The SEL-487B Bus Differential and Breaker Failure Relay from Schweitzer Engineering Laboratories (SEL) is designed to provide high-speed, low-impedance busbar differential protection, circuit-breaker failure protection and backup overcurrent protection.
Busbars are among the most important components in electrical substations. A fault on a busbar can affect several feeders, transformers, generators and transmission lines simultaneously. If the fault is not cleared quickly, it can cause extensive equipment damage, loss of supply and a wider disturbance in the power system.
The SEL-487B combines flexible bus differential protection with dynamic zone configuration, independent check zones, open-current-transformer detection, breaker-failure logic and substation automation capabilities.
This article explains the SEL-487B relay, its applications, protection functions, busbar differential principles, CT requirements, settings, communication options and practical testing procedures.
SEL-487B Bus Differential Relay: Complete Guide to Busbar Protection, Breaker Failure, Settings and Testing
- 1. What is the SEL-487B relay?
- 2. Applications of the SEL-487B
- 3. Main protection functions and ANSI codes
- 4. Busbar differential protection – ANSI 87B
- 5. Low-impedance differential protection
- 6. Dynamic bus-zone configuration
- 7. CT requirements and CT ratio mismatch
- 8. Open and shorted CT detection
- 9. Circuit-breaker failure protection – ANSI 50BF
- 10. Overcurrent protection
- 11. Voltage elements and differential supervision
- 12. Monitoring, metering and event recording
- 13. Communication and substation automation
- 14. SEL-487B-2: TiDL and Sampled Values
- 15. Configuration using SEL software
- 16. SEL-487B testing and commissioning
- 17. SEL-487B vs SEL-587Z vs SEL-787Z
- 18. Advantages of the SEL-487B
- 19. Frequently asked questions
- 20. Busbar protection training by Elec-Engg
- 21. Conclusion
1. What is the SEL-487B relay?
The SEL-487B is a numerical bus differential and breaker-failure protection relay. It is designed for low-impedance differential protection of busbars with different arrangements and numbers of terminals.
Its main functions include:
- Low-impedance bus differential protection (87B).
- Multiple differential bus zones.
- Independent check-zone protection.
- Dynamic bus-zone configuration.
- Open and shorted CT detection.
- Circuit-breaker failure protection (50BF).
- Instantaneous and time-overcurrent protection.
- Voltage elements for differential supervision.
- Programmable control and interlocking logic.
- Event recording, metering and substation automation.
The relay is suitable for new substations and retrofit projects where existing CTs and busbar arrangements must be accommodated.
According to SEL, one relay can protect up to seven three-phase bus terminals. Larger systems can use multiple relays: two relays for arrangements with up to ten terminals and three relays for systems with up to 21 terminals, subject to the manufacturer’s application guidance and the selected configuration. https://selinc.com/products/487B/
2. Applications of the SEL-487B
The SEL-487B can be applied to a range of busbar arrangements.
2.1 Single busbar
A single busbar arrangement is one of the simplest substation configurations. Multiple feeders and transformer bays connect to a common bus.
A bus fault requires the disconnection of all circuits connected to the affected bus section. The SEL-487B can provide differential protection by summing the current contributions from the connected terminals.
2.2 Single busbar with bus sectionalizer
In a sectionalized busbar arrangement, a bus-section circuit breaker divides the bus into two or more sections.
The relay must identify which terminals belong to each differential zone and respond correctly when the bus-section breaker changes position.
Dynamic zone configuration allows current inputs to be reassigned between bus zones according to the disconnect and breaker status logic.
2.3 Double busbar arrangement
Double busbar substations allow feeders to be connected to either of two busbars through disconnectors and associated switching equipment.
The protection system must follow the actual electrical connection of each bay. When a disconnector changes position, the corresponding current input must be assigned to the correct differential zone.
Incorrect disconnector-status information can lead to an incorrect zone selection. Therefore, auxiliary contact supervision and appropriate check-zone logic are essential.
2.4 Breaker-and-a-half arrangement
Breaker-and-a-half substations are commonly used in high-voltage and extra-high-voltage transmission networks.
Each diameter typically contains three circuit breakers connecting two circuits between two main busbars.
The SEL-487B can be applied to these arrangements by configuring the appropriate current inputs, bus zones, disconnect status logic and breaker-failure protection.
2.5 Complex busbar arrangements
The SEL-487B is designed for flexible busbar configurations and can be used in applications involving multiple bus sections, bus couplers, disconnectors and several differential zones.
The final design must be based on the substation single-line diagram, CT locations, breaker arrangement and switching philosophy.
3. Main protection functions and ANSI codes
| ANSI code | Function | Application |
|---|---|---|
| 87B | Bus differential protection | Detects internal faults within a bus differential zone |
| 50BF | Breaker failure protection | Initiates retrip and backup tripping when a breaker fails to clear a fault |
| 50P | Instantaneous phase overcurrent | Fast phase fault backup protection |
| 51P | Time-overcurrent protection | Time-delayed phase overcurrent backup |
| 50G / 51G | Ground overcurrent | Ground-fault backup, where configured |
| 46 | Current unbalance | Negative-sequence current protection, where configured |
| 27 | Undervoltage | Voltage supervision |
| 59 | Overvoltage | Voltage supervision |
| 47 | Voltage unbalance | Negative- and zero-sequence voltage supervision |
| SER | Sequential Events Recorder | Records changes in relay status and logic |
| DFR | Digital fault recording | Records current and voltage waveforms |
The exact enabled elements and available settings depend on the relay model, firmware and application configuration. The SEL-487B is primarily a bus differential and breaker-failure relay, not a general-purpose feeder protection relay.

4. Busbar differential protection – ANSI 87B
The main function of the SEL-487B is low-impedance bus differential protection.
The differential protection principle is based on Kirchhoff’s current law: the sum of currents entering a protected bus zone should equal the sum of currents leaving it, when the currents are represented using consistent reference directions.
For a simplified bus zone:
[
I_{\mathrm{diff}} =
\left|\sum_{k=1}^{n} I_k\right|
]
where (I_k) represents the current contribution from each terminal connected to the zone.
4.1 Normal operating condition
Under normal load conditions, the current entering the busbar is approximately equal to the current leaving it.
Therefore, the differential current should remain close to zero, allowing for CT errors and measurement tolerances.
4.2 External fault
Consider a short circuit on a feeder connected to the busbar.
The fault current may enter the bus through several other terminals and leave through the faulted feeder. For a fault outside the protected bus zone, the sum of the measured currents should remain balanced.
The differential relay must remain stable during this condition.
This is particularly important when one or more CTs saturate during a high-current external fault.
4.3 Internal busbar fault
For a fault inside the protected bus zone, current contributions from the connected terminals flow toward the fault.
The differential current becomes significant, and the relay identifies an internal fault and issues the required trip commands.
The protection system should disconnect all circuit breakers connected to the faulted zone while maintaining healthy bus sections in service where the arrangement permits.
5. Low-impedance differential protection
Unlike high-impedance busbar protection, low-impedance differential protection uses numerical processing of individual terminal currents.
The SEL-487B offers flexible low-impedance differential protection for different busbar arrangements and CT configurations.
Important features include:
- Multiple differential bus zones.
- Three independent check zones.
- Dynamic zone selection.
- External-fault security.
- Open- and shorted-CT detection.
- Accommodation of CT ratio mismatch up to 35:1.
SEL specifies that busbar differential protection operates in less than one power-system cycle. Actual protection performance depends on the system configuration and operating conditions.
5.1 Differential zones
The relay supports up to six three-phase differential zones in the supported multi-relay arrangements.
This allows the protection system to cover multiple bus sections and complex switching configurations.
For example, a double-busbar arrangement may require separate differential zones for Bus 1 and Bus 2, with additional logic to follow the switching status of each bay.
5.2 Check zones
Check zones provide an additional layer of security.
A check zone generally supervises the overall bus arrangement independently of the individual bus-zone selection logic.
The SEL-487B provides three independent check zones. These can help prevent unwanted operation caused by incorrect or failed disconnect auxiliary contacts and can provide additional verification of an internal bus fault.
Check-zone logic must be designed carefully. It should not be treated as a replacement for correct CT wiring, zone selection or switching-status supervision.
6. Dynamic bus-zone configuration
Dynamic zone configuration is one of the important features of the SEL-487B.
In a double-busbar substation, a feeder may be connected to Bus 1 or Bus 2. The differential protection must follow the actual connection.
The relay uses the status of circuit breakers and disconnectors to determine the assignment of each current input to the appropriate differential zone.
A simplified example:
- A feeder is initially connected to Bus 1.
- Its current input is assigned to the Bus 1 differential zone.
- The operator changes the disconnector arrangement.
- The relay receives the updated auxiliary contact status.
- The current input is reassigned to the appropriate bus zone.
- The check-zone protection provides additional supervision.
The engineer must verify the complete switching logic, including intermediate switching conditions, invalid status combinations, maintenance positions and auxiliary contact failures.
7. CT requirements and CT ratio mismatch
Current transformer selection and wiring are critical for busbar differential protection.
Traditional bus differential schemes may require dedicated CT cores and careful matching of CT ratios. The SEL-487B provides flexibility by supporting CT ratio mismatches up to 35:1, according to SEL’s product information.
This can allow existing CTs to be used for differential protection together with other functions such as metering or backup protection.
Important CT checks include:
- CT ratio and secondary rating.
- CT polarity.
- CT accuracy class.
- CT burden.
- CT secondary earthing.
- CT wiring resistance.
- CT location in relation to the circuit breaker and busbar.
- Shorting and test terminal arrangements.
The ability to accommodate a wide CT ratio mismatch does not eliminate the need for proper CT selection and engineering studies.
8. Open and shorted CT detection
An open or shorted CT secondary circuit can create an incorrect current measurement.
In a bus differential scheme, this may produce unwanted differential current and potentially cause an incorrect trip.
The SEL-487B includes patented open-CT detection algorithms designed to identify conditions that could compromise differential protection security.
Depending on the application and settings, detected CT problems can initiate alarms or block the affected differential protection.
Commissioning engineers should test the intended alarm and blocking behavior using the manufacturer’s recommended test procedures. Never open an energized CT secondary circuit.
9. Circuit-breaker failure protection – ANSI 50BF
Breaker-failure protection is another major function of the SEL-487B.
When a protection relay issues a trip command, the circuit breaker is expected to interrupt the fault current. If the breaker fails to open, the fault remains connected to the power system.
The breaker-failure scheme detects this condition and initiates backup tripping.
A typical breaker-failure sequence includes:
- A protection element detects a fault.
- A trip command is sent to the associated circuit breaker.
- Breaker-failure logic starts its timer.
- The relay checks whether current continues to flow and/or whether the breaker status indicates that it remains closed.
- If the breaker fails to clear the fault within the configured time, the breaker-failure element operates.
- The scheme issues retrip and backup trip commands as configured.
The SEL-487B includes integrated breaker-failure detection and logic, including retrip capability for each terminal.
9.1 Breaker-failure timer setting
The breaker-failure timer must account for:
- Circuit-breaker opening time.
- Protection relay operating time.
- Current interruption time.
- Auxiliary relay operating time.
- Safety margin.
- Coordination with upstream and adjacent breaker protection.
The timer should be calculated from actual equipment data and the approved protection coordination study.
10. Overcurrent protection
The SEL-487B provides integrated overcurrent protection for additional backup protection.
The relay supports multiple overcurrent curves for each current input, together with instantaneous and definite-time elements.
These elements can be used to provide backup protection for individual terminals and associated circuits.
The engineer should coordinate the overcurrent settings with feeder relays, transformer protection, upstream protection and the overall substation protection philosophy.
Overcurrent protection should not be confused with the main bus differential protection function.
11. Voltage elements and differential supervision
The SEL-487B provides three voltage elements, each with phase under- and overvoltage levels and negative- and zero-sequence overvoltage elements.
These voltage elements can be used to supervise current differential tripping and support the overall protection scheme.
Before enabling voltage-dependent logic, verify:
- VT ratio.
- VT connection.
- Phase sequence.
- Voltage polarity.
- Nominal voltage.
- Voltage input availability.
- The intended supervision philosophy.
Incorrect VT configuration can compromise the intended operation of voltage supervision.
12. Monitoring, metering and event recording
The SEL-487B provides monitoring and recording features for busbar and substation applications.
These include:
- Terminal current metering.
- Breaker and disconnector position monitoring.
- Three-phase voltage monitoring.
- Station DC power monitoring.
- Oscillographic event reports.
- Binary COMTRADE event reports.
- Sequential Events Recorder (SER).
These records are valuable when investigating busbar faults, breaker failures, CT problems and unexpected protection operations.
Engineers can use event records to reconstruct the sequence of operations and verify whether the relay responded according to the approved protection design.
13. Communication and substation automation
The SEL-487B offers serial and optional Ethernet communication interfaces.
Depending on the hardware and configuration, supported protocols include:
- SEL ASCII.
- SEL Fast Message.
- SEL Mirrored Bits.
- DNP3.
- FTP.
- Telnet.
- SNTP.
- PRP.
- IEEE 1588 PTPv2.
- IEC 61850 Edition 2.1.
These capabilities allow the relay to be integrated into substation automation systems for monitoring, event collection, control and protection data exchange.
For IEC 61850 projects, the engineer should verify the exact model, communication card, firmware and supported services before preparing the SAS architecture.
14. SEL-487B-2: TiDL and Sampled Values
The SEL-487B product family includes digital secondary system options.
The SEL-487B-2 is available in configurations using SEL Time-Domain Link (TiDL) technology or IEC 61850 Sampled Values (SV).
14.1 TiDL technology
TiDL uses SEL-TMU merging units installed close to primary equipment in the substation yard.
The merging units digitize current and voltage signals and transmit the information over fiber-optic connections to the protection relay.
Key characteristics include:
- Point-to-point fiber connections.
- Remote analog and discrete I/O.
- Reduced copper wiring.
- Synchronized sampling.
- A purpose-built communication architecture.
14.2 IEC 61850 Sampled Values
The Sampled Values option allows the relay to receive digitized current and voltage measurements from compatible merging units over an Ethernet process bus.
The solution uses IEC 61850-9-2 or IEC 61869-9, depending on the supported configuration.
Engineering considerations include:
- Merging-unit compatibility.
- Sampled Values stream configuration.
- Network architecture.
- Time synchronization.
- Redundancy.
- PRP or HSR where supported.
- Network monitoring and failure response.
The TiDL and Sampled Values solutions have different architectures. They should not be treated as interchangeable technologies.
15. Configuration using SEL software
SEL provides software tools for relay settings and engineering.
acSELerator QuickSet
QuickSet can be used to develop settings and program SELogic control equations for supported SEL-487B configurations.
SEL Grid Configurator
SEL Grid Configurator is used for supported digital relay configurations, including TiDL and Sampled Values applications. It provides settings management and engineering features for compatible devices.
A typical engineering workflow includes:
- Confirm the relay model and hardware configuration.
- Review the substation single-line diagram.
- Identify all CT inputs and terminals.
- Define the busbar differential zones.
- Configure breaker and disconnector status inputs.
- Configure dynamic zone selection logic.
- Configure check zones.
- Set differential protection parameters.
- Configure open-CT detection and alarm/blocking behavior.
- Configure breaker-failure logic and timers.
- Configure overcurrent and voltage elements.
- Develop SELogic equations and output logic.
- Configure communication and time synchronization.
- Verify the final settings against the approved design.
Always retain a copy of the original settings and document all changes.
16. SEL-487B testing and commissioning
A complete commissioning program should verify not only individual protection elements but also the complete busbar protection scheme.
16.1 Visual inspection and wiring checks
Before secondary injection:
- Verify relay model and hardware.
- Check auxiliary DC supply.
- Confirm CT wiring and polarity.
- Verify VT wiring and phase sequence.
- Check breaker and disconnector auxiliary contacts.
- Verify trip and retrip circuits.
- Check communication interfaces.
- Confirm approved relay settings.
16.2 Differential protection testing
A suitable relay test set, such as an OMICRON CMC, can be used to verify the differential protection characteristics.
Test cases should include:
- Differential pickup.
- Internal bus fault operation.
- External fault stability.
- Differential zone selection.
- Check-zone operation.
- CT ratio mismatch configuration.
- CT open-circuit detection.
- CT short-circuit detection, using safe and manufacturer-approved procedures.
The test plan should reproduce the actual current-input and zone configuration.
16.3 Dynamic zone selection testing
This is particularly important for double-busbar and complex busbar arrangements.
Test the status combinations for:
- Feeder connected to Bus 1.
- Feeder connected to Bus 2.
- Feeder connected to both buses, where permitted.
- Feeder disconnected from both buses.
- Bus coupler open.
- Bus coupler closed.
- Invalid or contradictory auxiliary contact indications.
- Disconnector status changes during switching.
Confirm that each current input is assigned to the correct differential zone in every permitted operating condition.
16.4 Breaker-failure testing
Verify:
- Breaker-failure initiation.
- Current detector operation.
- Breaker status supervision.
- Timer operation.
- Retrip output.
- Backup trip output.
- Transfer-trip logic, where applicable.
The test should confirm that the breaker-failure scheme operates only under the intended conditions.
16.5 Communication and automation testing
Verify communication with the substation automation system, including:
- Relay status indications.
- Protection alarms.
- Trip indications.
- Breaker and disconnector status.
- Metering values.
- Event records.
- Time synchronization.
- IEC 61850 communication, where installed.
The final commissioning report should include test results, settings, logic checks and any outstanding issues.
17. SEL-487B vs SEL-587Z vs SEL-787Z
SEL provides different solutions for busbar differential protection. The appropriate choice depends on the busbar arrangement, CT design, protection philosophy and project requirements.
| Feature | SEL-487B | SEL-587Z | SEL-787Z |
|---|---|---|---|
| Main protection principle | Low-impedance differential | High-impedance differential | High-impedance differential |
| Typical application | Flexible multi-zone busbar protection | High-impedance busbar protection | High-impedance differential protection |
| CT arrangement | Flexible CT ratios and inputs | Application-specific high-impedance CT circuit | Application-specific high-impedance CT circuit |
| Dynamic zone configuration | Yes | Scheme-dependent | Scheme-dependent |
| Integrated breaker failure | Yes | Model/application-dependent | Model/application-dependent |
| Digital process bus options | TiDL / Sampled Values on SEL-487B-2 | Check product configuration | Check product configuration |
The SEL-487B is particularly suitable for complex busbar arrangements requiring low-impedance differential protection and dynamic zone selection.
High-impedance schemes use a different protection philosophy and have their own CT matching, stability and resistor-sizing requirements. The two approaches should be evaluated against the actual substation design.
18. Advantages of the SEL-487B
Key advantages include:
- High-speed, low-impedance busbar differential protection.
- Flexible protection for multiple bus zones.
- Three independent check zones.
- Dynamic bus-zone configuration.
- Open- and shorted-CT detection.
- CT ratio mismatch capability up to 35:1.
- Integrated breaker-failure protection.
- Backup overcurrent elements.
- Voltage elements for differential supervision.
- Comprehensive event recording and metering.
- Flexible communication and automation options.
- TiDL and Sampled Values options in the SEL-487B-2 family.
19. Frequently asked questions
What is the main application of the SEL-487B?
The SEL-487B is primarily designed for low-impedance busbar differential protection and integrated circuit-breaker failure protection.
How many busbar terminals can one SEL-487B protect?
A single relay can protect up to seven three-phase bus terminals. SEL describes multi-relay arrangements for larger systems, with up to 21 terminals using three relays.
Does the SEL-487B support double-busbar protection?
Yes. Its dynamic zone configuration can assign current inputs to the correct differential zones according to the status of disconnectors and breakers.
What is a check zone?
A check zone provides additional supervision of bus differential protection and helps improve security against incorrect operation caused by problems such as failed or misaligned disconnect auxiliary contacts.
Does the SEL-487B provide breaker-failure protection?
Yes. It includes breaker-failure detection and logic, including retrip capability for each terminal.
Can the SEL-487B use CTs with different ratios?
Yes. SEL specifies that the relay can accommodate CT ratio mismatches up to 35:1 without auxiliary CTs, subject to the application and settings.
Does the SEL-487B support IEC 61850 Sampled Values?
The SEL-487B-2 has configurations for Sampled Values or TiDL technology. Confirm the ordered hardware and applicable documentation before designing the process bus.
Can the SEL-487B be tested using OMICRON CMC?
Yes. A suitable OMICRON CMC test set can be used for secondary injection and functional testing. The test plan must cover differential zones, check zones, CT supervision, breaker-failure logic and the actual substation configuration.
20. Busbar protection training by Elec-Engg
Busbar protection is one of the most demanding areas of power system protection engineering. Engineers must understand not only differential protection principles but also CT circuits, busbar arrangements, zone selection, breaker-failure protection and commissioning procedures.
At Elec-Engg, we provide practical power system protection and substation automation training for protection, commissioning, operation and maintenance engineers.
Our busbar protection training topics include:
- Busbar protection principles.
- High-impedance and low-impedance differential protection.
- CT selection, polarity and secondary circuits.
- Single-busbar, double-busbar and breaker-and-a-half arrangements.
- Dynamic zone selection.
- Check-zone protection.
- Circuit-breaker failure protection.
- SEL-487B and other busbar protection relays.
- Relay testing and commissioning using OMICRON CMC.
Online training can be arranged based on request. Customized training can also be developed around your company’s protection relays, substation drawings and engineering requirements.
https://elec-engg.com/ : more information about practical power system protection courses.
21. Conclusion
The SEL-487B is a powerful solution for low-impedance busbar differential protection and circuit-breaker failure protection. Its flexible differential zones, independent check zones, dynamic zone configuration and CT supervision make it suitable for a wide range of substation busbar arrangements.
For protection engineers, the most important aspects are understanding the busbar topology, designing reliable zone-selection logic, verifying CT circuits, configuring breaker-failure protection and performing comprehensive commissioning tests.
A well-engineered busbar protection scheme using the SEL-487B can improve substation protection security, reduce fault-clearing time and support reliable power-system operation.
