- 1. Introduction
- 2. What Is Overexcitation?
- 3. Understanding the V/Hz Relationship
- 4. What Causes Overexcitation?
- 5. ANSI 24 Overexcitation Protection
- 6. Overexcitation Protection in Power Transformers
- 7. Overexcitation Protection in Generators
- 8. Difference Between Overexcitation and Overvoltage Protection
- 9. Difference Between Overexcitation and Underfrequency Protection
- 10. V/Hz Operating Characteristics
- 11. Equipment V/Hz Withstand Curve
- 12. Practical V/Hz Calculation Examples
- 13. Voltage Transformer Configuration for ANSI 24
- 14. GE Multilin Relays and ANSI 24 Applications
- 15. General GE Multilin Configuration Workflow
- 16. Testing and Commissioning of ANSI 24 Protection
- 17. Common ANSI 24 Protection Problems
- 18. Commissioning Checklist
- 19. Best Engineering Practices
- 20. Training on GE Multilin Protection Relays by Elec-Engg
- 21. Frequently Asked Questions
- Conclusion
1. Introduction
Overexcitation protection is an important function in electrical power systems, particularly for power transformers, generator step-up transformers, and synchronous generators.
Overexcitation occurs when the magnetic flux in an electrical machine or transformer exceeds its acceptable design limit. This condition can cause core saturation, increased magnetizing current, localized heating, insulation stress, and possible equipment damage.
ANSI device number 24 is commonly associated with volts-per-hertz (V/Hz) protection. It monitors the relationship between voltage and frequency to identify abnormal magnetic flux conditions.
GE Multilin protection relays provide overexcitation protection in selected transformer and generator protection applications. The availability and implementation of ANSI 24 depend on the relay model, hardware configuration, and firmware.
This article explains the principles of overexcitation, the V/Hz relationship, transformer and generator applications, setting calculations, relay configuration, testing, and troubleshooting.
2. What Is Overexcitation?
The magnetic flux in a transformer or generator is approximately proportional to the ratio of applied voltage to frequency, assuming the relevant winding and operating conditions remain unchanged.
The relationship can be expressed as:
[
\Phi \propto \frac{V}{f}
]
Where:
- (\Phi) = magnetic flux.
- (V) = applied voltage.
- (f) = electrical frequency.
When voltage increases or frequency decreases, the V/Hz ratio increases.
If the ratio exceeds the equipment’s permissible limit, the magnetic core may enter saturation.
This can result in:
- Increased magnetizing current.
- Increased core losses.
- Localized heating.
- Stray flux heating in structural components.
- Increased vibration and noise.
- Insulation deterioration.
- Potential equipment damage.
Overexcitation protection detects this condition and initiates an alarm or trip according to the approved protection philosophy.
3. Understanding the V/Hz Relationship
The maximum magnetic flux in a transformer core is related to the applied voltage and frequency.
For a sinusoidal voltage:
[
V=4.44fN\Phi_{\max}
]
Rearranging:
[
\Phi_{\max}=\frac{V}{4.44fN}
]
Where:
- (V) = RMS induced voltage.
- (f) = frequency.
- (N) = number of winding turns.
- (\Phi_{\max}) = maximum magnetic flux.
For a given winding, the number of turns is constant.
Therefore:
[
\Phi_{\max}\propto\frac{V}{f}
]
This is the fundamental principle behind V/Hz protection.
4. What Causes Overexcitation?
Overexcitation can occur in transformers and generators due to several operating conditions.
Common causes include:
- Excessive system voltage.
- Reduced system frequency.
- Generator load rejection.
- Incorrect generator voltage regulation.
- Transformer energization under abnormal conditions.
- Incorrect tap-changer operation.
- Generator operation at reduced frequency.
- Incorrect excitation control.
- System disturbances and abnormal operating conditions.
The protection engineer should investigate both voltage and frequency because either variable can increase the V/Hz ratio.
5. ANSI 24 Overexcitation Protection
ANSI 24 protection monitors the V/Hz ratio and compares it with the configured operating characteristics.
A simplified per-unit relationship is:
[
(V/f){pu}=\frac{V{pu}}{f_{pu}}
]
Where:
[
V_{pu}=\frac{V_{\text{measured}}}{V_{\text{nominal}}}
]
and:
[
f_{pu}=\frac{f_{\text{measured}}}{f_{\text{nominal}}}
]
The V/Hz per-unit value is therefore:
[
(V/f){pu}=
\frac{V{\text{measured}}/V_{\text{nominal}}}
{f_{\text{measured}}/f_{\text{nominal}}}
]
When the V/Hz value exceeds the configured threshold, the protection element may start its operating timer.
Example
Assume:
- Nominal voltage = 100%.
- Nominal frequency = 50 Hz.
- Actual voltage = 110%.
- Actual frequency = 48 Hz.
Then:
[
V_{pu}=1.10
]
[
f_{pu}=\frac{48}{50}=0.96
]
Therefore:
[
(V/f)_{pu}=\frac{1.10}{0.96}
]
[
(V/f)_{pu}=1.146
]
The V/Hz ratio is approximately 1.146 pu, or 114.6% of nominal.
Whether this condition requires an alarm or trip depends on the equipment withstand curve and approved protection settings.
6. Overexcitation Protection in Power Transformers
Power transformers are particularly sensitive to excessive magnetic flux.
When the core becomes saturated, magnetizing current can increase significantly. The resulting losses and stray flux may produce abnormal heating.
Potential consequences include:
- Core overheating.
- Winding and structural-part heating.
- Increased tank and clamp losses.
- Insulation deterioration.
- Increased audible noise.
- Long-term reduction in transformer life.
6.1 Transformer operating conditions
Overexcitation may occur when:
- A transformer remains energized during low-frequency operation.
- The system voltage rises above the rated value.
- A generator connected to a step-up transformer experiences abnormal voltage and frequency.
- Voltage regulation is incorrectly coordinated.
- A system disturbance produces an abnormal V/Hz condition.
6.2 Generator step-up transformer
Generator step-up transformers are particularly important applications.
During generator operation, the generator terminal voltage and system frequency influence the magnetic flux in the transformer.
If generator voltage remains high while frequency decreases, the transformer V/Hz ratio can exceed its permissible limit.
The transformer protection scheme should therefore consider the operating characteristics of both the generator and its associated transformer.
7. Overexcitation Protection in Generators
Synchronous generators also require protection against excessive magnetic flux.
Overexcitation may result from:
- Excessive field excitation.
- Voltage regulator malfunction.
- Operation at reduced frequency.
- Incorrect excitation control.
- Abnormal voltage conditions.
- Load rejection and subsequent voltage changes.
The generator magnetic circuit may become saturated, increasing excitation current and heating.
ANSI 24 protection monitors the voltage-to-frequency relationship and provides an alarm or trip when the operating condition exceeds permissible limits.
The generator manufacturer normally provides the relevant V/Hz withstand information.
8. Difference Between Overexcitation and Overvoltage Protection
Overexcitation and overvoltage protection are related but not identical.
| Feature | Overvoltage (ANSI 59) | Overexcitation (ANSI 24) |
|---|---|---|
| Main measurement | Voltage | Voltage-to-frequency ratio |
| Main concern | Excessive voltage | Excessive magnetic flux |
| Frequency considered | Not inherently | Yes |
| Transformer core saturation | Not directly assessed | Directly addressed through V/Hz |
| Generator application | Yes | Yes |
| Transformer application | Yes | Yes |
Consider two operating conditions:
Condition A – High voltage at nominal frequency
Voltage = 1.10 pu.
Frequency = 1.00 pu.
[
V/f=1.10pu
]
Condition B – Nominal voltage at reduced frequency
Voltage = 1.00 pu.
Frequency = 0.90 pu.
[
V/f=\frac{1.00}{0.90}=1.111pu
]
Both conditions produce an elevated V/Hz ratio, although the voltage behavior is different.
This demonstrates why overvoltage protection alone cannot fully replace V/Hz protection.
9. Difference Between Overexcitation and Underfrequency Protection
Underfrequency protection (ANSI 81U) monitors frequency.
Overexcitation protection (ANSI 24) monitors the V/Hz ratio.
For example:
- A frequency decrease with constant voltage increases V/Hz.
- A voltage increase with constant frequency increases V/Hz.
- A frequency decrease accompanied by a proportional voltage decrease may leave V/Hz approximately unchanged.
Therefore, ANSI 81U and ANSI 24 perform different protection functions.
Both may be required in a generator or transformer protection scheme.
10. V/Hz Operating Characteristics
Overexcitation protection may use definite-time or inverse-time characteristics, depending on the relay.
10.1 Definite-time protection
With definite-time protection, the element operates after the V/Hz ratio exceeds a configured threshold for a specified time.
For example, an illustrative setting could be:
| Parameter | Example |
|---|---|
| V/Hz pickup | 1.10 pu |
| Operating delay | 10 s |
| Action | Alarm |
The actual operating time must follow the equipment withstand curve and protection design.
10.2 Inverse-time protection
An inverse-time characteristic provides faster operation at higher overexcitation levels.
The operating time decreases as the V/Hz ratio increases.
A simplified conceptual relationship is:
[
t=f\left(\frac{V}{f}\right)
]
The exact curve equation and available curve selections depend on the relay implementation.
The engineer must use the manufacturer’s documented characteristic rather than assuming a generic inverse-time equation.
10.3 Multiple-stage protection
A protection scheme may use multiple stages.
For example:
| Stage | Illustrative V/Hz ratio | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Stage 1 | 1.05 pu | Alarm |
| Stage 2 | 1.10 pu | Alarm or delayed trip |
| Stage 3 | 1.15 pu | Trip |
| Stage 4 | 1.20 pu | High-set trip |
These values are examples only. They must not be used as universal settings.
11. Equipment V/Hz Withstand Curve
The equipment manufacturer provides permissible operating limits for voltage and frequency conditions.
A V/Hz withstand curve typically indicates how long equipment can withstand different levels of overexcitation.
The protection characteristic should be coordinated with this curve.
The protection engineer should consider:
- Transformer core design.
- Generator magnetic circuit design.
- Cooling conditions.
- Equipment temperature.
- Manufacturer’s continuous V/Hz limit.
- Short-duration V/Hz withstand capability.
- Operating conditions during system disturbances.
The protection curve should provide sufficient margin to avoid unnecessary trips while ensuring that equipment is disconnected before its permissible withstand limit is exceeded.
12. Practical V/Hz Calculation Examples
Example 1 – Transformer overexcitation at reduced frequency
Consider a transformer operating with:
- Nominal voltage = 132 kV.
- Nominal frequency = 50 Hz.
- Actual voltage = 132 kV.
- Actual frequency = 45 Hz.
Voltage per unit:
[
V_{pu}=\frac{132}{132}=1.0
]
Frequency per unit:
[
f_{pu}=\frac{45}{50}=0.90
]
V/Hz ratio:
[
(V/f)_{pu}=\frac{1.0}{0.90}
]
[
(V/f)_{pu}=1.111
]
The transformer is operating at approximately 111.1% of nominal V/Hz.
Example 2 – Overexcitation due to high voltage
Assume:
- Nominal voltage = 33 kV.
- Actual voltage = 36 kV.
- Nominal frequency = 50 Hz.
- Actual frequency = 50 Hz.
[
V_{pu}=\frac{36}{33}=1.091
]
[
f_{pu}=1.0
]
Therefore:
[
(V/f)_{pu}=1.091
]
The V/Hz ratio is approximately 1.091 pu.
Example 3 – Combined high voltage and reduced frequency
Assume:
- Nominal voltage = 100%.
- Actual voltage = 108%.
- Nominal frequency = 50 Hz.
- Actual frequency = 47 Hz.
[
V_{pu}=1.08
]
[
f_{pu}=\frac{47}{50}=0.94
]
[
(V/f)_{pu}=\frac{1.08}{0.94}
]
[
(V/f)_{pu}=1.149
]
The V/Hz ratio is approximately 1.149 pu.
These calculations illustrate the principle. Actual relay measurement and settings may use configured voltage references, frequency inputs, and manufacturer-specific scaling.
13. Voltage Transformer Configuration for ANSI 24
Correct voltage measurement is essential for reliable V/Hz protection.
The protection engineer should verify:
- VT primary voltage.
- VT secondary voltage.
- VT ratio.
- Phase-to-phase or phase-to-neutral measurement.
- Phase assignment.
- Polarity.
- Nominal frequency.
- Voltage input configuration.
Incorrect voltage scaling can produce an incorrect V/Hz calculation.
For example, if the relay is configured for the wrong VT ratio, the measured voltage per unit may be incorrect even when the physical VT wiring is correct.
The engineer must verify the complete measurement chain rather than checking only the relay setting.
14. GE Multilin Relays and ANSI 24 Applications
GE Multilin offers transformer and generator protection relays that may include V/Hz overexcitation functions.
Potential application areas include:
- T60 transformer protection.
- 845 transformer protection.
- G60 generator protection.
- G30 generator protection.
- 889 generator protection.
- Other supported UR family applications.
The exact function availability, setting range, operating curves, voltage references, and logic options must be confirmed from the technical documentation for the selected relay and firmware.
Do not assume that every GE Multilin relay supports ANSI 24 or provides identical V/Hz characteristics.
15. General GE Multilin Configuration Workflow
The following procedure is a generic engineering workflow. Actual setting names and menu paths vary by relay model and EnerVista software version.
Step 1 – Identify the relay
Record:
- Relay model.
- Product order code.
- Firmware version.
- Hardware configuration.
- Available protection functions.
Step 2 – Verify voltage inputs
Confirm:
- VT primary voltage.
- VT secondary voltage.
- VT ratio.
- Phase assignment.
- Voltage measurement reference.
- Wiring and polarity.
Step 3 – Confirm nominal frequency
Select the correct nominal frequency:
- 50 Hz.
- 60 Hz.
Step 4 – Verify V/Hz measurement
Check the relay’s displayed voltage, frequency, and V/Hz values where available.
Compare them with independent measurements.
Step 5 – Configure protection characteristics
Where supported, configure:
- V/Hz pickup.
- Operating delay.
- Definite-time or inverse-time characteristic.
- Number of stages.
- Reset behavior.
- Alarm and trip logic.
Step 6 – Configure output logic
Verify the intended response:
- Alarm.
- Generator trip.
- Transformer trip.
- Lockout relay operation.
- Breaker trip.
- Event recording.
Step 7 – Review coordination
Compare the relay characteristic with the manufacturer’s V/Hz withstand curve.
Confirm coordination with:
- Generator excitation control.
- Turbine control.
- Overvoltage protection.
- Underfrequency protection.
- Transformer differential protection.
- Generator differential protection.
Step 8 – Save and document
Save the final settings and maintain a controlled settings revision.
16. Testing and Commissioning of ANSI 24 Protection
Overexcitation protection should be tested using a suitable relay test set capable of controlling voltage magnitude and frequency.
Testing must verify the relay’s V/Hz measurement, pickup, timing, reset, and output logic.
16.1 Pre-test checks
Before testing:
- Confirm the approved V/Hz settings.
- Verify relay model and firmware.
- Check VT ratio.
- Confirm nominal voltage and frequency.
- Review output logic.
- Verify trip circuit arrangements.
- Confirm test isolation and safety procedures.
16.2 V/Hz measurement test
- Apply nominal voltage at nominal frequency.
- Read the relay’s voltage and frequency measurements.
- Verify the displayed V/Hz value.
- Increase voltage in controlled steps or decrease frequency.
- Compare the calculated ratio with the relay measurement.
- Record deviations.
16.3 Pickup test by voltage variation
- Apply nominal frequency.
- Increase voltage gradually.
- Monitor the V/Hz element.
- Record the pickup value.
- Compare the measured value with the approved setting.
16.4 Pickup test by frequency variation
- Apply a suitable voltage level.
- Reduce frequency gradually.
- Monitor the V/Hz element.
- Record the pickup value.
- Confirm the element response.
16.5 Operating-time test
- Apply a V/Hz ratio above the pickup threshold.
- Start the timing measurement.
- Record the operating time.
- Compare the result with the configured characteristic.
- Repeat at additional test points for inverse-time elements.
16.6 Reset test
Restore voltage and frequency to normal operating conditions.
Verify:
- Element reset.
- Timer reset behavior.
- Alarm reset.
- Trip logic reset.
- Latching and lockout behavior, where applicable.
16.7 Trip circuit test
Where ANSI 24 is connected to a trip output, verify the complete trip chain:
- Protection element operation.
- Logic equation.
- Output contact.
- Interposing relay.
- Lockout relay.
- Circuit breaker trip coil.
- Breaker auxiliary contact feedback.
The complete scheme should be tested according to the approved commissioning procedure.
17. Common ANSI 24 Protection Problems
Problem 1 – V/Hz measurement is incorrect
Possible causes:
- Incorrect VT ratio.
- Incorrect nominal voltage.
- Incorrect nominal frequency.
- Wrong voltage reference.
- Incorrect phase assignment.
Recommended checks:
- Verify VT data.
- Compare relay voltage measurements with a calibrated instrument.
- Confirm frequency measurement.
- Recalculate the expected V/Hz value.
Problem 2 – Overexcitation element does not operate
Possible causes:
- Function disabled.
- Pickup setting too high.
- Incorrect voltage measurement.
- Incorrect frequency reference.
- Blocking logic active.
- Incorrect output mapping.
Recommended checks:
- Review function enable status.
- Check the V/Hz measurement.
- Review element status.
- Verify timer operation.
- Check the output matrix.
Problem 3 – Unwanted overexcitation trip
Possible causes:
- Incorrect V/Hz setting.
- Inappropriate operating curve.
- Incorrect VT scaling.
- Incorrect nominal frequency.
- Poor coordination with equipment withstand limits.
Recommended checks:
- Retrieve event records.
- Review oscillography.
- Recalculate V/Hz.
- Compare actual operating conditions with the approved study.
- Verify the relay characteristic.
Problem 4 – Incorrect operating time
Possible causes:
- Wrong curve selection.
- Incorrect pickup setting.
- Timer configuration error.
- Test-set frequency or voltage inaccuracies.
- Different operating characteristics between firmware versions.
Recommended checks:
- Confirm the selected curve.
- Verify the test waveform.
- Compare against the manufacturer’s documented characteristic.
- Repeat tests at multiple operating points.
Problem 5 – Transformer operates at excessive V/Hz without tripping
Possible causes:
- Function not enabled.
- Incorrect voltage reference.
- Incorrect frequency measurement.
- Protection output not assigned.
- Alarm-only configuration.
- Active blocking condition.
Recommended checks:
- Verify the measured V/Hz ratio.
- Review element status.
- Check protection logic.
- Confirm output configuration.
- Verify the approved trip philosophy.
18. Commissioning Checklist
| No. | Inspection or test | Result |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Confirm relay model and firmware | ☐ |
| 2 | Verify ANSI 24 function availability | ☐ |
| 3 | Confirm VT primary and secondary ratings | ☐ |
| 4 | Verify voltage measurement reference | ☐ |
| 5 | Confirm nominal frequency | ☐ |
| 6 | Verify voltage measurement accuracy | ☐ |
| 7 | Verify frequency measurement accuracy | ☐ |
| 8 | Check V/Hz measurement | ☐ |
| 9 | Test V/Hz pickup | ☐ |
| 10 | Test operating time | ☐ |
| 11 | Test inverse-time characteristic if applicable | ☐ |
| 12 | Verify reset behavior | ☐ |
| 13 | Check alarm and trip logic | ☐ |
| 14 | Verify lockout and breaker trip circuits | ☐ |
| 15 | Compare settings with equipment withstand curve | ☐ |
| 16 | Review event and disturbance records | ☐ |
| 17 | Save final settings | ☐ |
| 18 | Complete commissioning report | ☐ |
19. Best Engineering Practices
For reliable overexcitation protection:
- Understand the relationship between voltage, frequency, and magnetic flux.
- Verify VT ratio and voltage measurement configuration.
- Confirm nominal frequency and nominal voltage.
- Obtain the equipment manufacturer’s V/Hz withstand curve.
- Coordinate the protection characteristic with equipment withstand limits.
- Consider generator and transformer operating conditions.
- Coordinate ANSI 24 with ANSI 59 and ANSI 81.
- Verify the complete trip and alarm logic.
- Test the element at multiple V/Hz operating points.
- Maintain approved settings and commissioning records.
Overexcitation protection should be engineered as part of the complete transformer or generator protection scheme.
20. Training on GE Multilin Protection Relays by Elec-Engg
Practical overexcitation protection engineering requires more than understanding the V/Hz equation. Engineers must understand transformer and generator magnetic circuits, VT configuration, protection characteristics, coordination, relay settings, and commissioning procedures.
Elec-Engg provides practical technical training by Dr Saeed Roostaee (Electrical Engineering) for protection, commissioning, operation, and maintenance engineers.
Relevant training subjects include:
- GE Multilin transformer protection.
- GE Multilin generator protection.
- T60 and 845 transformer protection applications.
- G60, G30, and 889 generator protection applications.
- Overexcitation protection (ANSI 24).
- Overvoltage and undervoltage protection (ANSI 59 and 27).
- Frequency protection (ANSI 81).
- V/Hz calculations and protection coordination.
- EnerVista configuration and settings management.
- Secondary injection and functional testing.
- Troubleshooting and commissioning.
Training delivery options include:
- Pre-recorded video courses.
- Structured self-paced training.
- Live online training.
- Face-to-face technical training.
- Customized in-house training for companies and utilities.
Explore technical courses at Elec-Engg or contact us to discuss a customized training program.
21. Frequently Asked Questions
What is ANSI 24 protection?
ANSI 24 is overexcitation protection. It monitors the voltage-to-frequency ratio to detect excessive magnetic flux conditions.
What is V/Hz protection?
V/Hz protection compares the applied voltage and frequency to determine whether the magnetic flux may exceed the equipment’s permissible limit.
Why does low frequency cause overexcitation?
At constant voltage, reducing frequency increases the V/Hz ratio and therefore increases magnetic flux.
Can high voltage cause overexcitation?
Yes. At constant frequency, an increase in voltage increases the V/Hz ratio.
Is ANSI 24 the same as overvoltage protection?
No. Overvoltage protection monitors voltage, while ANSI 24 monitors the relationship between voltage and frequency.
Is ANSI 24 required for transformers?
The need for ANSI 24 depends on the transformer application, system operating conditions, manufacturer requirements, and protection philosophy.
Can a GE Multilin relay provide ANSI 24 protection?
Selected GE Multilin transformer and generator relays provide overexcitation functions. Availability and characteristics must be confirmed for the exact model and firmware.
How is ANSI 24 tested?
A suitable relay test set applies controlled voltage and frequency signals to verify V/Hz measurement, pickup, operating time, reset, and trip logic.
Conclusion
Overexcitation protection is essential for protecting transformers and generators against excessive magnetic flux.
ANSI 24 monitors the V/Hz relationship and detects abnormal conditions caused by high voltage, reduced frequency, or a combination of both.
Reliable protection depends on correct voltage measurement, accurate frequency measurement, appropriate operating characteristics, and coordination with the equipment manufacturer’s withstand curve.
For GE Multilin applications, engineers must verify the exact capabilities of the selected relay model and firmware, configure the protection according to the approved study, and perform comprehensive commissioning tests.
