
- Export of fault records
- Time-signal diagrams
- Vector and phasor diagrams
- Analysis of analog and binary signals
- Evaluation of calculated electrical quantities
These functions help engineers understand the sequence of events during a disturbance and assess the performance of protection systems.
2. Retrieving Fault Records with DIGSI 4
DIGSI 4 is the engineering software used for configuring and managing compatible Siemens SIPROTEC 4 protection devices.
Fault records stored in a relay can be retrieved using DIGSI 4 and subsequently evaluated in SIGRA 4.
A typical workflow involves:
- Connecting to the protection relay.
- Retrieving the available fault records.
- Transferring or exporting the recordings.
- Opening the fault record in SIGRA 4.
- Examining the recorded analog and binary signals.
- Evaluating the disturbance using waveform, vector, and calculation tools.
This workflow is useful during commissioning, troubleshooting, periodic maintenance, and post-fault investigations.
3. COMTRADE Format
COMTRADE stands for Common Format for Transient Data Exchange. It is a standardized format used to exchange transient and disturbance records between protection relays, disturbance recorders, and analysis software.
COMTRADE files typically contain information such as:
- Analog channel data
- Digital or binary channel data
- Channel descriptions
- Sampling information
- Time information
- Scaling and conversion information
SIGRA 4 can use COMTRADE recordings to analyze disturbances from compatible recording devices.
When evaluating recordings from different manufacturers, engineers should check the channel descriptions, scaling factors, nominal values, sampling information, and other configuration details to ensure correct interpretation.
4. Parameterization of Fault Record Channels
Correct channel parameterization is essential for reliable fault record analysis.
SIGRA 4 performs its calculations using primary electrical quantities. For recordings obtained from Siemens devices, DIGSI may provide the relevant transformer ratings in the COMTRADE recording information.
When analyzing recordings from third-party devices, engineers must verify whether the recorded values represent primary or secondary quantities.
If the recording contains secondary current and voltage values, the appropriate CT and VT ratios must be entered or applied so that SIGRA 4 can correctly convert the signals into primary quantities.
The Parameterize Channels dialog is used to configure the channel parameters.
The channel settings should be checked carefully, including:
- Current transformer ratios
- Voltage transformer ratios
- Primary and secondary ratings
- Channel assignment
- Signal polarity
- Measurement direction
A negative rating can reverse the corresponding measured signal by 180°. This is relevant when ensuring consistency with the SIGRA 4 arrow metering convention.
Incorrect CT or VT ratios, polarity, or channel assignments can lead to misleading calculated values and incorrect conclusions during fault analysis.
5. Representation of Measured Values
The representation of measured quantities in the secondary system depends on the applicable CT and VT transformation ratios.
When reviewing a disturbance recording, engineers should understand whether the displayed quantities represent primary values or secondary values.
SIGRA 4 provides tools to examine measured and calculated values at selected points in time. These values can help identify:
- Pre-fault operating conditions
- Fault inception
- Current and voltage changes
- Protection operating times
- Circuit breaker opening
- Fault clearance
- Post-fault system behaviour
Measuring Window
When measured quantities are calculated using a measuring window, the window is positioned before the observation time, such as the selected cursor position.
The window has a duration corresponding to one period of the nominal system frequency.
For example:
- At 50 Hz, one cycle is 20 ms.
- At 60 Hz, one cycle is approximately 16.67 ms.
The calculated quantities are meaningful only when the measuring window does not contain an unsuitable change of signal status, such as fault inception or interruption.
Calculated quantities in SIGRA 4 are identified by an asterisk in their names.
6. Time Signal View
The Time Signal View is used to display recorded signals as functions of time.
It allows engineers to create diagrams and assign different measured or calculated signals to them.
The available diagram types include:
- Analog curve diagrams
- Binary value diagrams
- Status diagrams
- Time markings
The software can display current values or root-mean-square (RMS) values, depending on the selected representation and signal.
Status Diagram
The status diagram is used to display important event times and status information associated with the fault recording.
For example, the fault recording trigger time can be displayed as a defined status. User-defined status signals can also be used to mark specific events and times with corresponding symbols.
This is useful when investigating the sequence of protection operations and circuit breaker behaviour.
Cursor Measurement
SIGRA 4 provides cursor tools that allow engineers to inspect signals at specific points in time.
The values of individual signals can be read directly from the diagram. The positions of Cursor 1 and Cursor 2 are also displayed on the time axis.
When a cursor is moved in another SIGRA 4 view, its corresponding position is updated in the Time Signal View.
This makes it easier to compare different signals at the same instant during a fault.
7. Vector Diagram View
The Vector Diagram View displays measured and calculated quantities as complex vectors at selected points in time.
The diagram on the left corresponds to Cursor 1, while the diagram on the right corresponds to Cursor 2.
This view is particularly useful for examining current and voltage phasors during different stages of a disturbance.
The vector quantities are based on the RMS values of the fundamental-frequency component. Their magnitudes and angles are calculated using a full-cycle Discrete Fourier Transform (DFT).
The measuring window:
- Is positioned before the reference time (cursor position).
- Has a duration of one nominal-frequency cycle.
- Is 20 ms for a 50 Hz system.
- Is approximately 16.67 ms for a 60 Hz system.
The vector angle is referenced to a standard vector rotating at the nominal system frequency.
Engineers can use the vector diagram to investigate:
- Phase relationships between currents and voltages
- Changes in current and voltage angles
- Fault conditions
- Directional protection behaviour
- Phase displacement
- Fundamental-frequency quantities
As with the Time Signal View, the corresponding signal values and cursor positions can be examined directly. Moving a cursor in one view updates the associated vector diagram.
8. Fourier Analysis
Fourier analysis is used to examine the frequency components of recorded electrical signals.
SIGRA 4 uses Discrete Fourier Transform (DFT) calculations to determine the fundamental-frequency component used in its vector representation.
This is particularly important when evaluating protection relay measurements, because many protection functions operate using fundamental-frequency current and voltage quantities.
Fourier-based analysis can help engineers understand the relationship between the recorded waveform and the fundamental-frequency phasors used in protection calculations.
9. Impedance Calculation
Impedance calculation is an important function when analyzing transmission line and distance protection disturbances.
Using recorded voltage and current signals, engineers can investigate the apparent impedance during a fault.
The basic relationship is:
Z = V / I
where:
- Z = Apparent impedance
- V = Measured voltage
- I = Measured current
The calculated impedance can be compared with the expected line impedance and relay protection characteristics.
This is useful for investigating:
- Distance protection operation
- Fault location within protection zones
- Apparent impedance during faults
- Changes in impedance during fault clearance
- Possible effects of fault resistance
The interpretation must consider the fault type, selected voltage and current quantities, CT/VT ratios, residual compensation, and the distance relay’s measurement principles. The simple V/I relationship alone does not represent every distance protection measurement loop.
10. Exporting Fault Records
SIGRA 4 also supports exporting fault record data for further evaluation and documentation.
Exporting records can help engineers:
- Share disturbance recordings with other specialists
- Maintain records of investigated faults
- Compare recordings from different events
- Prepare technical reports
- Archive fault analysis results
The available export formats and options depend on the software version and the selected recording.
11. Practical Applications of SIGRA 4
SIGRA 4 is particularly useful in practical protection engineering activities.
Typical applications include:
- Analyzing transmission line faults
- Investigating distance relay operation
- Evaluating overcurrent protection events
- Reviewing transformer protection disturbances
- Checking circuit breaker opening times
- Comparing relay operation with recorded fault conditions
- Examining current and voltage waveforms
- Investigating incorrect or unexpected protection operation
- Supporting commissioning and post-fault investigations
12. SIGRA 4 Training by Elec-Engg
Understanding how to use SIGRA 4 is an important skill for protection and commissioning engineers. However, effective fault analysis requires more than simply opening a COMTRADE file. Engineers must understand the recorded signals, CT/VT ratios, phasor relationships, protection functions, and the sequence of events during a disturbance.
Elec-Engg provides practical technical training in power system protection, relay engineering, testing, commissioning, and substation automation.
Training is available through:
- Online technical training
- Structured self-paced training
- Face-to-face training
- Customized in-house training for companies and utilities
Practical Courses by Dr Saeed Roostaee / Elec-Engg.
For course information and training enquiries, please visit:
- Representation of indications and measured values
- Retrieval of fault records with DIGSI 4
- The COMTRADE format
- Parameterization of fault record representation
- Definition of user profile
- Angle measuring
- Fourier analysis
- Impedance calculation
- Export of fault records
Sample pages:
The system program SIGRA 4 offers support when faults occur in your network. The data recorded during fault occurrence are graphically represented and further data on the basis of the measured values are calculated in addition, like impedance or effective values, which will facilitate the evaluation of the fault record for you.
The SIGRA 4 calculations are always on the basis of primary magnitudes.
The transformer ratings are entered in the COMTRADE file of the fault record by DIGSI for evaluation by SIGRA 4.
If you want to evaluate the fault records from third-party devices recording the measured magnitudes as secondary magnitudes, you must make sure that the magnitudes will be correctly converted into primary magnitudes via the transformer ratings. The dialog box Parameterize Channels serves to carry out this parameterization. Negative ratings will cause a measured signal rotation of 180°. Thus, compatibility with the definition of the SIGRA 4 arrow metering system is ensured.
The representation and display of metered values in the secondary system is always based on the compilation ratio between the primary current or principal voltage transformer.
If metered magnitudes are created via a measuring window, this window is always left of the observation time, for ex. The cursor position. The measuring window equals the length of a period interval of the rated frequency TN, 20 ms at 50 Hz for example. The calculated magnitudes are only valid if there is no change of status displayed in the measuring window, like fault occurrence or interruption. The magnitudes calculated by SIGRA 4 are identified by an asterisk in the name.

The Time Signal view serves to visualize signals as a time function.
This view serves to define any number of diagrams of the following type status diagrams:
- analog curve diagrams
- binary value diagrams
- and to assign any number of measured and calculated magnitudes, binary or status signals (time marking).
There is the option to display the values as current or root-mean-square values.
The status diagram serves to represent the fault recording trigger time as defined status.
If user-defined status signals have been set to select individual times, these times are displayed in the status diagram with the corresponding symbol.
In addition to the graphical representation, the values of individual signals can be read at defined times from a diagram, and the current position of Cursor 1 and Cursor 2 can be read from the time axis. If a cursor is moved in a view other than that of time signals, the cursor position in the time signal view is changed, as well.
The Vector Diagram view serves to visualize measured and calculated magnitudes as complex vectors at defined times.
The diagram on the left is clearly assigned to Cursor 1 and the diagram on the right to Cursor 2.
The vector of the measured magnitudes is r.m.s. values of the harmonic component
(nominal frequency TN.). The amount and angle of the vector are determined via a full-cycle DFT (Discrete Fourier Transformation).
The measuring window is always left of the reference time (cursor position) and has the length of a time of the nominal frequency TN (for ex., 50 Hz « 20 ms).
The vector angle refers to a standard vector rotating at a nominal frequency of (fN=nominal frequency).
As a supplement to the graphical representation, you can use a diagram to read the signal values at specified times and the corresponding position of Cursor 1 and Cursor 2 on the time axis. If a cursor is moved in one view, the current vector diagram is changed, as well.

