GE Multilin Line Differential Protection (ANSI 87L): L90 Relay, Differential Principles, Communication Channels, CT Saturation and Testing

Table Of Contents
  1. 1. Introduction
  2. 2. What Is Line Differential Protection?
  3. 3. GE Multilin L90 Line Differential Relay
  4. 4. Protection Zone and CT Locations
  5. 5. Differential Current and Restraint Current
  6. 6. Why Is Communication Required?
  7. 7. Communication Delay and Current Alignment
  8. 8. Fibre-Optic Communication in Line Differential Protection
  9. 9. CT Requirements for Line Differential Protection
  10. 10. Line Charging Current
  11. 11. Multi-Terminal Line Differential Protection
  12. 12. Line Differential Protection Settings
  13. 13. Practical Line Differential Protection Example
  14. 14. GE Multilin L90 Configuration and Engineering
  15. 15. Testing GE Multilin Line Differential Protection
  16. 16. Common Line Differential Protection Problems
  17. 17. Practical Commissioning Checklist
  18. 18. Engineering Recommendations
  19. 19. Conclusion
  20. 20. Training on GE Multilin Line Protection by Elec-Engg

1. Introduction

Transmission lines and important distribution circuits require fast, selective, and dependable protection against electrical faults. One of the most effective protection methods for these applications is line current differential protection, identified by ANSI device number 87L.

Line differential protection compares the currents measured at different terminals of a protected line. Under normal operating conditions and for external faults, the currents entering and leaving the protected zone should balance after accounting for current reference directions and measurement errors.

For an internal fault, the current balance is disturbed. The differential protection detects this imbalance and issues a trip command to isolate the protected line.

GE Multilin provides line differential protection solutions, including the L90 Line Differential System in its Universal Relay family. The L90 is designed for line protection applications and uses communication between line terminals to exchange information required by its differential protection scheme.

This article explains the engineering principles of GE Multilin line differential protection, with emphasis on the L90 relay, differential and restraint currents, communication channels, CT performance, settings, testing, and commissioning.

2. What Is Line Differential Protection?

Line differential protection is a unit protection scheme. It protects a clearly defined electrical zone between the current transformers at the line terminals.

For a simple two-terminal line, the relay receives current measurements from both ends.

Under normal load conditions, current entering the protected line at one end should correspond to current leaving at the other end, considering the selected current reference directions.

For an internal fault, current contributions from the connected sources flow toward the fault. The resulting current imbalance allows the differential relay to identify the fault as internal to the protected zone.

Basic operating principle

A simplified differential-current expression is:

Idiff = |IA + IB|

Where:

  • IA is the current measured at terminal A.
  • IB is the current measured at terminal B.
  • The currents are expressed using consistent reference directions.

The relay must receive and correctly align the remote current information before performing the differential calculation.

For multi-terminal lines, the differential calculation considers the current contributions from all protected terminals.

3. GE Multilin L90 Line Differential Relay

The GE Multilin L90 belongs to the Universal Relay family and is designed for line protection applications.

Its capabilities depend on the exact model, hardware configuration, firmware, and enabled functions.

Typical line protection engineering applications may include:

  • Line current differential protection.
  • Phase and earth-fault protection.
  • Distance protection, where supported and configured.
  • Overcurrent backup protection.
  • Communication-assisted protection schemes.
  • Breaker failure initiation.
  • Event recording and oscillography.
  • Line monitoring and programmable logic.

The L90 is particularly relevant to applications where high-speed unit protection is required and suitable communication infrastructure is available between line terminals.

The relay’s actual protection elements, communication options, and redundancy arrangements must be verified using the applicable product documentation.

4. Protection Zone and CT Locations

The line differential protection zone is normally defined by the locations of the CTs at the line terminals.

Consider a two-terminal transmission line:

Substation A → CT-A → Protected transmission line → CT-B → Substation B

The CTs measure the current entering and leaving the protected zone.

The protection scheme must correctly account for:

  • CT ratios.
  • CT polarity.
  • Phase identification.
  • Current reference directions.
  • Terminal configuration.
  • Line charging current.
  • Communication and synchronization requirements.

4.1 Internal Fault

An internal fault occurs between the CT locations.

Examples include:

  • Phase-to-earth faults.
  • Phase-to-phase faults.
  • Double-phase-to-earth faults.
  • Three-phase faults.
  • Conductor faults within the protected line section.

For an internal fault, current contributions from the connected sources generally flow toward the fault. The relay detects the resulting differential current and can issue a trip command to the relevant circuit breakers.

4.2 External Fault

An external fault occurs outside the differential protection zone.

Examples include:

  • Busbar faults.
  • Faults on adjacent feeders.
  • Faults beyond the remote terminal CT.
  • Faults on connected equipment outside the protected line section.

For an external fault, the current entering the protected zone should correspond to the current leaving it. The differential relay must remain stable.

5. Differential Current and Restraint Current

Line differential protection generally uses an operating quantity and a restraint quantity.

5.1 Differential Current

For a simplified two-terminal application:

Idiff = |IA + IB|

The calculation assumes that both currents have been referred to the same phase and reference direction.

A significant differential current indicates a possible internal fault.

5.2 Restraint Current

The restraint quantity provides security during external faults and measurement errors.

A simplified expression is:

Ibias = (|IA| + |IB|) / 2

Actual relay algorithms may use different definitions, scaling factors, and characteristic calculations.

5.3 Percentage Differential Characteristic

The relay compares differential current against a characteristic determined by restraint current.

A simplified operating condition is:

Idiff > Imin + Slope × Ibias

Where:

  • Imin is the minimum differential pickup.
  • Slope is the percentage restraint setting.
  • Ibias is the restraint current.

Some relays use multiple slopes or additional regions to improve stability across different operating conditions.

The exact characteristic and parameter definitions must be taken from the L90 documentation.

6. Why Is Communication Required?

Unlike conventional local overcurrent protection, line differential protection requires information from the other terminal or terminals.

The local relay cannot independently determine the total current entering and leaving the entire protected line zone using only its local CT measurements.

Remote current information is therefore exchanged through a suitable communication system.

Typical communication arrangements

Depending on the relay hardware and project design, communication may use:

  • Dedicated fibre-optic channels.
  • Multiplexer-based communication systems.
  • Telecommunication networks.
  • Other supported digital communication interfaces.

The actual interface, channel architecture, bandwidth, and protocol must be confirmed for the selected L90 configuration.

6.1 Communication Channel Requirements

A line differential scheme requires a communication channel with suitable performance.

Important considerations include:

  • Communication delay.
  • Delay variation.
  • Channel availability.
  • Data integrity.
  • Synchronization.
  • Channel redundancy.
  • Communication failure detection.
  • Protection behavior during channel interruption.

The channel must be engineered according to the manufacturer’s requirements and the utility’s protection standards.

7. Communication Delay and Current Alignment

One of the important technical challenges in line differential protection is the alignment of current measurements from different terminals.

Current signals are sampled at different physical locations and transmitted through a communication channel.

If the relay does not correctly compensate for communication delay and align the received information, the calculated differential current may become inaccurate.

7.1 Communication Latency

Latency is the time required for information to travel from one terminal to another.

The actual impact depends on the communication architecture and the relay’s processing method.

7.2 Delay Variation

Changes in communication delay can affect the timing relationship between local and remote measurements.

Protection engineers should verify that the communication network meets the relay manufacturer’s performance requirements.

7.3 Channel Monitoring

The relay should supervise the communication channel and provide appropriate alarms or status indications.

The protection scheme must have a defined response to communication failure.

Depending on the design, differential protection may become unavailable or restrained when the channel is lost. Other independent protection functions, such as distance or overcurrent protection, may provide backup.

The exact behavior must be verified from the configured relay logic and protection design.

8. Fibre-Optic Communication in Line Differential Protection

Fibre-optic communication is widely used in modern transmission-line protection because it offers several advantages.

These include:

  • Electrical isolation.
  • Immunity to electromagnetic interference.
  • High data capacity.
  • Long-distance communication capability, depending on the optical system.
  • Reliable transmission when correctly engineered.

8.1 Direct Fibre Connections

Some protection schemes use dedicated fibre links between line terminals.

The relay communication hardware must support the selected connection arrangement.

8.2 Multiplexer-Based Communication

In some installations, protection data is transported through a telecommunications multiplexer.

The engineering design must account for the complete communication path, including intermediate equipment and network interfaces.

8.3 Fibre-Optic Commissioning Checks

Before enabling line differential protection, verify:

  • Correct fibre type.
  • Correct connector type.
  • Correct transmit and receive connections.
  • Optical power levels.
  • Link status.
  • Communication interface configuration.
  • Channel delay performance.
  • End-to-end communication.
  • Alarm and failure indications.

Fibre connection and optical testing should follow the equipment manufacturer’s procedures.

9. CT Requirements for Line Differential Protection

CT performance is critical to the security of line differential protection.

During normal load, the currents at both ends should balance closely.

During an external fault, however, the through-current can become very high. If one CT saturates significantly before the other, the measured currents may become unequal.

This creates a false differential current.

9.1 CT Saturation

CT saturation occurs when the magnetic core cannot reproduce the primary current accurately.

Possible causes include:

  • High primary fault current.
  • High secondary burden.
  • High secondary lead resistance.
  • Significant DC offset in fault current.
  • Inadequate CT knee-point performance.
  • Incorrect CT application.

9.2 External Fault Stability

The line differential relay must remain stable for external faults, including demanding conditions involving CT saturation.

The relay’s differential characteristic and any dedicated CT saturation detection or security features should be understood and configured according to the manufacturer’s recommendations.

9.3 CT Engineering Checks

Verify:

  • CT ratio.
  • Protection accuracy class.
  • Secondary rated current.
  • Knee-point voltage, where applicable.
  • Secondary winding resistance.
  • Connected burden.
  • Cable resistance.
  • CT polarity.
  • Maximum system fault current.

CT suitability should be assessed using the actual system fault level and protection design.

10. Line Charging Current

Transmission lines have distributed capacitance.

Even when there is no external load, a line can draw charging current due to its capacitance.

For a long transmission line, this current may become significant.

The differential relay must account for line charging current according to its protection algorithm and configuration.

10.1 Why Charging Current Matters

The current measured at the two terminals may not be identical because the line itself draws charging current.

This can create a differential component under normal operating conditions.

10.2 Compensation and Stability

The relay’s treatment of line charging current depends on its design and available settings.

The engineer should review the manufacturer’s guidance, particularly for long lines, underground cables, and applications with substantial capacitive current.

Do not assume that all line differential relays use identical charging-current compensation methods.

11. Multi-Terminal Line Differential Protection

Some transmission networks contain more than two terminals connected to the same protected line zone.

For example, a three-terminal line may connect substations A, B, and C.

The differential protection scheme must consider the current contributions from all terminals.

A simplified expression is:

Idiff = |IA + IB + IC|

The actual implementation depends on the relay architecture and the supported multi-terminal scheme.

Engineering considerations

Multi-terminal applications require additional attention to:

  • Communication links.
  • Terminal identification.
  • Current reference directions.
  • Communication delay.
  • Protection-zone configuration.
  • Channel failure behavior.
  • Switching and isolation arrangements.

The number of supported terminals and the required hardware and communication topology must be checked against the exact L90 product documentation.

12. Line Differential Protection Settings

Line differential protection settings should be selected based on the line application, CT performance, system fault levels, communication characteristics, and protection philosophy.

Typical setting considerations include:

12.1 Minimum Differential Pickup

The minimum pickup determines the differential current required to initiate operation at low restraint current.

It should provide adequate sensitivity for internal faults while remaining secure for normal measurement errors and charging current.

12.2 Differential Restraint Slope

The restraint slope improves security as through-current increases.

The setting should consider CT errors and the expected conditions during external faults.

12.3 High-Set Differential Protection

Where a high-set differential element is available, its setting must be chosen to ensure dependable operation for high-current internal faults without compromising security.

12.4 Line Charging Compensation

For applications requiring charging-current compensation, configure the relevant parameters using the relay’s supported method.

12.5 Communication Supervision

Confirm the channel supervision parameters and the intended protection behavior during communication failure.

12.6 Backup Protection

Line differential protection should be considered alongside independent backup protection.

Depending on the project, backup functions may include:

  • Distance protection (ANSI 21).
  • Phase overcurrent protection (ANSI 50/51).
  • Directional overcurrent protection (ANSI 67).
  • Earth-fault protection.
  • Breaker failure protection (ANSI 50BF).

The backup arrangement should be coordinated with adjacent protection zones and the utility protection philosophy.

13. Practical Line Differential Protection Example

Consider a two-terminal 132 kV transmission line connecting Substation A and Substation B.

Assume:

  • CT ratio at Terminal A: 800/1 A.
  • CT ratio at Terminal B: 800/1 A.
  • Normal load current: 400 A primary.
  • Both terminals use correctly connected CTs.
  • The relay communication channel is healthy.

At each terminal, the corresponding CT secondary current is:

400 / 800 = 0.5 A

For normal load, the two currents should balance when expressed using the relay’s common reference direction.

Case 1 – Normal Load

The relay receives approximately equal and opposite current contributions according to its reference convention.

The differential current should remain low, and the relay should restrain operation.

Case 2 – External Fault

A fault occurs on the busbar at Substation B, outside the protected line zone.

A high through-current flows through the line.

The differential relay should remain stable despite the high current, provided the CTs and protection scheme perform within their design limits.

Case 3 – Internal Fault

A phase-to-earth fault occurs halfway along the protected transmission line.

Current contributions from both substations flow toward the fault.

The differential current increases and the relay identifies the condition as an internal fault.

The relay then issues trip commands to the relevant circuit breakers at the line terminals according to the protection scheme.

This example illustrates the principle. Actual operating quantities and settings must be determined from the system study and relay configuration.

14. GE Multilin L90 Configuration and Engineering

GE Multilin L90 configuration is performed using the appropriate engineering software and device-specific settings structure.

The exact software version, setting names, communication options, and available functions depend on the relay firmware and hardware.

A general engineering workflow is outlined below.

Step 1 – Confirm Relay and Hardware Information

Identify:

  • Exact L90 model.
  • Firmware version.
  • Installed communication hardware.
  • Current input configuration.
  • Binary input and output configuration.
  • Available protection functions.

Step 2 – Configure Line Terminal Information

Confirm the number of terminals and the intended protection-zone arrangement.

Verify that each terminal is correctly identified and associated with its communication connection.

Step 3 – Configure CT Data

Enter the appropriate CT ratios and verify:

  • Current input assignments.
  • CT polarity.
  • Phase identification.
  • Current reference directions.

Step 4 – Configure Communication

Configure the supported communication interfaces and channel parameters.

Verify communication with the remote terminal before relying on the differential protection function.

Step 5 – Configure Differential Protection

Review the relevant settings, including:

  • Differential pickup.
  • Restraint characteristic.
  • Slope settings.
  • Charging-current treatment, where applicable.
  • Communication supervision.
  • Relevant blocking and alarm logic.

Step 6 – Configure Backup Protection

Configure additional protection functions according to the protection coordination study.

Verify that backup functions remain available under the intended communication failure conditions.

Step 7 – Configure Trip Logic

Check the complete trip logic for each line terminal.

Confirm the intended breaker trip outputs, breaker failure initiation, alarms, and interlocking signals.

Step 8 – Save and Review the Settings

Save the approved configuration and maintain revision control.

Document the relay model, firmware, settings file, communication arrangement, and test results.

15. Testing GE Multilin Line Differential Protection

Testing line differential protection requires coordination between the terminal relays and the communication system.

Testing only one relay locally may not demonstrate correct operation of the complete line differential scheme.

15.1 Required Test Equipment

Depending on the test scope, commissioning may require:

  • Protection relay test set.
  • Suitable current injection channels.
  • Voltage channels where required by additional functions.
  • Fibre-optic test equipment.
  • Communication test equipment.
  • Suitable access to both line terminals.
  • Approved test procedures and drawings.

15.2 CT Measurement Test

Verify the current measurements at each terminal.

Check:

  • Phase identification.
  • CT ratio scaling.
  • Polarity.
  • Current magnitude.
  • Phase angle.
  • Measurement consistency.

15.3 Communication Channel Test

Verify that the local and remote relays exchange the required protection information.

Check:

  • Channel connection.
  • Communication status.
  • Remote terminal identification.
  • Communication alarms.
  • Delay and performance requirements.
  • Behavior during channel interruption.

15.4 Differential Stability Test

The purpose is to confirm that the relay remains stable under normal load and external fault conditions.

A suitable test method applies current quantities that represent current entering and leaving the protected zone.

The relay should calculate a low differential current and remain restrained.

15.5 Internal Fault Operating Test

The test should simulate current contributions flowing toward an internal fault.

For a two-terminal scheme, the current signals are configured so that the relay calculates the expected differential operating quantity.

Verify:

  • Differential element pickup.
  • Operating time.
  • Trip logic.
  • Output contact operation.
  • Remote-end trip behavior.
  • Event and oscillography records.

15.6 Bias Characteristic Test

Test the differential operating characteristic at different restraint-current levels.

Record the operating threshold and compare the results with the configured characteristic.

15.7 Communication Failure Test

Where permitted by the approved commissioning procedure, simulate communication failure.

Confirm:

  • Correct channel alarm.
  • Correct differential protection response.
  • Correct backup protection availability.
  • No unintended breaker trip.
  • Correct restoration after communication recovery.

The test should be coordinated carefully to avoid unintended trips during commissioning.

15.8 End-to-End Testing

End-to-end testing verifies the complete protection scheme using coordinated signals at the different terminals.

The objective is to demonstrate that the local and remote relays operate correctly for internal faults and remain stable for external faults.

End-to-end testing is particularly important because it checks the combined behavior of the relays, communication channels, and trip logic.

16. Common Line Differential Protection Problems

Problem 1 – Differential Current Is High During Normal Load

Possible causes:

  • Incorrect CT polarity.
  • Incorrect CT ratio.
  • Incorrect phase assignment.
  • Incorrect terminal configuration.
  • Communication data misalignment.
  • Incorrect current reference directions.
  • Incorrect charging-current treatment.

Recommended action: Verify current measurements at both terminals and review the communication and configuration status.

Problem 2 – Differential Protection Does Not Operate for an Internal Fault

Possible causes:

  • Differential element disabled.
  • Incorrect pickup or restraint settings.
  • Communication channel unavailable.
  • Incorrect remote-terminal configuration.
  • Incorrect current measurements.
  • Trip logic not correctly configured.

Recommended action: Review local and remote event records, differential measurements, channel status, and trip logic.

Problem 3 – Unwanted Operation During External Faults

Possible causes:

  • CT saturation.
  • CT polarity error.
  • CT ratio mismatch.
  • Incorrect differential characteristic.
  • Communication timing problems.
  • Incorrect configuration.

Recommended action: Review fault records and evaluate CT performance under the actual external fault conditions.

Problem 4 – Communication Failure Alarm

Possible causes:

  • Damaged fibre.
  • Incorrect transmit/receive connections.
  • Incorrect communication configuration.
  • Faulty interface hardware.
  • Multiplexer or telecommunications failure.
  • Remote relay unavailable.

Recommended action: Check the complete communication path, optical levels, interface status, and remote-end configuration.

Problem 5 – Protection Becomes Unavailable During Network Changes

Possible causes:

  • Communication path changes.
  • Incorrect terminal configuration.
  • Switching-related protection logic.
  • Channel supervision or configuration mismatch.

Recommended action: Review the protection design and verify that the communication architecture supports the intended network operating arrangements.

17. Practical Commissioning Checklist

Before placing a GE Multilin L90 line differential scheme into service, verify:

  • Exact relay models and firmware confirmed.
  • Protection-zone boundaries checked.
  • CT ratios verified at all terminals.
  • CT polarity checked.
  • Phase identification verified.
  • Current reference directions confirmed.
  • Communication hardware verified.
  • Fibre connections checked.
  • Communication channel healthy.
  • Remote terminal identification correct.
  • Communication delay performance acceptable.
  • Differential pickup verified.
  • Restraint characteristic tested.
  • External fault stability verified.
  • Internal fault operation verified.
  • Charging-current treatment reviewed.
  • Communication failure response tested.
  • Backup protection checked.
  • Trip logic and breaker interfaces verified.
  • Event records and oscillography checked.
  • End-to-end test report completed.
  • Final settings and drawings archived.

18. Engineering Recommendations

Line differential protection is highly dependent on the combined performance of the relays, CTs, communication system, and trip circuits.

Important engineering recommendations include:

  1. Define the differential protection zone clearly in the protection drawings.
  2. Verify CT polarity and current reference directions at every terminal.
  3. Assess CT performance for the maximum external fault current.
  4. Engineer the communication channel according to the relay manufacturer’s requirements.
  5. Check communication delay and supervision.
  6. Consider line charging current for long transmission lines and cable circuits.
  7. Test both internal and external fault conditions.
  8. Verify the complete scheme through coordinated end-to-end testing.
  9. Define the protection response to communication failure.
  10. Ensure that suitable independent backup protection is available.
  11. Review all event records and oscillography after commissioning tests.
  12. Maintain controlled settings files and communication drawings.

19. Conclusion

GE Multilin line differential protection provides fast and selective protection for transmission lines and other suitable circuits.

The L90 is an important GE Multilin solution for line protection applications. Its line differential scheme compares current information from the protected terminals through a suitable communication system.

Successful implementation requires more than selecting differential pickup and restraint settings. CT performance, current reference directions, communication delay, channel reliability, line charging current, and backup protection must all be considered.

Commissioning should include local and remote measurement checks, communication testing, differential stability tests, internal fault simulation, and complete end-to-end verification.

The exact functions, communication options, and setting procedures must always be confirmed using the applicable L90 model and firmware documentation.

20. Training on GE Multilin Line Protection by Elec-Engg

Elec-Engg provides practical technical training by Dr Saeed Roostaee (Electrical Engineering) for engineers involved in transmission-line protection, relay engineering, testing, commissioning, and substation automation.

Relevant training topics include:

  • GE Multilin L90 line protection engineering.
  • Line differential protection (ANSI 87L).
  • Differential and restraint current calculations.
  • CT ratio, polarity, and saturation assessment.
  • Fibre-optic communication for protection relays.
  • Communication channel supervision and troubleshooting.
  • Distance protection and backup protection coordination.
  • Differential protection testing and end-to-end commissioning.
  • Event records and oscillography analysis.
  • Practical protection scheme troubleshooting.

Training is available through pre-recorded video courses, structured self-paced programs, live online sessions, face-to-face courses, and customized in-house training.

Visit https://elec-engg.com/ to explore available technical training programs or contact Elec-Engg through https://elec-engg.com/contact/ for customized training requirements.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top