GE Multilin Negative-Sequence Protection (ANSI 46): Phase Unbalance, Current Unbalance, I₂²t Thermal Limits, Motor and Generator Protection, Settings and Testing

Table Of Contents
  1. 1. Introduction
  2. 2. What Is Negative-Sequence Current?
  3. 3. Symmetrical Components and Negative-Sequence Calculation
  4. 4. Why Is Negative-Sequence Current Dangerous?
  5. 5. Causes of Negative-Sequence Current
  6. 6. ANSI 46 Negative-Sequence Protection
  7. 7. Negative-Sequence Protection in Generators
  8. 8. Negative-Sequence Protection in Induction Motors
  9. 9. Negative-Sequence Current and Voltage Unbalance
  10. 10. Negative-Sequence Thermal Protection – I₂²t
  11. 11. Continuous Negative-Sequence Current Limit
  12. 12. Practical Generator Negative-Sequence Calculation
  13. 13. CT Configuration for ANSI 46 Protection
  14. 14. Negative-Sequence Protection and Other Protection Functions
  15. 15. GE Multilin Relay Applications
  16. 16. General GE Multilin Configuration Workflow
  17. 17. Testing and Commissioning of Negative-Sequence Protection
  18. 18. Common Negative-Sequence Protection Problems
  19. 19. Commissioning Checklist
  20. 20. Best Engineering Practices
  21. 21. Training on GE Multilin Protection Relays by Elec-Engg
  22. 22. Frequently Asked Questions
  23. Conclusion

1. Introduction

Negative-sequence protection is an important function in three-phase electrical power systems. It detects current unbalance and identifies operating conditions that can produce dangerous heating in rotating electrical machines.

A three-phase power system is ideally balanced, with three phase currents having equal magnitudes and phase angles separated by 120 degrees. Under normal balanced conditions, the negative-sequence current is approximately zero.

When phase currents become unbalanced, a negative-sequence component appears. This component can produce additional heating in generator rotors and induction motor rotors.

ANSI device number 46 is commonly associated with negative-sequence current protection or phase-balance protection.

GE Multilin generator and motor protection relays may provide negative-sequence measurement and protection functions, depending on the model and firmware.

This article explains symmetrical components, negative-sequence current, generator and motor applications, I₂²t protection, practical calculations, GE Multilin configuration, testing, and troubleshooting.

2. What Is Negative-Sequence Current?

A balanced three-phase system contains three phase currents:

  • Phase A current.
  • Phase B current.
  • Phase C current.

Under balanced conditions:

[
I_A=I_B=I_C
]

in magnitude, with phase displacement of 120 degrees.

When the system becomes unbalanced, the phase currents can be separated into three symmetrical components:

  1. Positive-sequence current.
  2. Negative-sequence current.
  3. Zero-sequence current.

These components are used to analyze unbalanced power-system conditions.

2.1 Positive-sequence current

Positive-sequence currents have equal magnitudes and the normal phase sequence:

A-B-C.

Positive-sequence current represents the balanced component of the three-phase system.

2.2 Negative-sequence current

Negative-sequence currents have equal magnitudes but the opposite phase sequence:

A-C-B.

Negative-sequence current appears during unbalanced operating conditions, including:

  • Unequal phase loading.
  • Phase-to-phase faults.
  • Single-phase faults.
  • Open-phase conditions.
  • Unbalanced supply voltages.
  • Incorrect phase connections.
  • Unequal phase impedances.

2.3 Zero-sequence current

Zero-sequence currents have equal magnitudes and are in phase with one another.

Zero-sequence current is associated with ground-return paths and depends on the system grounding arrangement.

Negative-sequence protection is not the same as earth-fault protection. A system can have significant negative-sequence current without substantial zero-sequence current.

3. Symmetrical Components and Negative-Sequence Calculation

The symmetrical component transformation is based on the operator:

[
a=1\angle120^\circ
]

The positive-sequence current is:

[
I_1=\frac{1}{3}(I_A+aI_B+a^2I_C)
]

The negative-sequence current is:

[
I_2=\frac{1}{3}(I_A+a^2I_B+aI_C)
]

The zero-sequence current is:

[
I_0=\frac{1}{3}(I_A+I_B+I_C)
]

Where:

  • (I_A) = phase A current phasor.
  • (I_B) = phase B current phasor.
  • (I_C) = phase C current phasor.
  • (I_1) = positive-sequence current.
  • (I_2) = negative-sequence current.
  • (I_0) = zero-sequence current.

For a perfectly balanced system:

[
I_2=0
]

and:

[
I_0=0
]

A protection relay can calculate negative-sequence current from its measured phase currents.

4. Why Is Negative-Sequence Current Dangerous?

Negative-sequence current produces a magnetic field that rotates in the opposite direction to the normal rotating magnetic field.

In a synchronous generator, the negative-sequence magnetic field rotates relative to the rotor at approximately twice the system frequency.

This induces currents in the rotor body, damper winding, and other conductive rotor components.

The resulting losses can cause:

  • Rotor surface heating.
  • Damper winding heating.
  • Localized thermal stress.
  • Mechanical stress.
  • Insulation deterioration.
  • Reduced machine life.

Induction motors also experience additional rotor heating under unbalanced supply conditions.

The allowable negative-sequence current therefore depends on the machine design and manufacturer specifications.

5. Causes of Negative-Sequence Current

Common causes include:

5.1 Unbalanced loading

Unequal single-phase loads connected to a three-phase network can produce current unbalance.

Examples include:

  • Single-phase industrial loads.
  • Unequal distribution loads.
  • Large single-phase heating equipment.
  • Unequal phase loading in auxiliary systems.

5.2 Open-phase conditions

An open conductor or defective circuit breaker pole can create severe current unbalance.

Possible causes include:

  • Broken conductor.
  • Loose terminal.
  • Failed breaker contact.
  • Fuse operation in one phase.
  • Cable or busbar connection failure.

5.3 Unbalanced supply voltage

Unequal phase voltages can cause unbalanced currents, particularly in induction motors.

Even a relatively small voltage unbalance can produce a considerably larger current unbalance depending on the machine and network impedance.

5.4 Phase-to-phase faults

A phase-to-phase fault produces an unbalanced current condition and can create substantial negative-sequence current.

5.5 Single-phase-to-ground faults

A single-phase-to-ground fault can produce positive-, negative-, and zero-sequence components.

The exact sequence-current distribution depends on the system grounding and fault impedance.

6. ANSI 46 Negative-Sequence Protection

ANSI 46 protection monitors negative-sequence current and initiates an alarm or trip when the current exceeds the configured operating characteristic.

The relay generally calculates:

[
I_2
]

from the three phase-current measurements.

The negative-sequence current may be expressed in amperes or as a per-unit value.

A common per-unit reference is:

[
I_{2,pu}=\frac{I_2}{I_{\text{rated}}}
]

Where (I_{\text{rated}}) is the selected current reference defined by the relay application.

The exact scaling and reference must be checked in the relay documentation.

7. Negative-Sequence Protection in Generators

Synchronous generators are particularly sensitive to negative-sequence current.

The reverse-rotating magnetic field induces currents in rotor components and produces additional heating.

For this reason, generator manufacturers normally specify permissible negative-sequence current limits.

A common form of generator negative-sequence thermal capability is:

[
I_2^2t=K
]

Where:

  • (I_2) = negative-sequence current in per unit.
  • (t) = time in seconds.
  • (K) = machine-specific thermal withstand constant.

The actual manufacturer may specify a continuous negative-sequence current limit and a short-time withstand curve.

7.1 Generator negative-sequence protection objectives

The protection scheme should:

  • Detect abnormal phase-current unbalance.
  • Protect rotor components against excessive heating.
  • Coordinate with generator differential protection.
  • Coordinate with backup overcurrent protection.
  • Provide an alarm for abnormal operating conditions.
  • Trip the generator when the permissible thermal limit is exceeded.

7.2 Generator applications

Negative-sequence protection is particularly important for:

  • Large synchronous generators.
  • Thermal power stations.
  • Hydroelectric generators.
  • Industrial captive power plants.
  • Generator units connected to unbalanced networks.

8. Negative-Sequence Protection in Induction Motors

Three-phase induction motors are also affected by negative-sequence currents.

The negative-sequence magnetic field rotates opposite to the normal rotating field.

This creates high relative rotor frequency and additional rotor losses.

Possible consequences include:

  • Rotor overheating.
  • Stator winding heating.
  • Torque pulsations.
  • Increased vibration.
  • Reduced motor efficiency.
  • Premature insulation deterioration.

Negative-sequence protection may be used together with motor thermal overload protection.

The actual settings should consider motor manufacturer data, operating duty, starting conditions, and the relay’s thermal model.

9. Negative-Sequence Current and Voltage Unbalance

Current unbalance and voltage unbalance are related but different quantities.

A simplified voltage-unbalance calculation is:

[
%V_{\text{unbalance}}=
\frac{\text{Maximum deviation from average voltage}}
{\text{Average voltage}}\times100
]

For example, assume the three measured phase-to-phase voltages are:

  • 400 V.
  • 396 V.
  • 404 V.

Average voltage:

[
V_{\text{avg}}=\frac{400+396+404}{3}
]

[
V_{\text{avg}}=400\text{ V}
]

Maximum deviation:

[
\Delta V=4\text{ V}
]

Therefore:

[
%V_{\text{unbalance}}=\frac{4}{400}\times100
]

[
%V_{\text{unbalance}}=1%
]

This is a simplified maximum-deviation method. It is not identical to the negative-sequence voltage ratio:

[
\frac{V_2}{V_1}\times100
]

The two methods should not be treated as interchangeable.

10. Negative-Sequence Thermal Protection – I₂²t

For generator applications, negative-sequence thermal protection commonly uses an I₂²t characteristic.

The underlying concept is that heating is related to the square of current and the duration of the condition.

A simplified operating-time relationship is:

[
t=\frac{K}{I_2^2}
]

Where:

  • (t) = allowable operating time.
  • (K) = negative-sequence thermal constant.
  • (I_2) = negative-sequence current in per unit.

This simplified equation illustrates the principle. Actual relay characteristics may include pickup thresholds, continuous limits, thermal memory, reset behavior, and additional manufacturer-specific features.

Example

Assume a generator has an illustrative negative-sequence thermal constant:

[
K=10
]

If:

[
I_2=0.5pu
]

Then:

[
t=\frac{10}{0.5^2}
]

[
t=40\text{ seconds}
]

If negative-sequence current increases to:

[
I_2=1.0pu
]

Then:

[
t=\frac{10}{1.0^2}=10\text{ seconds}
]

The allowable time decreases as negative-sequence current increases.

Important: The value of K in this example is illustrative only. Use the generator manufacturer’s specified capability and the relay manufacturer’s documented implementation when determining actual settings.

11. Continuous Negative-Sequence Current Limit

Generator manufacturers may specify a maximum continuous negative-sequence current.

This limit is important because a generator may experience a small but persistent phase-current unbalance.

The continuous limit must be considered separately from the short-time I₂²t capability.

A complete setting study should evaluate:

  • Continuous negative-sequence current.
  • Short-time thermal withstand.
  • Generator cooling arrangement.
  • Rotor design.
  • Operating duty.
  • Protection reset characteristics.
  • Alarm and trip philosophy.

12. Practical Generator Negative-Sequence Calculation

Consider a generator with:

  • Rated current = 5,000 A.
  • Measured negative-sequence current = 250 A.

The negative-sequence current in per unit is:

[
I_{2,pu}=\frac{250}{5000}
]

[
I_{2,pu}=0.05pu
]

Therefore, the negative-sequence current is 5% of rated current.

Whether this value is acceptable depends on the generator manufacturer’s continuous negative-sequence capability and the configured protection settings.

13. CT Configuration for ANSI 46 Protection

Correct current measurement is essential for negative-sequence protection.

The relay calculates negative-sequence current using the phase-current inputs.

The protection engineer must verify:

  • CT primary ratio.
  • CT secondary rating.
  • CT polarity.
  • Phase identification.
  • Current input assignment.
  • Phase sequence.
  • CT wiring integrity.
  • Current scaling in the relay.

13.1 CT polarity errors

Incorrect CT polarity can produce incorrect phase relationships and affect symmetrical-component calculations.

A relay may display unexpected negative-sequence current even when the primary system is balanced.

13.2 Phase interchange

If two phase-current inputs are interchanged, the relay may calculate incorrect positive- and negative-sequence components.

Therefore, phase identification must be verified during commissioning.

13.3 CT saturation

During high-current faults, CT saturation may distort the measured phase currents.

This can affect negative-sequence calculations and protection element behavior.

The protection engineer should evaluate CT performance and the relay’s response during high-current faults.

14. Negative-Sequence Protection and Other Protection Functions

ANSI 46 operates alongside other protection functions.

Protection functionANSI numberMain purpose
Generator differential87GInternal generator phase faults
Phase overcurrent50/51Excessive phase current
Earth fault50N/51N or 64Ground faults
Negative sequence46Current unbalance
Thermal overload49Thermal protection
Reverse power32Reverse active power
Loss of excitation40Abnormal excitation
Underfrequency81ULow system frequency
Overfrequency81OHigh system frequency

Negative-sequence protection does not replace differential or earth-fault protection.

It provides a complementary protection function.

15. GE Multilin Relay Applications

GE Multilin generator and motor protection relays may provide negative-sequence measurement and protection functions.

Potential applications include:

  • G60 generator protection.
  • G30 generator protection.
  • 889 generator protection.
  • 369 motor protection.
  • 469 motor protection.
  • Other supported GE Multilin generator and motor protection devices.

The exact function implementation depends on the relay model and firmware.

Before engineering ANSI 46, verify:

  • Negative-sequence measurement availability.
  • Current input configuration.
  • Pickup setting range.
  • Thermal characteristic.
  • I₂²t capability.
  • Continuous negative-sequence limit.
  • Alarm and trip logic.
  • Thermal memory and reset behavior, where applicable.

Do not assume that all GE Multilin relays use the same ANSI 46 characteristic.

16. General GE Multilin Configuration Workflow

The following workflow is generic. Actual menu names and setting paths depend on the relay model and EnerVista software version.

Step 1 – Identify the relay

Record:

  • Exact relay model.
  • Product order code.
  • Firmware version.
  • Hardware configuration.
  • Current input ratings.
  • Available protection functions.

Step 2 – Verify CT configuration

Check:

  • CT primary ratio.
  • CT secondary rating.
  • Phase assignment.
  • Polarity.
  • Current scaling.
  • Phase sequence.

Step 3 – Verify current measurements

Apply or observe balanced three-phase current conditions.

Check that:

  • Phase-current magnitudes are reasonable.
  • Phase angles are correct.
  • Positive-sequence current is consistent with the load.
  • Negative-sequence current is close to the expected value.

Step 4 – Review machine capability

For a generator, obtain:

  • Rated current.
  • Continuous negative-sequence capability.
  • I₂²t constant or withstand curve.
  • Manufacturer’s operating limits.

For a motor, obtain:

  • Rated current.
  • Thermal withstand information.
  • Permissible phase unbalance.
  • Starting and operating duty.

Step 5 – Configure ANSI 46

Where supported, configure:

  • Negative-sequence pickup.
  • Operating characteristic.
  • Thermal constant or curve parameters.
  • Continuous alarm or limit.
  • Time delay.
  • Reset behavior.
  • Alarm and trip logic.

Step 6 – Verify output logic

Check:

  • Alarm output.
  • Generator trip.
  • Motor trip.
  • Lockout logic.
  • Event recording.
  • External control signals.

Step 7 – Save and document

Save the final settings and record the relay firmware and configuration revision.

17. Testing and Commissioning of Negative-Sequence Protection

Negative-sequence protection should be tested using a suitable three-phase relay test set capable of controlling current magnitudes and phase angles independently.

Testing should verify current measurement, negative-sequence calculation, pickup, operating time, reset, and output logic.

17.1 Pre-test checks

Before testing:

  • Confirm the approved protection settings.
  • Verify relay model and firmware.
  • Check CT ratio and current input configuration.
  • Confirm phase assignment.
  • Review the manufacturer’s thermal capability.
  • Verify output and trip logic.

17.2 Balanced current test

  1. Inject three equal phase currents.
  2. Set the phase angles to 120 degrees apart.
  3. Confirm the relay measures the expected positive-sequence current.
  4. Confirm negative-sequence current is close to zero.
  5. Record the measured values.

Small residual measurement values may occur due to test-set accuracy, relay measurement tolerances, or wiring conditions.

17.3 Negative-sequence pickup test

  1. Apply three-phase current with controlled unbalance.
  2. Increase negative-sequence current gradually.
  3. Monitor the relay’s negative-sequence measurement.
  4. Record the pickup threshold.
  5. Compare the result with the approved setting.

17.4 Operating-time test

For a definite-time element:

  1. Apply a negative-sequence current above pickup.
  2. Start the timer.
  3. Record the operating time.
  4. Compare with the configured delay.

For an I₂²t characteristic:

  1. Select a test current above the applicable threshold.
  2. Calculate the expected operating time using the documented characteristic.
  3. Inject the required unbalanced current.
  4. Measure the operating time.
  5. Repeat at additional current levels.
  6. Compare results with the manufacturer’s tolerance.

17.5 Thermal memory test

Where the relay provides thermal memory:

  1. Apply an unbalanced current that causes thermal accumulation.
  2. Remove the test current before trip.
  3. Observe the thermal state or reset behavior.
  4. Reapply current according to the test plan.
  5. Verify the expected thermal accumulation and recovery.

The test must follow the manufacturer’s documented thermal model.

17.6 Trip logic test

Verify the complete protection chain:

  • ANSI 46 element operation.
  • Protection logic.
  • Output contact.
  • Interposing relay.
  • Lockout relay, where applicable.
  • Circuit breaker trip command.
  • Breaker auxiliary contact feedback.

18. Common Negative-Sequence Protection Problems

Problem 1 – Negative-sequence current is high during balanced operation

Possible causes:

  • Incorrect CT polarity.
  • Incorrect phase assignment.
  • Wrong phase sequence.
  • CT ratio mismatch.
  • Unequal current measurement scaling.
  • Wiring defects.

Recommended checks:

  • Verify phase-current measurements.
  • Check CT polarity.
  • Confirm phase identification.
  • Compare relay measurements with a calibrated instrument.
  • Inspect current wiring.

Problem 2 – ANSI 46 does not operate

Possible causes:

  • Function disabled.
  • Pickup setting too high.
  • Incorrect current scaling.
  • Active blocking logic.
  • Incorrect characteristic configuration.
  • Output logic not assigned.

Recommended checks:

  • Review element enable status.
  • Verify negative-sequence measurement.
  • Check pickup settings.
  • Review logic and output mapping.

Problem 3 – Unwanted generator trip

Possible causes:

  • Incorrect I₂²t constant.
  • Inappropriate pickup setting.
  • CT measurement error.
  • Actual phase unbalance.
  • Incorrect thermal reset configuration.

Recommended checks:

  • Retrieve event and disturbance records.
  • Review the measured phase currents.
  • Recalculate negative-sequence current.
  • Verify generator manufacturer data.
  • Review the thermal characteristic.

Problem 4 – Protection operates too slowly

Possible causes:

  • Incorrect thermal constant.
  • Incorrect current scaling.
  • Wrong reference current.
  • Incorrect characteristic selection.
  • Different relay implementation from the assumed calculation.

Recommended checks:

  • Verify the exact relay characteristic.
  • Confirm current reference.
  • Compare with manufacturer documentation.
  • Test at multiple current levels.

Problem 5 – Negative-sequence current appears during a phase fault

This may be a normal protection response.

Unbalanced faults can produce significant negative-sequence current.

The engineer should evaluate the operation of ANSI 46 together with differential, overcurrent, and earth-fault protection.

19. Commissioning Checklist

No.Inspection or testResult
1Verify relay model and firmware☐
2Confirm ANSI 46 availability☐
3Check CT primary and secondary ratios☐
4Verify CT polarity☐
5Confirm phase identification☐
6Verify current measurements☐
7Test balanced three-phase current☐
8Verify negative-sequence measurement☐
9Test negative-sequence pickup☐
10Verify operating-time characteristic☐
11Test I₂²t characteristic if applicable☐
12Verify thermal memory if applicable☐
13Check alarm and trip logic☐
14Test trip circuit☐
15Compare settings with machine capability☐
16Review event records☐
17Save final settings☐
18Complete commissioning report☐

20. Best Engineering Practices

For reliable negative-sequence protection:

  1. Understand symmetrical components and phase sequence.
  2. Verify CT polarity and phase identification.
  3. Confirm the relay’s current scaling.
  4. Obtain the generator or motor manufacturer’s negative-sequence capability.
  5. Coordinate the continuous limit and short-time thermal characteristic.
  6. Consider CT saturation during high-current faults.
  7. Coordinate ANSI 46 with differential, overcurrent, and thermal protection.
  8. Verify the relay’s thermal memory and reset behavior.
  9. Test balanced and unbalanced current conditions.
  10. Record all test results and settings revisions.

Negative-sequence protection is particularly important for generators because relatively modest unbalanced currents can produce significant rotor heating over time.

21. Training on GE Multilin Protection Relays by Elec-Engg

Practical negative-sequence protection engineering requires a clear understanding of symmetrical components, CT circuits, generator and motor thermal limits, protection coordination, relay configuration, and secondary injection testing.

Elec-Engg provides practical technical training by Dr Saeed Roostaee (Electrical Engineering) for engineers involved in power-system protection, generator and motor protection, commissioning, operation, and maintenance.

Relevant training subjects include:

  • GE Multilin generator protection.
  • GE Multilin motor protection.
  • G60, G30, 889, 369, and 469 applications.
  • Negative-sequence protection (ANSI 46).
  • Symmetrical component calculations.
  • Generator I₂²t thermal protection.
  • Motor current unbalance protection.
  • CT configuration and verification.
  • EnerVista settings and configuration.
  • Secondary injection testing.
  • Protection coordination and troubleshooting.

Training delivery options include:

  • Pre-recorded video courses.
  • Structured self-paced training.
  • Live online training.
  • Face-to-face technical training.
  • Customized in-house training for companies and utilities.

Explore available courses at Elec-Engg or contact us to discuss customized technical training.

22. Frequently Asked Questions

What is ANSI 46 protection?

ANSI 46 is negative-sequence or phase-balance protection. It detects abnormal current unbalance in a three-phase system.

Why is negative-sequence current dangerous for generators?

Negative-sequence current produces a magnetic field rotating opposite to the normal rotor field. This induces currents in rotor components and causes additional heating.

What is the I₂²t characteristic?

It is a thermal protection characteristic that relates negative-sequence current magnitude and operating time to the machine’s thermal withstand capability.

Is negative-sequence protection the same as earth-fault protection?

No. Negative-sequence protection detects phase unbalance, while earth-fault protection detects current associated with ground faults.

Can a phase-to-phase fault produce negative-sequence current?

Yes. Unbalanced phase faults generally produce negative-sequence current.

Can negative-sequence protection be used for induction motors?

Yes. Selected motor protection relays provide negative-sequence or current-unbalance protection to help protect motors against excessive heating.

Does every GE Multilin relay support ANSI 46?

No. Availability and characteristics depend on the exact relay model, hardware configuration, and firmware.

How is negative-sequence protection tested?

A three-phase relay test set injects controlled unbalanced currents to verify negative-sequence measurement, pickup, timing, thermal behavior, and trip logic.

Conclusion

Negative-sequence protection is essential for identifying abnormal three-phase current conditions and protecting generators and motors against excessive heating.

ANSI 46 calculates the negative-sequence component of the measured phase currents and applies an appropriate protection characteristic. Generator applications frequently use I₂²t thermal protection coordinated with the machine manufacturer’s capability.

Reliable implementation requires correct CT configuration, accurate current measurement, suitable settings, coordination with other protection functions, and comprehensive commissioning tests.

For GE Multilin applications, always confirm the exact ANSI 46 implementation and settings requirements for the selected relay model and firmware.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top