- 1. Introduction
- 2. Why Is Directional Overcurrent Protection Required?
- 3. ANSI 67 and ANSI 67N
- 4. Operating Principle of Directional Overcurrent Protection
- 5. Voltage Polarization and Directional Characteristics
- 6. Forward and Reverse Direction
- 7. Phase Directional Polarization Methods
- 8. Directional Earth-Fault Protection (ANSI 67N)
- 9. CT and VT Requirements for Directional Protection
- 10. Practical Applications of ANSI 67
- 11. Directional Overcurrent Coordination
- 12. GE Multilin Relay Configuration and EnerVista Engineering
- 13. Testing GE Multilin Directional Overcurrent Protection
- 14. Common Directional Protection Problems
- 15. Practical Commissioning Checklist
- 16. Engineering Recommendations
- 17. Conclusion
- 18. Training on GE Multilin Protection Relays by Elec-Engg
1. Introduction
Directional overcurrent protection is an essential protection function in electrical networks where fault current can flow in more than one direction. Unlike conventional overcurrent protection, which operates primarily according to current magnitude and time, directional overcurrent protection also evaluates the direction of the fault current.
GE Multilin protection relays provide directional overcurrent protection in selected relay families and models. Depending on the application and relay configuration, directional elements can be used for phase faults, earth faults, or both.
The two main ANSI device numbers are:
- ANSI 67: AC directional overcurrent protection.
- ANSI 67N: Directional earth-fault or neutral overcurrent protection.
These functions are particularly important in ring networks, parallel feeders, interconnected substations, networks with multiple sources, and industrial power systems with distributed generation.
This article explains the operating principles of GE Multilin directional overcurrent protection, polarizing quantities, directional characteristics, forward and reverse operation, practical applications, configuration considerations, and commissioning tests.
2. Why Is Directional Overcurrent Protection Required?
In a simple radial distribution network supplied from one source, fault current normally flows from the source toward the fault. Conventional non-directional overcurrent protection can often provide adequate discrimination when correctly coordinated.
However, the situation becomes more complicated when a network has multiple sources or alternative current paths.
Consider a ring network supplied from two substations. If a fault occurs on one section, current may flow toward the fault from both directions. A conventional overcurrent relay may detect the fault current but cannot necessarily determine whether the fault is in its intended protection zone.
Directional protection solves this problem by evaluating both:
- The magnitude of the measured current.
- The phase relationship between the operating current and a suitable polarizing reference.
The relay can therefore distinguish between forward and reverse fault conditions.
Typical applications
Directional overcurrent protection is commonly applied to:
- Ring distribution networks.
- Parallel incoming and outgoing feeders.
- Networks supplied from multiple transformers.
- Industrial power systems with multiple generators.
- Networks containing embedded generation.
- Interconnected substations.
- Transformer backup protection.
- Bus coupler and bus-section protection schemes.
- Ground-fault protection in systems with complex earthing arrangements.
3. ANSI 67 and ANSI 67N
Although both functions use directional supervision, they are intended for different fault types.
3.1 ANSI 67 – Phase Directional Overcurrent Protection
ANSI 67 detects phase overcurrent conditions and determines whether the fault current flows in the configured forward or reverse direction.
The relay normally evaluates phase currents and suitable polarizing voltages. The exact measurement and polarization method depends on the relay model and protection implementation.
Typical applications include:
- Three-phase faults.
- Phase-to-phase faults.
- Phase-to-earth faults where phase directional elements are used.
- Directional phase overcurrent backup protection.
3.2 ANSI 67N – Directional Earth-Fault Protection
ANSI 67N is used to detect earth faults and determine their direction.
Depending on the system and relay design, the operating quantity may be derived from residual current, neutral current, or another configured earth-fault measurement. The polarizing quantity may be derived from residual voltage, neutral voltage, or another suitable reference.
Typical applications include:
- Earth faults in ring networks.
- Earth faults in parallel feeders.
- Ground-fault protection in resistance-grounded systems.
- Directional earth-fault backup protection.
- Networks where earth-fault current can flow in multiple directions.
It is important to distinguish between residual current protection and directional earth-fault protection. Measuring residual current alone does not establish the direction of an earth fault.
4. Operating Principle of Directional Overcurrent Protection
A directional overcurrent element generally uses two separate decisions.
First decision: Overcurrent detection
The relay checks whether the measured current exceeds the configured pickup value.
Second decision: Directional supervision
The relay evaluates the relationship between the operating quantity and the polarizing quantity to determine whether the fault is in the permitted direction.
The trip condition can be represented conceptually as:
Trip = Overcurrent pickup AND Directional permission AND Applicable time-delay condition
The actual logic may include additional supervision, blocking, interlocking, or programmable logic.
4.1 Operating Current
For phase directional protection, the operating quantity is normally a phase current, such as IA, IB, or IC.
For directional earth-fault protection, the operating quantity may be residual current:
I0 = IA + IB + IC
The residual current may be obtained from three phase CT measurements or from a dedicated core-balance CT, depending on the installation and relay configuration.
4.2 Polarizing Quantity
The polarizing quantity provides a reference for determining the direction of the fault current.
For phase directional protection, voltage polarization is commonly used. The relay compares the operating current with a selected voltage reference.
For earth-fault directional protection, residual voltage or another suitable polarization quantity may be used.
The availability and selection of polarizing quantities depend on the relay model, VT arrangement, system earthing, and configured protection function.
5. Voltage Polarization and Directional Characteristics
A directional relay does not simply compare current and voltage magnitudes. It evaluates their phase relationship.
A simplified representation of the directional decision is based on the angle between the operating current and the polarizing voltage:
θ = Angle between the operating quantity and the polarizing reference
The relay uses a directional characteristic to determine whether this angle represents forward or reverse operation.
5.1 Maximum Torque Angle
The term Maximum Torque Angle (MTA) is commonly used in directional protection to describe the angle at which the directional element has maximum operating sensitivity.
Some relay manufacturers use related terms such as characteristic angle or directional characteristic angle. The exact terminology, reference convention, and setting definition must be taken from the applicable GE Multilin relay manual.
The directional characteristic is important because the phase relationship between current and voltage changes with the type of fault and the network impedance.
5.2 Directional Operating Region
The directional element typically has an operating region and a restraining region.
- Forward region: The measured quantities fall within the configured forward directional characteristic.
- Reverse region: The quantities indicate the opposite direction.
- Non-operating or uncertain region: The relay may not issue directional permission because the measured quantities do not provide sufficient directional evidence.
The exact angular boundaries depend on the relay implementation and settings.
5.3 Why Directional Settings Matter
Incorrect directional settings can cause serious protection problems.
For example:
- A forward fault may be interpreted as reverse.
- A reverse fault may incorrectly receive forward permission.
- A relay may fail to operate for an internal fault.
- An external fault may cause unwanted operation.
- Coordination between adjacent feeders may be lost.
Directional settings must therefore be checked against the actual CT and VT connections and the network’s defined reference direction.
6. Forward and Reverse Direction
Forward and reverse are not universal physical directions. They are defined relative to the relay’s configured reference direction.
The engineer must establish the intended forward direction using:
- CT polarity.
- Current input phase assignment.
- VT phase connections.
- Relay phase rotation configuration.
- Protection-zone arrangement.
- Directional reference settings.
For a feeder relay, forward direction is commonly defined from the busbar toward the protected feeder. However, the actual definition must be confirmed from the project drawings and relay configuration.
Practical example
Assume a substation busbar supplies two interconnected feeders.
The protection engineer defines the forward direction of each feeder relay from the busbar toward its protected feeder.
If a fault occurs on Feeder 1, the relay at the source end of Feeder 1 should recognize the fault as forward.
A relay on an adjacent feeder may detect current associated with the same network disturbance, but its directional element should identify the condition as reverse if the fault is behind its configured forward direction.
This directional discrimination helps the protection system isolate the faulty feeder without unnecessarily disconnecting healthy sections.
7. Phase Directional Polarization Methods
Different relay designs use different polarization methods. The appropriate method depends on the network configuration and the available voltage signals.
7.1 Phase-to-Phase Voltage Polarization
A phase directional element may use a voltage associated with the other two phases as its polarizing reference.
For example, the B-C voltage may be used as a reference for the A-phase directional element in an appropriate phase-selection arrangement.
This approach is commonly associated with cross-polarized directional protection.
7.2 Positive-Sequence Voltage Polarization
Positive-sequence voltage can provide a reference for directional protection, particularly where phase voltages are disturbed during unbalanced faults.
The relay’s implementation determines how positive-sequence quantities are calculated and used.
7.3 Memory Voltage Polarization
During close-in faults, the voltage at the relay location can collapse significantly. This can make directional determination difficult if the relay relies only on the instantaneous fault voltage.
Some numerical relays use memory polarization, retaining a pre-fault voltage reference for a limited period to support directional decisions during voltage depression.
Whether and how this feature is implemented must be verified for the selected GE Multilin model.
8. Directional Earth-Fault Protection (ANSI 67N)
Earth-fault directional protection requires special attention because the current and voltage relationships depend strongly on the system earthing arrangement.
8.1 Residual Current
Residual current is commonly calculated as:
Ires = IA + IB + IC
Under balanced operating conditions, the vector sum of the three phase currents is approximately zero.
During an earth fault, the residual current may become significant.
Alternatively, a dedicated core-balance CT can measure the earth-fault current directly. The chosen measurement arrangement must be supported by the relay and correctly configured.
8.2 Residual Voltage
Residual voltage can be represented as:
3V0 = VA + VB + VC
In practice, this quantity may be measured or calculated depending on the VT arrangement and relay design.
An open-delta or broken-delta VT secondary connection is one possible method of obtaining residual voltage. The voltage transformer arrangement must be designed and connected appropriately for the system.
8.3 System Earthing and Directional Earth Faults
The earth-fault current depends on the network’s neutral-earthing arrangement.
Common arrangements include:
- Solidly earthed systems.
- Resistance-earthed systems.
- Reactance-earthed systems.
- Isolated-neutral systems.
- Resonant-earthed systems.
The directional method suitable for one earthing arrangement may not be suitable for another.
For example, in resistance-earthed systems, earth-fault current may be sufficiently high for conventional directional earth-fault measurement. In isolated or resonant-earthed networks, specialized directional methods may be required.
Some relays provide wattmetric, admittance-based, or other specialized earth-fault directional methods. Their availability must be verified for the specific GE Multilin relay and firmware.
9. CT and VT Requirements for Directional Protection
Directional protection is particularly sensitive to incorrect instrument-transformer connections.
9.1 CT Polarity
CT polarity determines the reference direction of measured current.
A reversed CT connection can cause the relay to interpret forward current as reverse current.
The engineer should verify:
- P1 and P2 primary polarity.
- S1 and S2 secondary terminals.
- Relay current input polarity.
- Phase identification.
- CT secondary earthing.
- CT ratio and rated secondary current.
9.2 VT Phase Assignment
The VT connections must provide the correct voltage references for the directional elements.
Check:
- Phase-to-phase voltage connections.
- Phase-to-neutral voltage connections.
- Phase rotation.
- VT ratio.
- VT secondary earthing.
- Fuse and MCB arrangements.
- Open-delta or residual voltage connections, where applicable.
9.3 Phase Sequence
A phase-sequence error can produce incorrect phase relationships between current and voltage.
For directional protection, this can result in incorrect forward/reverse decisions.
The engineer should verify phase rotation using drawings, primary-system information, and suitable commissioning measurements.
10. Practical Applications of ANSI 67
10.1 Ring Distribution Network
In a ring network, current may reach a fault from more than one direction.
Directional overcurrent relays can identify the fault direction and coordinate the isolation of the faulty section.
10.2 Parallel Feeders
Where two feeders operate in parallel, a fault on one feeder can produce current contributions from both paths.
Directional protection helps distinguish the feeder carrying current toward the fault from the healthy feeder carrying current in the opposite direction.
10.3 Multiple Transformer Sources
Industrial substations may have two or more transformers supplying interconnected bus sections.
When bus couplers are closed, fault current distribution can change significantly.
Directional overcurrent protection can provide improved selectivity compared with non-directional protection alone.
10.4 Distributed Generation
When generators or other embedded sources are connected to a distribution network, fault-current direction may differ from the assumptions used in a conventional radial protection design.
Directional elements can help maintain protection discrimination under different network operating conditions.
However, inverter-based resources may have limited or controlled fault-current contributions. Protection settings must reflect the actual source characteristics and network study.
11. Directional Overcurrent Coordination
Directional supervision does not replace time-current coordination. It adds a direction criterion to the overcurrent function.
A typical protection scheme may use:
- Forward directional overcurrent as the primary feeder protection.
- Reverse directional overcurrent as backup or blocking logic.
- Time-delayed operation for coordination.
- Instantaneous directional overcurrent where suitable.
- Directional earth-fault protection for ground faults.
Important coordination considerations
- Identify the minimum and maximum fault-current levels.
- Determine current contributions from all connected sources.
- Establish the forward direction for every relay.
- Select suitable pickup values.
- Select the directional characteristic.
- Coordinate operating times with adjacent relays.
- Check normal load and maximum emergency loading.
- Consider different network configurations.
- Verify the effect of generators and tie-breaker positions.
- Confirm backup protection for communication or VT failure conditions where relevant.
A coordination study should examine credible operating configurations, not just the normal network arrangement.
12. GE Multilin Relay Configuration and EnerVista Engineering
GE Multilin directional protection configuration is model-dependent. Available functions, setting names, logic options, and engineering interfaces can differ between relay families and firmware versions.
The following is a general engineering workflow rather than a model-specific menu procedure.
Step 1 – Identify the Relay Model
Confirm the exact relay model, hardware configuration, firmware version, and installed protection options.
Examples of GE Multilin families include Universal Relay (UR) products and selected distribution and industrial protection relays.
Do not assume that every model supports identical ANSI 67 or 67N functionality.
Step 2 – Verify CT and VT Configuration
Enter and verify:
- CT primary and secondary ratings.
- VT primary and secondary ratings.
- Current phase assignment.
- Voltage phase assignment.
- Phase rotation.
- Residual current measurement arrangement.
- Residual voltage measurement arrangement, where applicable.
Step 3 – Enable the Directional Protection Elements
Enable the relevant phase or earth-fault directional protection functions if supported by the selected model.
Confirm the available operating quantities and directional polarization method in the relay manual.
Step 4 – Configure Overcurrent Settings
Set the relevant parameters, which may include:
- Phase overcurrent pickup.
- Earth-fault pickup.
- Instantaneous or time-delayed operation.
- Time-current characteristic.
- Operating time or time multiplier.
- Directional supervision.
- Forward/reverse selection.
Step 5 – Configure Trip Logic
Confirm how the directional and overcurrent elements are combined.
Verify that the intended protection element operates the correct trip output and that any blocking or interlocking logic is correctly applied.
Step 6 – Verify the Configuration
Before energization:
- Review the complete settings file.
- Confirm the intended protection direction.
- Check the CT and VT wiring drawings.
- Verify the logic matrix.
- Review event and oscillography configuration.
- Save and document the approved settings revision.
13. Testing GE Multilin Directional Overcurrent Protection
Directional protection must be tested for both overcurrent pickup and directional discrimination.
A relay that passes a simple current injection test has not necessarily demonstrated correct directional operation.
13.1 Secondary Injection Test Equipment
A suitable protection relay test set can provide controlled current and voltage signals with adjustable phase angles.
The test equipment should support the required number of current and voltage channels for the selected test method.
13.2 Current Pickup Test
The purpose is to confirm that the overcurrent element operates at the configured pickup level.
Procedure:
- Apply the appropriate voltage signals if directional supervision is required.
- Inject current below the configured pickup.
- Increase current gradually.
- Record the pickup value.
- Compare the result with the approved setting and applicable tolerance.
13.3 Forward Direction Test
The purpose is to verify that the relay recognizes the configured forward direction.
Procedure:
- Apply the required polarizing voltage.
- Inject current above the overcurrent pickup.
- Set the current-to-voltage phase relationship within the expected forward operating region.
- Confirm directional permission.
- Verify the expected trip or start indication, according to the test logic.
- Record the operating result.
13.4 Reverse Direction Test
The purpose is to verify that the relay restrains operation for reverse current when forward operation is required.
Procedure:
- Maintain suitable polarizing voltage.
- Inject current above the overcurrent pickup.
- Change the phase relationship to the reverse region.
- Confirm that the forward directional element blocks operation.
- Check the relay’s directional status indications.
The exact test angles must be taken from the relay’s directional characteristic and the configured reference convention.
13.5 Directional Characteristic Test
A more complete test checks the directional operating boundary.
The test engineer varies the current-to-voltage angle while maintaining suitable current and polarizing voltage magnitudes.
The results can be plotted to confirm the operating and restraining regions.
The test should consider:
- Forward operating region.
- Reverse restraining region.
- Characteristic angle.
- Directional boundary.
- Polarizing voltage supervision.
- Minimum operating voltage, where applicable.
13.6 ANSI 67N Testing
For directional earth-fault protection, the test must reproduce the required operating and polarizing quantities.
Depending on the selected relay implementation, this may require residual current and residual voltage injection or another supported combination.
The test engineer should verify:
- Correct residual-current measurement.
- Correct residual-voltage measurement.
- Forward earth-fault direction.
- Reverse earth-fault direction.
- Pickup and timing.
- Trip logic.
- Behavior when the polarizing quantity is insufficient or unavailable.
Do not assume that a three-phase current injection alone is sufficient to test every 67N implementation.
14. Common Directional Protection Problems
Problem 1 – Forward Fault Detected as Reverse
Possible causes:
- Reversed CT polarity.
- Incorrect phase assignment.
- Incorrect VT phase sequence.
- Incorrect directional reference.
- Incorrect characteristic-angle setting.
Recommended action: Verify the complete current and voltage measurement chain before changing directional settings.
Problem 2 – Relay Does Not Operate for a Forward Fault
Possible causes:
- Current below pickup.
- Directional element restraining operation.
- Insufficient polarizing voltage.
- Incorrect VT configuration.
- Incorrect phase rotation.
- Trip logic not configured correctly.
- Protection element disabled.
Recommended action: Review measured quantities, element status, directional status, and trip logic.
Problem 3 – Relay Operates for Reverse Faults
Possible causes:
- Incorrect forward/reverse configuration.
- Reversed CT polarity.
- Incorrect directional characteristic.
- Incorrect logic combination.
- Incorrect current or voltage phase assignment.
Recommended action: Perform controlled forward and reverse secondary injection tests.
Problem 4 – Directional Earth-Fault Protection Is Unstable
Possible causes:
- Incorrect residual CT connection.
- Incorrect residual voltage measurement.
- Unsuitable polarization method for the system earthing arrangement.
- Low earth-fault current.
- Incorrect neutral or VT wiring.
- Incorrect settings or logic.
Recommended action: Review the earthing design and confirm that the selected directional method is appropriate for the network.
Problem 5 – Directional Element Is Unavailable
Possible causes:
- The selected relay model does not support the required function.
- The function is not included in the installed configuration.
- Required hardware inputs are unavailable.
- Firmware or settings compatibility limitations.
Recommended action: Check the exact model documentation and supported firmware features.
15. Practical Commissioning Checklist
Before energizing a GE Multilin relay with directional overcurrent protection, verify the following:
- Correct relay model and firmware identified.
- Approved settings file loaded.
- CT ratios and polarities checked.
- VT ratios and phase assignments checked.
- Phase rotation verified.
- Residual current measurement verified.
- Residual voltage measurement verified, where applicable.
- Forward direction confirmed against the protection drawings.
- Reverse direction confirmed.
- Phase overcurrent pickup tested.
- Earth-fault pickup tested.
- Directional characteristic tested.
- Time-delay operation verified.
- Trip outputs and breaker interface tested.
- Blocking and interlocking logic checked.
- Event records and oscillography verified.
- Final test results documented.
16. Engineering Recommendations
Directional overcurrent protection should be designed as part of an overall protection and coordination philosophy.
The following recommendations are particularly important:
- Define forward direction consistently across the protection drawings and relay settings.
- Verify CT and VT polarity before performing directional tests.
- Select a polarization method appropriate to the fault type and network.
- Consider voltage depression during close-in faults.
- Evaluate all credible network configurations.
- Check directional earth-fault suitability against the system earthing arrangement.
- Do not copy directional settings from another relay without verifying the application.
- Test both forward and reverse operating conditions.
- Confirm the relay’s actual trip logic rather than relying only on element indications.
- Keep the final approved settings and test reports under revision control.
17. Conclusion
GE Multilin directional overcurrent protection provides an important means of achieving selectivity in networks where fault current can flow in multiple directions.
ANSI 67 provides directional phase overcurrent protection, while ANSI 67N provides directional earth-fault protection. Both functions require correct measurement inputs, suitable polarization, appropriate directional settings, and coordinated operating times.
For commissioning engineers, one of the most important tasks is to verify the complete measurement chain: CT polarity, VT phase assignment, phase rotation, directional reference, and trip logic.
A successful commissioning test must demonstrate that the relay operates for the intended forward fault conditions and restrains correctly for reverse conditions.
The exact capabilities, setting names, and testing procedures must always be confirmed against the documentation for the selected GE Multilin relay model and firmware.
18. Training on GE Multilin Protection Relays by Elec-Engg
Elec-Engg provides practical technical training by Dr Saeed Roostaee (Electrical Engineering) for engineers working in power system protection, relay engineering, commissioning, operation, and maintenance.
Relevant training topics include:
- GE Multilin relay architecture and hardware configuration.
- Protection functions and ANSI device numbers.
- Phase and earth-fault overcurrent protection.
- Directional overcurrent protection (67/67N).
- CT and VT configuration and polarity verification.
- Protection coordination and relay settings.
- EnerVista software and relay configuration.
- Secondary injection testing and commissioning.
- Fault analysis, event records, and oscillography.
- Practical troubleshooting of protection schemes.
Training is available through pre-recorded video courses, structured self-paced training, live online sessions, face-to-face courses, and customized in-house programs.
Visit https://elec-engg.com/ to explore available technical training programs or contact Elec-Engg through https://elec-engg.com/contact/ for customized training requirements.
